Skip to main content

tv   Anderson Cooper 360  CNN  March 28, 2012 10:00pm-11:00pm EDT

10:00 pm
"ac 360" starts right now. thanks, piers. we begin with breaking news. our first look at george zimmerman in police custody the night that trayvon martin was killed. zimmerman is claiming he fired in self-defense, that trayvon martin came up behind him, decked him with a single punch in the face and began slamming his head on the ground. his father said that was bs. the family has always questioned zimmerman's version. now we have direct evidence of zimmerman's condition for the first time. you can decide whether the man in the video looks like someone who minutes before had been in a fight for his life. this police surveillance video first shown tonight on "abc world news" begins with george zimmerman being taken out of a patrol car at sanford police headquarters. he's wearing the same red jacket and blue jeans that he was wearing when he came across trayvon martin. who is on his way home from the 7/11 with a bag of skittles and an iced tea. now, the police report says he was bleeding from the nose and back of the head and was examined by emts at the scene before being taken in for questioning.
10:01 pm
attorney sonner says he believes that martin broke zimmerman's nose. we have frozen a portion of the video showing his nose and face so you can look more carefully and see if it's consistent with the kind of fight that zimmerman describes. granted, it's surveillance video. it's not up close and the lighting is not good and the angle obviously could be better. but it's full of clues. here the officer touches zimmerman's sleeve and a few minutes later wipes off his hand. is it blood? that's a question. and then you see here the officer looks at the back of zimmerman's head. he takes a good look at it. he's clearly looking at something. the question, though, is he looking at the kind of injury that comes from somebody slamming someone's head repeatedly into concrete. let's wait for him to look. there he is looking. now, the officer takes a second look and now so can you.
10:02 pm
finally, zimmerman is taken inside for questioning. we've slowed down the video here so you can take another longer look at zimmerman's face, his head, whether there's blood on his clothing, grass stains even on the back of his jacket. remember, abc news and a local media reporting that a lead investigator that night did not buy zimmerman's story. he wanted to file manslaughter charges but was overruled by the state's attorney. tonight you can see at least a hint of what he saw that night. in addition abc news spoke to trayvon martin's girl friend about the conversation. he said he was walking fast when he says this man behind him again. he come and says -- and say this dude look like he about to do something to him. she went on to say, and then trayvon said the man is still behind him and then i come and say, run. she also said that he was scared. trayvon said this dude looked creepy, he crazy.
10:03 pm
joining me is director of the private security group. thanks very much. i guess you looking at this surveillance tape, what do you see in terms of the police procedures? bringing him in, did everything look normal? >> he was obviously in a state of arrest. i didn't observe any dramatic physical injuries. if he complained of some, i would suspect specially a broken nose, anderson, that the law enforcement agency would have offered him some medical treatment, an emergency room, for example. but i hate to say it in this fashion but the injuries to this individual to me are almost academic at this point because i think if you look at the timeline from when zimmerman contacted the police through 911 and they basically instructed him to stand down and they continued to precipitate contact with this young man and the statement and recording of -- with his girlfriend, trayvon with his girlfriend, he precipitated this. this young man didn't know who
10:04 pm
he was. the reality of the situation is, zimmerman had no authority to approach him, period. he's not a sworn law enforcement, he didn't have anything to identify him as such. why would anyone just randomly comply with anyone approaching him? >> he had no training, not even in uniform. >> no training, no experience, no identification. and he wasn't licensed to carry the weapon in this capacity. what people don't understand, in florida, you may have a license to carry a concealed weapon. it's a very liberal state. the minute you want to carry that weapon in a capacity of employment, you're required to have another license. and in the neighborhood watch, under whose authority did he do this? and quite frankly, if anyone is questioning whether there was anything that precipitated this,
10:05 pm
you must need to have your head examined. >> his lawyer told us he believed zimmerman had broken his nose and by the time he was actually taken to an emergency room, the wound on the back of his head, which the lawyer said would have needed stitches, had actually begun to heal so they didn't actually put in any stitches. in that video, though, again, it's not good video. it's not a great angle. the lighting's not good. you don't see any indication of blood. >> i saw the video in the waiting room where i was far closer to it than i am in proximity right now and i did not see any injuries consistent with this alleged struggle that took place. and the other problem he has is that he's alleging that this young man jumped him from behind when there's nothing consistent with the timeline for that evening that would support that. >> the fact that a lead investigator on the case wanted charges to be brought, what does that tell you? >> that someone was on the ball. he looked a not thing and he realized that this guy
10:06 pm
had used what we consider to be excessive force and he knew that was problematic and he was on the money there, as we all know in hindsight right now. the law enforcement agency dropped the ball on this. actually, the state attorney or investigator. >> right. because the police turned it over to the state attorney to see if charges would finally be brought. >> exactly. >> this is the first video that we've been able to see of george zimmerman from that night. thank you for coming in. >> my pleasure. >> always good to talk to you. >> we want to get some legal perspective on this, also joining us, obviously jose baez won an acquittal in the casey anthony trial. also, marcia clark is joining us. marcia, this video, the first time we are seeing george zimmerman. no one wants to make any rush to judgment. there's still a lot we don't know about the facts of this case. looking at the footage as you see it, does anything jump out to you? >> well, i have to agree with your former guest, mr. columbo.
10:07 pm
i don't see any injuries in this tape, with all of the caveats. regarding angle and lighting and the distance, et cetera. nevertheless, the injuries described by george zimmerman that made it sound as really he should have been on a stretcher are not apparent in this tape at all. he moves freely. he moves fluidly, not someone that has just been through a beating in any way, shape or form. someone whose head has been pounded in the way he described, this is someone that requires immediate treatment. police, when they see somebody in that kind of extreme or trouble, the first thing they do, if only for their own protection, is make sure medical treatment is given because otherwise they can be held accountable for any aggravated injuries that occur as a result of him not being treated for his injuries. it's very significant that, a, he didn't demand medical treatment and, b, the police didn't see a need for it either. that tells you a great deal, even with the angle and lighting
10:08 pm
as such that we see right now on the surveillance tape doesn't give you anything. the actions and manner in which this man was treated, his injuries tell you that his injuries could not have been that significant. >> jose, as a defense attorney looking at this tape, what do you see? >> i don't think you can tell much from this tape. this is an after-the-fact situation where at the scene he was spoken to. he might have been cleaned up there. we don't know the extent of what occurred at the scene. whether he was actually looked at by emt. if he was, he was cleaned and put in cuffs and taken away. how often do you see someone get knocked out, perhaps in a boxing match and walk back to the dressing room. this does not tell you much. >> lou, if the report had been that his head was banged multiple times -- we don't know if it was on the grass or ground or sidewalk, he seems to be walking pretty fine. again, we don't know the time line. we don't know how many hours after the incident or minutes after the incident this is. you wanted to make a point? >> well, obviously if the police
10:09 pm
arrived on the scene and saw him in a battered condition, with the broken nose which would have been consistent with profused bleeding, lacerations or contusions to the head, they would have transported him. or suggested it. marcia clark made a very good point. procedurally what we do if you refuse to seek medical treatment, we would make note that you did so so we further insulated ourselves. she's right. if we mishandle someone's injury and god forbid they expire, we end up in wrongful death and under the spotlight. but i don't think there was anything consistent with this individual's injuries from start to finish that lent itself to his story. i think he bit off more than he could chew and was trying to figure out how he was going to employ damage control. >> marcia, is this a tape that would find its way into a trial if there was a trial? >> oh, yeah. most definitely. anderson, this tape, in my opinion, is very impeaching. yes, you can say it was after the fact and other things may have happened. but there is going to be some indication that he refused medical treatment.
10:10 pm
i'd like to see all of the police reports. the jury will certainly hear what was written in the police reports but the manner in which he's moving, the manner in which the police is handling him would be extremely important to show that he was not beaten. that he was lying when he said he was beaten as badly as he was, if indeed he is lying. it's very important proof that you can get there. we'll see what ultimately happens with it. in the very beginning when this case broke, a lot of us believed, including myself, that police had dropped the ball, let this thing go, had not pursued all of the procedures to seek his arrest. in fact, they did. it came out now that we now that a police officer, the lead investigator said we don't believe him. his story doesn't make sense and wanted to pursue a case against him. so i think that as the information unfolds, we have to leave our minds open to the possibility that what we thought in the beginning of this case is not the way it's going to ultimately develop. >> and, again, it argues for not rushing to judge on either side of this. obviously still photos would
10:11 pm
have been taken by police officers, right? >> well, obviously at the crime scene there would have been still photography. they would have ripped it off -- they would have roped it off and -- >> would they have taken photos of george zimmerman? >> not necessarily. if he was placed under arrest and formally charged, they would have taken photographs of him. the thing that is interesting and i don't have a full grasp of the laws of the state of florida,. they should have charged him with murder because you can always back off that charge. when they charge him with manslaughter, it's a little gray unto itself. as if it might have been an accidental shooting. that resulted in his death. >> that's what the lead investigator suggested. i want to hear from jose baez in just a second. we have to take a break, though. a lot more to talk about. coming up, we'll be joined by the reporter who broke this story and spoke directly to trayvon martin's girlfriend. let me know what you think about this tape.
10:12 pm
more on this ahead. we'll be right back. all energy development comes with some risk, but proven technologies allow natural gas producers to supply affordable, cleaner energy, while protecting our environment. across america, these technologies protect air - by monitoring air quality and reducing emissions... ...protect water - through conservation and self-contained recycling systems... ... and protect land - by reducing our footprint and respecting wildlife. america's natural gas...
10:13 pm
domestic, abundant, clean energy to power our lives... that's smarter power today. on december 21st, polar shifts will reverse the earth's gravitational pull and hurtle us all into space, which would render retirement planning unnecessary. but say the sun rises on december 22nd and you still need to retire, td ameritrade's investment consultants can help you build a plan that fits your life. we'll even throw in up to $600
10:14 pm
when you open a new account or roll over an old 401(k). so who's in control now, mayans? recapping our breaking news tonight, we're getting our first look at george zimmerman in police custody the night he shot trayvon martin. shown first tonight on abc world news, you can see zimmerman getting out of a police squad car. his hands are cuffed behind his back. he's wearing the red jacket that
10:15 pm
we've heard so much about. a jacket that did not identify him as a neighborhood watch volunteer. it's the first look we have had of him that night. it's the first opportunity we've had to judge for ourselves if he looks like a man who was beaten in what he described as a fight for his life. trayvon martin's parents have always questioned zimmerman's version of what happened in the moments before he was killed and we've frozen a portion of the video showing his face and nose. he said trayvon punched him into the nose and slammed his head into the ground. we don't know if it was the sidewalk or the grass or what. the police report said he was bleeding from his nose and the back of the head. he was examined by emts at the scene. you can see the officer touching zimmerman's sleeve and then wiping something off. we're not clear what he's going to be wiping off here.
10:16 pm
the quality of the video is far from ideal. the lighting, angle could obviously be better. he then appears to check the back of zimmerman's head, or the back of zimmerman. and then you can see he does the same -- we've frozen this portion of the video. remember, zimmerman told police that trayvon martin slammed his head into the ground after punching him so forcefully that it knocked him down. finally, zimmerman is taken inside for questioning. we've slowed down the video so you can take a longer look at his face, his head, whether you see any signs of blood on his clothing or grass stains on his clothing. trayvon's family doesn't believe zimmerman's family. he calls the language here bs. >> he said that trayvon hit him, knocked him to the ground, got on top of him, put his knees on arms and pinned him down. put his hand -- put his
10:17 pm
left hand over his mouth, told him shut the "f" up. and proceeded to beat him with the other hand. zimmerman said -- then says, trayvon was -- i mean, zimmerman was able to unholster his weapon and fire one shot and trayvon fell back and said, you got me. >> tonight we have potential clues in this tape. joining me by phone is matt gutman who got hold of the tape. matt, you also talked to the woman -- the young woman who spoke to trayvon martin on the phone moments before the shooting. what is the most important thing that she told you were? >> she seems to tell a different version than what mr. zimmerman told police. she was on the phone with him, 7:12 p.m. and he was trying to run away from george zimmerman. he talks about this crazy
10:18 pm
looking man behind him, this white dude chasing him. he starts running away. he thought he lost zimmerman. but then she heard, this guy is on my tail again. he says, this guy is on my tail again. zimmerman says, what are you doing here and the next thing she hears is a scuffle breaking out, the phone falling to the grass, and then it went dead. she never heard from him again. so her version seems to contradict pretty significantly from what mr. zimmerman said. it seemed impossible for martin to turn around and attack him, knocking him out and then as you mentioned slamming his head on the ground. >> you got hold of this surveillance tape. have you been told anything by police or from any sources about any injuries that george zimmerman may have had or allegedly had? because we've heard prior reports -- go ahead. >> the only thing we really know
10:19 pm
about zimmerman's injuries were from his attorney, craig sonner who said that his nose was broken, back of his head was bloody. there was similar information on the police report -- the original police report that night. but we never knew the extent of his injuries. we also knew that he never checked into the hospital. he never required stitches for the back of the head. now we can see why because you look at that video and we think we've been able to make out a little bit of a welt on the back of his head but certainly your assessment of this is correct. it doesn't look like someone that was beaten to an inch of his life, or beaten so significantly that he needed to draw his weapon. >> matt gutman, i appreciate you calling in. matt broke the story with the videotape -- first to get this videotape. once again, joining us is criminal defense attorney jose baez and marcia clark and lou a palumbo.
10:20 pm
in terms of what matt said, that you might be able to see a welt on the back of the head, how important do you think this tape will be in any potential trial? >> well, i think the prosecutor would certainly use something like that i think is certainly well after the fact. this is subsequent to him receiving treatment from emt. what's really important here is under the law you actually don't have to sustain these type of injuries. you just have to fear death or great bodily harm. you don't actually have to have great bodily harm to use deadly force in this scenario. so i don't think -- first of all, legally it doesn't seem to be highly relevant. however, it does become relevant if you're trying to prove a circumstantial set of facts. however, you have to take it with a grain of salt, this is well after the incident and after he's well enough to go to the police department. actually, sustaining these types of injuries it's not required under the law.
10:21 pm
>> it bears repeating again, we don't know the full details of what happened from the time george zimmerman got out of the vehicle until the time that trayvon martin was shot. we have different eyewitness reports. we don't know exactly what happened yet. but jose raises an interesting point that so much of this case, if it becomes a legal case, what will hinge on what was in george zimmerman's mind? what was in trayvon martin's mind? what was their perceptions? did george zimmerman fear for his life rightly or wrongly but did he have that fear in his mind? those are all things that are very difficult to try to determine in a court of law, you know? >> well, you know, if you're going to look at it in a very literal sense, it's difficult. but when you look at all of the other evidence, it's less difficult. for example, you have two interestingly corroborating pieces of information. number one thing, anderson, you have the 911 call by george
10:22 pm
zimmerman in which the police ask, are you following him? or he admits that he's following. they say, don't follow him. then you have the girlfriend who gives an account that seems to actually corroborate that 911 tape. the girlfriend says this guy's following me and why does he keep following me and, look, he's tailing me again. and when you put these two things together and apparently in the 911 tape, george zimmerman admits he was following trayvon martin. so now you have two pieces of evidence that corroborate each other showing that george zimmerman was very likely the attacker, was likely the provocateur. and under the law you are not allowed to break a law and then claim self-defense. in california at least, if you do provoke a fight, you cannot use self-defense until you have retreat and given up and tried to calm matters and said you're going to lay down arms and not going to fight and then the other person launches an attack. this is not what happened here
10:23 pm
according to anyone's account. including george zimmerman's. george zimmerman is saying that trayvon martin attacked him but none of the evidence seems to indicate that trayvon martin was the initiator. all of it, not little pieces, seem to go to the fact that george zimmerman was the initiator. >> we see george zimmerman in handcuffs. does that indicate that was he arrested? >> yes, he's in a state of arrest. not just when your handcuffed but when the law enforcement deprives your right of free movement, you're under a state of arrest. the thing i want to mention that is likely relevant in this case, deals with the distance that the weapon was discharged from trayvon martin. in other words, if a struggle ensued and the weapon is pressed up against the body of the individual who is shooting is burn marks. forensics can prove unequivocally the distance in which a weapon was discharged from a person. >> and the angle of the bodies at the time that the weapon was discharged as well. >> absolutely. and that's part of the information that i'm curious that the police department has not been more forthcoming with. i'm curious to know how far he
10:24 pm
was when the weapon was fired. >> jose, a viewer sent something in to us about a florida statute. 776-032, says expressly prohibits police from arresting someone who had a reasonable fear of great bodily harm. police may investigate but the agency may not place that person -- arrest that person without probable cause. is that true? do you know about that? >> well, obviously every arrest has to be -- they have to have probable cause. that's a huge part of what's going on here. you have a law enforcement agency and a state attorney that has established that they don't have enough evidence to reach the level of probable cause. how in the world are you going to get to beyond a reasonable doubt in a situation that happened probably under 60 seconds. >> but if they've arrested him there, they felt they had probable cause to arrest him, no? >> they had enough probable cause to detain him. there is no such thing as unarrest for certain cases.
10:25 pm
but in this case they had enough to detain him, investigate it further and at the end of the day after they had investigated all they could at that moment, they made the determination that they did not have probable cause. and what's interesting here, law enforcement doesn't need to call a prosecutor to make an arrest in this situation. they felt very uneasy that they were actually were going to release him and to just cover a cya type of situation. they had someone second off on it which was an actual prosecutor on call. so i think not only did they make a decision after thoroughly analyzing it, you -- they went ahead and got a second opinion. now you have political pressure, the president speaking about the case and you have the governor pulling the prosecutor off the case and putting on a special prosecution, i just don't see a conviction down the line here. i really don't. and to touch on something marcia
10:26 pm
said earlier, i distinctly remember hearing on the 911 tape george zimmerman saying, he's now walking towards me and he looks like he has something around his waistband. so there's some conflicting stories here. >> yeah, there's definitely -- >> either way you look at it. so it's really -- we're microanalyzing this, but, remember, this is a decision george zimmerman had to make in a split second and to go back and second guess it, it's something that george zimmerman didn't have. >> some say it's a decision he chose to make by following trayvon martin if in fact that's what he did. again, a lot of the facts simply aren't known. jose baez, appreciate you being on, marcia clark and lou palumbo. we'll be talking to senator john mccain up ahead. until she heard about the value plan.
10:27 pm
dollar for dollar, nobody protects you like allstate. chocolate lemonade ? susie's lemonade... the movie. or... we make it pink ! with these 4g lte tablets, you can do business at lightning-fast speeds. we'll take all the strawberries, dave. you got it, kid. we have a winner. we're definitely gonna need another one. small businesses that want to grow use 4g lte technology from verizon. i wonder how she does it. that's why she's the boss. because the small business with the best technology rules. contact the verizon center for customers with disabilities at 1-800-974-6006. impact wool exports from new zealand, textile production in spain, and the use of medical technology in the u.s.? at t. rowe price, we understand the connections of a complex, global economy. it's just one reason over 75% of our mutual funds beat their 10-year lipper average. t. rowe price. invest with confidence. request a prospectus or summary prospectus
10:28 pm
with investment information, risks, fees and expenses to read and consider carefully before investing.
10:29 pm
10:30 pm
another keeping them honest. a new call for action to stop the killing the action. bashar al assad has asked the killing to stop and has the power to stop the slaughter he's already promised to stop on more than one occasion and just recently as yesterday and no surprise he's not stopping. john mccain said the killing and lies have gone on too long. >> again, i've asked the question, how many have to die, how many have to die before the united states will take a leadership role in trying to end the mass slaughter taking place in syria. the people of syria need to know that we in america are on their side. it matters to them. it matters to them to know that
10:31 pm
we are on their side and we are willing to assist him. >> we'll talk to senator mccain in a moment. he and some of the colleagues are calling on president obama to help speed the flow of weapons to opposition forces, today like every day, it was deadly dangerous to be a civilian in syria. the video purports to show a sniper attack on protesters in aleppo. the marchers got to the intersection and gunmen on the roof turned it into sniper. we don't know who are dead or wounded. at least 26 people were killed today all across syria. reports of 9,000 since the uprising began a year ago. shelling and gun fire reported today in aleppo, in daraa, and homs.
10:32 pm
the assad regime accepted a peace plan that included a cease-fire. the assad regime included a cease fire and not only is assad breaking his commitment today he was already making a mockery of it on day one. the same day that he toured the neighborhood in homs, the same forces under his control were shelling other parts of the city. stopping only briefly while propaganda visit played out. senator john mccain has seen the videos. he says he's seen enough. we spoke to him earlier tonight. >> senator mccain, you were on this program three weeks ago calling for the united states in cooperation with the international community to have air strikes against the bashar regime and now you're asking congress to condemn syria and push the white house to take concrete action to support the opposition. do you have any optimism that your resolution is actually going to have an impact? >> well, i hope so, anderson. and previous experience in
10:33 pm
bosnia, kosovo, libya, that with enough pressure that perhaps the united states and other countries will react in a similar fashion but several more have been massacred, women raped, children maimed by this incredibly cruel and barbaric regime. so i think we will get some progress but unfortunately i don't know how many thousands more have to die before we do that. >> yesterday the assad regime say they accepted the six-point peace plan. there have been so many laws by this regime, so many red herrings and diplomatic feints. they say one thing and doing something else on the ground. do you have any belief that the regime will live up to their end of the bargain this time? >> i do not. and by the way, they made the same commitment to the u.n. a couple months ago and didn't do it.
10:34 pm
since kofi annan's announcement that they had had accepted that proposal, they crossed over into lebanon and killed more people. there's nothing that you and i would love to see more than the cease-fire. notice, the u.n. plan does not call for bashar al assad for stepping down. that has been the position for the united states and literally every other nation. but the point is so far there has been no sign that there has been any adherence to that at all. and finally can i say that when kofi annan says that we have to have this agreement because they don't want to militarize the situation, that was his words, where has he been? >> it's well beyond that point. >> absolutely. >> two other quick questions. one of syria's key allies is russia. you're critical of the russian government on multiple fronts. you've also criticized president
10:35 pm
obama's off-mic comments to russia's president this week about president obama having more flexibility if he's re-elected. that's what he said off mic. you say that the president is playing fast and loose with national security. that's a tough charge. do you really think the president is putting politics over american safety? >> well, he referred specifically to political aspect of his presidency and that is his re-election. he said that he's going to be, quote, more flexible. no one could interpret that in any way except to say that he would be willing to compromise from the position that the united states of america has adhered to through several administrations and the way he reached out to sort of show president medvedev that he's going to -- you know, wink, w k wink, nod, nod. and then, of course, medvedev says that he will pass that on to vladimir and then interfering in american politics and decides
10:36 pm
to criticize governor romney. so, look, missile defense is as important part and a cornerstone of american foreign policy. it is defensive in nature. there's no reason to be flexible any more than the present policy which has been that of several administrations, both democrat and republican. >> one political question. i know you voted against the president's health care bill but there's also no love lost between you and the supreme court. they overturned a key part of your campaign finance bill. you call their actions on that a combination of arrogance, fly -- naivete and stupidity. the feeling of a lot of legal analysts seems to be that they toss out the mandate portion of health reform. would you welcome that? and if that were to happen, could that work out against republicans, giving them one last thing to run on in the fall? >> i don't think so, anderson.
10:37 pm
first of all, i'm not sure as some people seem to be that by the nature of the questioning that means a supreme court justice is going to take one side or the other. you know that they like to ask provocative questions and they should. so i'm not -- i don't share the confidence but some do. second of all, i think that this was one of the signature legislative accomplishments, end quote, of the obama administration and we argued that it was unconstitutional at the time. so if that's substantiated by the united states supreme court, i don't see how that could possibly help the president politically. i've seen a number of his minions spinning it the other way but i just don't see that. >> senator mccain, thank you for your time, sir. >> thanks for having me. in other news, a school in montana is facing serious allegations of abuse. its religious status exempts it
10:38 pm
from licensing requirements and state overstatement and some say that puts students in danger. we'll have a 360 investigation in a moment. ah, welcome to hotels.com. i get it...guys weekend. yeah! if you're looking for a place to get together, you came to the right place. because here at hotels.com, we're only about hotels.
10:39 pm
yeah! yeah! noooo. yeah! finding you the perfect place is all we do. welcome to hotels.com the healthcare law gives us powerful tools to fight it... to investigate it... ...prosecute it... and stop criminals. our senior medicare patrol volunteers... are teaching seniors across the country... ...to stop, spot, and report fraud.
10:40 pm
you can help. guard your medicare card. don't give out your card number over the phone. call to report any suspected fraud. we're cracking down on medicare fraud. let's make medicare stronger for all of us.
10:41 pm
tonight, part two of our report on disturbing allegations at a religious school in montana. it's part of our ungodly discipline series. the school has been operating for decades beyond the state authorities. it's all perfectly legal but the question is, is the lack of oversight safe for the students? we'll let you decide. here's part two of gary
10:42 pm
tuchman's investigation. >> reporter: bob larsson is a christian preacher and founder of the pinehaven children's ranch in montana. >> i was raised that way, i don't know if you were. clean up your plate. don't waste anything. >> reporter: there are about 40 children and teenagers at the ranch right now. some have troubled pasts, others have troubled families. >> and they know when they come, they sign a form of acceptance for coming. that says, i understand this is a christian program. i do believe in god. i believe jesus is the son of god and the bible is the word of god and i have no objection to being taught along those lines. >> reporter: but many former students have objections to what they recall as physical abuse at the ranch. >> choking was to be expected at some point. nerves under my chin when i went into the marine corps were dead.
10:43 pm
>> reporter: a former student says one of bob larson's employees -- >> picked me up dun this section of throat here and lifted me up and slammed me down on the kitchen table and basically held me down and told me that i was a drug addict and i was never going to amount to anything. >> reporter: some former employees of the ranch say they witnessed abuse. >> i know it caused extreme pain because the kids were wrenching and screaming because of the pain of what had happened. >> reporter: bob larson says satan is behind the dozen or so teachers and students. >> i'm not perfect and the bible says you can expect this to happen. >> reporter: some of them accused is long-time employee and house employee, ned kent. some of the kids who are now adults tell us that you used to choke them. >> that's totally false.
10:44 pm
>> reporter: what is it that you did to them? >> used pressure points to restrain them but -- >> what does that mean? >> you have places on your body where nerve endings are close. >> reporter: show me on my body. >> right here. show me on my -- >> right there. >> reporter: ned claims he does not do it anymore but who are the authorities who are responsible for checking out such allegations? let's tell you a little bit more. it's unregulated, unlicensed, unaccredited, teachers uncertified by the state of montana. they're required to oversee public and private schools, but not religious schools. so who oversees pinehaven, pinehaven oversees pinehaven. who is responsible to make sure that the kids are good and the counselors are good? and the kids behave? >> i am. >> reporter: he says he has it licensed out of state but not in montana which is one of many states where the government has no oversight of religious schools. the montana legislature considered a bill to require oversight but the former
10:45 pm
state legislator fought the attempt to regulate pinehaven. >> the truth is, i did not know the breadth and depth of what was going on. >> reporter: but now she's trying to get the legislature to reverse that vote because she believes pinehaven has indeed abused children. >> that doesn't sound very christian to me. >> reporter: bob larsson denies abuse of his students, but acknowledges unpleasant moments in the past. a former employee was accused of raping two underaged students. he pled guilty and went to prison. could they help to prevent ordeal with other horrifying situations, such as this one? james mason says he was sodomized by a fellow student. >> i was raped. i've never told anybody that. he threatened me with fencing
10:46 pm
pliers to my throat and testicles if i were to ever tell anybody. >> reporter: this is a former student who says he was also raped by a former pinehaven student. >> i started cutting myself. i stole some wire from the shop we were working in and i started to cut my iner in thighs because that's the only place that wouldn't show. i just cut and cut and cut because it's the only thing -- pain -- physical pain felt better than the mental pain that i was going through. >> reporter: two years ago, a sheriff's office detective in lake county, montana, investigated abuse allegations against pinehaven. no charges were filed but the case files indicate one alleged victim was interviewed. we talked to the detective's boss, sheriff dave doyle. he was elected sheriff after the case was closed. >> it can be reopened. there are alleged victims out there that may or may not come forward. if they wish to come forward and report a crime, we look into it.
10:47 pm
>> reporter: what will be wrong if the state of montana looked over this school? >> because it is an arm of the church, it would be unconstitutional. >> do you see it would make some people breathe easier, perhaps some parents. >> send their kids somewhere else. they don't have to send them here. >> gary joins us now. i mean, he's correct. parents don't have to send their kids there. it's not really a great defense, though. >> right. there is -- it is a real statement. it's true. but there are certainly kids we talk to during this investigation who say while they were there, they were not allowed to make phone calls to their parents describing what was happening. also there's a woman we talked to who has a child there today and this woman want her child out of pinehaven. that's the subject of part three of our investigation, and i want to show a snippet of that right now. >> reporter: paula bowen says without her permission her daughter cassie was whisked away to more than 1800 miles to the pinehaven
10:48 pm
christian ranch. that's where we met her. >> reporter: what's your name? >> cassie. >> reporter: where are you from? she says she wants her daughter home but cassie is not being allowed to leave. >> so why isn't she being allowed to leave? >> reporter: basically, a true -- a truant officer in illinois recommended to a judge that cassie go to montana. and that truant officer, he tells us this, he sent 29 children over the years from that small area in illinois to montana. so basically that small town in illinois is a pipeline to pinehaven. >> fascinating story. we'll look at that more tomorrow night. gary, appreciate that. bizarre stories involving a jetblue pilot who caused chaos. new information about how he was acting, what he was was talking about before passengers subdued him. we'll see it right there.
10:49 pm
sergio! christina! question for you. what factors led you to buy your explorer. definitely the ecoboost option. what's pretty amazing is that you can get the fuel economy of a car in an suv. that basically did it for us. and the technology... oh, my goodness, the technology is amazing. everything is touch. you can actually talk to the car and it talks back to you. what have your friends said about your explorer? can we drive it? can we borrow it? what's your answer? no. no way. uh uh. (laugh) nno matter what you do. when you're living with moderate to severe crohn's disease,
10:50 pm
there are times it feels like your life... revolves around your symptoms. if you're tired of going around in circles, it may be time to ask your gastroenterologist about humira. because with humira, remission is possible. humira has been proven to work for adults who have tried other medications... but still experience the symptoms of moderate to severe crohn's disease. in clinical studies, the majority of patients on humira saw significant symptom relief. and many achieved remission. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal events, such as infections, lymphoma, or other types of cancer, have happened. blood, liver and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure have occurred. before starting humira, your doctor should test you for tb. ask your doctor if you live in or have been to a region where certain fungal infections are common. tell your doctor if you have had tb, hepatitis b,
10:51 pm
are prone to infections, or have symptoms such as fever, fatigue, cough, or sores. you should not start humira if you have any kind of infection. if you're tired of going around in circles, get headed in a new direction. ask your gastroenterologist about humira today. remission is possible. the sleep number bed. the magic of this bed is that you're sleeping on something that conforms to your individual shape. wow! that feels really good. it's hugging my body. in less than a minute i can get more support. if you change your mind once you get home you can adjust it. so whatever you feel like, the sleep number bed's going to provide it for you. at our semi-annual sleep sale, save $400 to $700 on our most popular bed sets. sale ends march 31st. only at the sleep number store, where queen mattresses start at just $699.
10:52 pm
will be giving away passafree copies of the alcoholism & addiction cure. to get yours, go to ssagesmalibubook.com. i'm isha sesay with the news bulletin. new details about the jetblue flight that was diverted because a pilot was act be erratically. a criminal complaint said as the plane was taking off, he we're not going to vegas. passengers said he was banging on the cockpit door and shouting about jesus, 9/11 and terrorists before he was subdued. he has been suspended and is getting medical treatment. he could face prison time on charges of interfering with a flight crew. there's already a fight over
10:53 pm
tim tebow going to the new york jets. nike selling reebok for selling the clothing with his name on it. and they said their company allowed to use its name on clothing. and how many planets have the potential to support life? you want to guess the number, anderson? tens of billions. back to you. the mega millions jackpot is up to millions tonight. but don't bother playing, because we're sure we'll will it. "the ridiculist" is up next. to roll over my old 401(k) into a fidelity ira. man: okay, no problem. it's easy to get started; i can help you with the paperwork. um...this green line just appeared on my floor. yeah, that's fidelity helping you reach your financial goals. could you hold on a second?
10:54 pm
it's your money. roll over your old 401(k) into a fidelity ira and take control of your personal economy. this is going to be helpful. call or come in today. fidelity investments. turn here. cannot be contained. [ clang ] the all-new 2013 lexus gs. there's no going back. see your lexus dealer. [♪...] >> announcer: with nothing but his computer, an identity thief is able to use your information to open a bank account in order to make your money his money. [whoosh, clang] you need lifelock, the only
10:55 pm
identity theft protection company that now monitors bank accounts for takeover fraud. lifelock: relentlessly protecting your identity. call 1-800-lifelock or go to lifelock.com today. [ male announcer ] this is lois. the day starts with arthritis pain... a load of new listings... and two pills. after a morning of walk-ups, it's back to more pain, back to more pills. the evening showings bring more pain and more pills. sealing the deal... when, hang on... her doctor recommended aleve. it can relieve pain all day with fewer pills than tylenol. this is lois... who chose two aleve and fewer pills for a day free of pain. [ female announcer ] and try aleve for relief from tough headaches.
10:56 pm
10:57 pm
time now for "the ridiculist" and tonight we're adding the mega millions lottery. because clearly, that thing is rigged. it's the only logical conclusion given that we did not last night. that's right. like so many other people in the 42 states where you can play mega millions, the 360 staff caught a ripping case of lottery fever. we pooled our money to buy a whole mess of tickets for the $363 million jackpot. there were a few hold outs, that person who reminds us that we have a better chance of being killed in a vending machine accident but almost alof us -- all of us chipped in $5.
10:58 pm
for the record, i put in $10, $5 for me and five for isha. i'd ask for it back but i don't want a pocket pull of pens or half penny or bob or whatever they have over there, the point is, somehow we did not win. nobody did, actually. now it's up to $500 million for friday's drawing. i don't know if we'll play again. we're all frankly still reeling from the shock and disappointment. i felt really good about our chances. technically, yes, you are more likely to die due to melting pajamas. we lose so many people like that. >> you have to be in it to win it. >> you're in it how many times some. >> 23. >> i hope somebody that we need wins the money. >> this is a lucky store. >> it's early retirement. >> it's more money than you can spend and you can even imagine. >> see, none of those people won either. but it could be worse. you could have thought that you won the millions and then found out it was a big mistake.
10:59 pm
that's what happened to hundreds of people who played in denmark, including this guy. 300 people were told they won $50 billion and then they got an e-mail saying you actually only got 50 bucks. the lottery blames human error. they might have sent those people an e-mail that said, easy come, easy go. then just a gigantic clip art middle finger. what is it that draws us to the lottery, the odds, think about it, you have a better chance of becoming an athlete, a president of the united states or a saint. but it's all about dreaming. it's about optimism in the face of mathematical improbability. i never did good in math anyway. you have a better chance of seeing a ufo today. i don't mean ever, i mean today than winning the mega millions. but with a record breaking $550 million, most people don't want to take that risk of splashing around in a sad little puddle that used to be the office pool.

78 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on