tv Lou Dobbs Tonight FOX Business July 10, 2013 10:00pm-11:01pm EDT
doctor, insurer, health care and lower your cost. again, this starts monday. thank you for joining us, we will see you back here tomorrow. lou: good evening, everybody, thank you for being with us. cheers erupting inside the house republican caucus meetingon immigration. speaker john boehner and republican leadership confirming late today the house of reesentativewill not be taking up the senate passed gang of eight immigration bill. commerce and darrell issa reporting to fox that the said bill will not see the light of day in the house of representatives. >> it was not a wel well-thought approach in the senate, the reason the senate bill has is little chance, no chance of being considered here, however
we are looking at what to do with 11 million people we had lou: after tling fox business the gang of seven bill is "all done," just not public. they gang of seven bill would not be discussed in the meeting. the house republicans have now succeeded in taking up national leadership on ises of migration and border security. the white house efforts into: friday senate bill obviously failing as the president plotted his latest strategy with democratic members of the congressional hispanic caucus. today trying to help a way forward releasing a report showing a broad coalition and major economic benefits from the gang of eight now dead proposal. council of economic advisors made a point of naming some
prominent republicanswho he said agree with the president's approach. >> it reflects a widesprea bipartisan agement, so for example people like grover norquist, former vice presidential candidate, former republican president george bush, all of them aee th the administration on the basic premise comprehensive common sense immigration reform wille good for economic growth. lou: president george bush reemerged in the public arena today after remaining largely out of public view sinche left ofce. mr. sh try to offer a helping hand to his frustrated successor in the white house. >> we have a problem. the laws governing immigration system aren't working. the system is broken.
we are now in an important debate reforming those laws. and that is good. i don't tend to get involved in the politics or the specifics of policy, but i doope there is a positive resolution to the debate. lou: president obama's press secretary jay carney taking a different approach today essentiallblaming his bosses support for the gang of eight bill and the house's reluctance to hold a vote. >> i know it annoys them that he is in office, let's just accept that. but this isn't about him. the reason why we have the progress we have se is in no small measure because of the support the presidenhas put behind immigration reform of the advocacy he engaged in
throughout e campaign and throughout his first term, but it is not about him. >> it is not about him, although it was about him, but the communications department at the white house struggling with the language, most americans learned last year's possession campaign conservatism to prevail, far more than a balanced budget. conservatism has to be about far less government and both president obama and his predecessors created. to prevail on the issue for washington conservatives must have better ideas, stronger principals and courage than the ft. they must embrace the national interest, not imitate liberals and their proposals. today the house republican leadership demonstrated that they are now on that new wave.
our first guest inside the house caucus meeting is one of those leading the way on the step-by-step approach to immigration reform. joining us now is member of the judiciary committee, chairman of the subcommittee on immigraaion, member of the house oversight committee. as always, good to have you with us, that must have done something to hear the cheers breakout in what has been a rather somber meeting when the caucus convenes. >> i think got the loudest cheer when he said i will be brief. but he reiterated what he has said time and time again the senate bill ll not be voted on in the house. if i knew another language to say it in, i would say it in another language is so our friends in the senate would get the message but their bill will not be voted on in the house of representives. we are going to do our own bill,
our own way, step-by-step. it has been 27 years since the last foray. i don't know what the rush to do it in the next 27 days would be other than a political rush, and i have got to add this, i was listening to jay carney, and i have looked and looked and looked since i have been going to washington the comments immigration bill president obama and the house and sena democrats passed in 2008, 2009 when the head control of both bodies and the white house. they didn't lift a finger which makes skeptics think more interested in 2014 in the election cycle then they are a real remedy. nevertheless we are going to work in the house and we will do it responsibly step-by-step and hopefully engender public trust in the process.
lou: that process would be regular order in the house, there will be hearings, rigorous analysis of issues and questions asked, insistence upon answers by the hous >> as now as that sounds, have had for hearings so far in the amendment process went well into the late evening, that is the way it is supposed to be done. if you have a better idea, debated with stability and fact, and take a vote. don't lump everything in together, throw some more money in certa states where you think the senators need to vote for it. that is not how they set it up and that is not the way we are going to do it. another out of homeland security that deals with the border. there are other bills to come, and we're going to let the house
work its will. i think that's what the american people want, i thinkhey want to seehe process unfold and not have some deal cut behind a mahogany door. lou: it is exhilarating to be quite candid about the matter to hear you and the leadership of the other members of the leadership of the house of representatives say this is going to be a government well-run, process well-managed and the people served rather than to see another effort, i once thought they were well meeting. i am not sure all the e e mbersf the gang of eight and this president are well-meaning because it suggests if they are well-meaning, they missed entirelyhe lessons of 2006 and 2007 which are the american people desee far beer on important issues that matter to our sovereignty, our destiny, our lives as americans and of
course order security and immigration must, border security must be present, immigration must be reformed but it is supposed to be done in the national interest. you all have decided to dot the right way. is exhilarating. >> what was exhilarating for me is in that coerence thear my colleagues who have very compelling stories about how their families came to this country. we are a nation of immigrants, also a nation of law, that does not mean you cannot balance us with compassion. i am thankful we have a compassionate citizenry. i don't know the colleagues in the senate have ticed or not, but there is a decrease in confidence in the institutions of government, if nothing els people are going to have confidence in the process, hope we end up with a product they
like, but if we end up with a product or not, they will have confidce in the process and i don't want to repeat myself, but there are some who believe the president is more interested in the issue in 2014 then he is a solution and look no further back than to his first term with nancy pelosi and harry reid, they did not lift a finger on comprehensive immigration refo reform, why do they want to do with before august? why do it the next 27 days? lou: the coniston made an intereeting point on the sean @annity sh last night said if president obama can force obamacare, who is to say he cannot be selective as an enforcement on border security. in fact i will say he has been extraordinarily selective and forcing security on the borders but also immigration law itself.
it will have to change some of the rules if there is to be real reform, which i think most americans want. first and foremost want the border tbe secured as a real change in immigration lo law tht equitable. >> they want to make sure this is the last time we go thugh this conversatn as a nation. the only ways to not give the executive branch ability to turn triggers on and off based on political expediency. i can tell the president right now we will not give them the authority to decide which parts of the law to enforce, you can add recess appointment to your list of laws he so actively enforces when he wants to. i'm about respecting the rule of law. it is not his job to decide which ones to enforce and which ones not to.
eric cantor is exactly right. lou: always good to talk to you. republican leadership, quite a y in washington. much more on illegal immigration debate, border security debate coming up later, we will take it upn the "chalk talk" tonight. egyptian military gets more help from its friends. the general on that and the reduction in the size of the reduction in the size of the u.s. military. ere is a pursuit we all share. a better life for your family, a better opportunity for your business,
for their family. that's why i created the honest company. i was just a conrned mom, with a crazy dam. a wish that there was a company that i could rely on, that did all of the hard work for me. i'm jessica alba, and the honest company was my dream. [ male announcer ] legalzoom has helped a million businesses successfully get started, including jessica's. launch your dream at legalzoom today. call us. we're here to help.
lou: breaking news, associated press is reporng canadian officials are teing the families of the 30 people still missing after the runaway oil train crash over the weekend that those are all presumed dead. for the 20 bodies found today, that would put the death toll from surday's derailment and massive explosion at 50. the head of the railway explosion blame an engineer for failing to set the brakes properly. a new outragfor taxpayers, pentagon likely to tou teradyne ste-of-the-art facility in afghanistan. u.s. forces wi likely never use. three years ago commanders warned the pentagon they didn't need the massive operation center that rivals itself. operations move forward. the afghans cannot afford it parked the because it is wired for american appliances, the militaryays it is investigating what went wrong.
the white house today vowing to take its time deciding whether to freeze aid to egypt while avding a military coup. this is the pentagon movin ahead with plans to send for more fighter jets to the egyptian military. joining now is former army brigadier general, commande comf the first infantry division along with many more prestigious, prominent commands. great to have you with us. >> thank you. lou: let's start with the idea in a state senator johnncain saying the united states should cut off aid egypt. yo thoughts. >> historically egypt, israel, greece, turkey have received the bulk of the u.s. aid for the military, but in this case i think with the changing dynamics
in this area, egypt is a very impoant country in the middle east and north africa. the dust settles and their sorting out what kind of government, treating the peopl and their place in the region. we do know saudi arabia and kuwait among others providing substantial aid to the egyptia with the fall of the government, do look upon that a positive one as egypt itself whenhey desperately need that money, but also for the region. >> i believe it is positive, it is positive because it is good to have the arab states to
provide funding to do so for the other western counies that may have fulfilled to the past. we have to wait to see how things turn out. that does not mean we turn our backs, but stand back somewhat and wait until conditions develop before we start providing lot of a begin. lou: turning to afghanistan, considering is your optio wishes the withdrawal of the troops from afghanistan next year. a wise course? >> with the strategic marks to pakistan, we need me sort of
commitment to not only keep an e on the commitment that we and sacrifices we made, but to understand a way ahead, to not totally cut out of that country. a zero poll out had done wise. lou: 12 combat brigades to be cut from 10 u.s. bases, combat brigades to be polled, this looks like an extraordinar extraordinary, a complicated surgery that the military right now can't really afford. >> iyou look back in history, vietnam and the first iraq war, other wars in history, we always do this, people are the most expensive part of the military, but the most critical. more criticathan the type of equipment you give to them.
cutting these out, you have to be very careful. you cannot mobilize recruit, traifor mobilize those kinof units overnight. having the forces at a good rate providing proper rotation overseas giving you a perspective. it provides jobs. it is an employment issue, every g.i. and their family provides jobs with three to seven other people in the communities ere they serve. cut out the troops spread it
affects more than the numbers of the army itself. lou: general, thank you for being with us, as always. thank you. turning now to wall street, stocks finishing basically flat following the release of minutes from the federal reserve meeti meeting, that's a good thing given recent history with those minutes on the market. the dow falling nine points, the s&p gained a fraction. the volume on the big board 3 billion shares. fed chairmanen bernanke speaking as a market is closing saying the economy needs highly accommodative policy. they will not raise short-term rates for some time after it hits 6.5%, which is the feds target. security and exchange commission ended the 80-year-old advertising restrictions for hedge funds and other firms that seek private investments. those companies need to raise a limited amnts for private offerings for private
advertising. ld up a dollar and a half. finishing $106, $0.52 per barrel. the highest since march, 2012. the yield on the 10-year rose to 2.68%. up next the white house making it sound like the gang of eight immigration bill is supported by all. we know now far better than that, we will show you why that in today's markets, a lot can happen in a second. with fidelity's guaranteed one-second trade execution, we route your order to up to 75 market centers to look for the best possible price -- ybe even better than you expected. it's all part of our goal to execute your trade in one sond. i'm derrick chan of fidelity investments. our one-second trade execution is one more innovative reason seous investors are choosing fidelity.
>> you have a coalition of support behind, consensus of support behind comprehensive immigration reform, reflected in a senate bill that includes business leaders, law enforcement leaders. deats, republicans. lou: the way the white house is talking, you would think nobody opposed the gang of eight reform bill. republican leadership and house of representatives have said that legislation is dead on arrival.
j coie says there is no reason to not just move quickly, but not so fast as they say. obama 2012 coalition has a lot to fear. after the president 193% of the black vote, 57% of the middle-class vote. and those kingetween 30-$50,000 per year. what the white house won't tell you is the study shows african-americans anth middle-class will be hit hard for the gang of eight immigration to have moved ahead. why? pure research did a tudy on illegal immigrants in the country and found illegal imgrants are just proportionately likely to be fully educated, low skilled and working thoughncome jobs. 47%, 47% of illegal immigrants have less than a higschool education.
compared to 8% of us-born working age americans. that means likely be competing for low skilled american citizens. the congressional black caucus supports the gang of eight, in what sense does it make for black youth unemployment already and unacceptable 43.6%. let me say that again. 43.6%. there is so much ideology over the so-called gang of eight legislation that they cannot seingly get the impact of the prescriptions there often. during the inauguration speech, the president also railed against the forces in the middless. in his first term the president even called income inequality the defining issue of our times. nowhere in the white hoe report the gang of eight
proposition that it would work worsen income equality the income is about $36,000, $36,000. compared to $50,000 for u.s. immigrants. the cause of those lower wages, bringing down average wages the entire lab force. possess sound like something any of us should be supporting. house republican leadership decided two hoursgo they would not be picking up his senate bill or if you prer the president bill. creating effective and humane immigration policy and secure borders. and you have two give the
chairman of the house judiciary committee, the congressman a great deal o credit for working in the natial interest be it george zimmerman declined to testify the defense rests its case in the murder trial. the attorneys aaalyze it all the boys used double miles from their capital one venture card to fly home for the big family reunion. you must be garth's father? hello. mother. mother! traveling is easy with the venture card because you can fly any airline anytime. two words. double miles! this guy can act. wanna play dodge rock? oh, you guys! and with double miles you can actuay use, you never miss the fun. beardrowing contest and go! ♪ win! what's in your wallet?
-- record the called a community relations service immediately folwing the shooting death of trayvon martin inste of following the stated mission to prevent racial and ethnic tensions they helped to organize anti-zimmerman demonstrations. we have talked a great deal about the politicalization of the justice apartment but i n't think anyone ever anticipated of what we just reported to you. the defense rest of the murder trial of georgia zimmermann did not before a dummy took center stage staging a dramatic re-enactment between the fight using a life-size dummy or many can how they clai martin drove zimmerman
said into the cement. joining us now former federal prosecutors in now from new york city, a good to have you here. today, the defense counsel turning it into his prop how important was that? >> almost to show where it is going down. put to her calling in on the stand. they need to be careful. big surprise. >> it helps their rhetoric the other slaves it. it is comical quite honestly i am sure the jurors understand each side's been set the way they want to.
lou: i would think ere reid the amounts of that with any trial but this is overwhelming when they bring the case for wd from nearly every point spinet that is a great observation but part of the issue is looking at 60 year-old jurors they will say. >> they are brodeur minded? >> yes they are. [laughter] that the analysis starts off with why dat get outf your car? but it may all may say look at the moments before the gun was pulled. that is in favor of suburban. if you looat him for when he gets out of the car things will go our right. >> what i have said all
along just because he disregarded 91 and follow the d it does not mean that he did anything wrong at if he is attacked he cannot defend himself. lou: dpatchedid not say to follow him they said that we don't need you to purple and purposeful destruction. >> you areight. they may get past that but it looked at the age. 17 years old. anybody who knows a teenager knows they do not make the wisest decisions. you are an adult. these of the types of issues lou: they portray george zimmern as a wimp. >> that is all they needed to do.
that he doesn't have the macho ness that isn't bad to have five out of 10. [laughter] >> all joking aside that with the women all lawyers are scratching there heads say how could that the prosecution and the defense be satisfied with the jury? thinking the jury may be of course, . i lost my son. lou: this is a casual observation, i do not follow this minute by minute but this judge seems to be clearly on the side of the prosecution. for rulings have been disastrous i would take if there ever is an appeal if necessary, she is beyond the pale. >> she has a lot of discretion. this goe back to t decision of the case. someone is voted into office
she will be sensitive to that because constituents don't want this case so that is why they have been. >> all constituents? >> not all of them. [laughter] lou: up next crude oil prices at the highest level in more than a year even as production is soaring to an all-time high. what is g on? what is g on? we will have the next. when we made our commitment the gulf, bp had two big goals: help the gulf recover, and learn from what happened so we could be a better, fer energy compa. i've been with bp for 24 years. i was part of the team that helped deliver on our commitments to the gulf - and i can tell you, safety is at the heart of everything we do. we've added cting-edge safety equipment and technology, like new deepwater well cap and a state-of-the-art monitoring center, where experts watch over all drilling activity, twenty-four-seven. and we're sharing what we've learned, so we can all produce energy more safely.
safety is a vital part of bp'commitment to erica - and to the nearly 25000 peopleho work withs here. we invest more in the u.s. than anywhere else in the world. over fifty-five billion dollars here in the last five years - making bp america's largest energy investor. our commitment has never been stronger.
first of all, this is stunning. everything to be accommodate into the market what do you make of it? that is the last thing the fed wants to see. i was downtown with gas and $4 a gallon but clearly if we get some high intention in the middle east and oil goes to 130 a barrel so that will clearly will take wind out of the recovy. lou: said a question that billiley would insist upon. watching will productn
screen higher. what is going on? will we see them reverse? >> a lot of that if we think back betwn israel will they baum i ran? -- bomb iran? >> i don't agree with bill of rights these conspiracy theory. lou: neither do i. le me be clear. there are hundreds of thousands ofarticipants in the oil market. it is running:fear because there is plenty of supp despite the inventory
numbers. there is a lot of oil out there. it is purely middle east tensions. lou: derek is a lot of money and in this economy. and then bernanke made it very clear the unemployment rate does not represent what he considers to be a very difficult labor market in and he will be accommodating for the foreseeable future. he made that clear. but the market torrow will react how? >> i think the market has bounceback remember on may may 22nd it miss redbird khaki saying they would start to taper. and to try to be more clear
on that. the rest assured in my opinion it will be an extremellong period of time and i still think despite the comments from bernanke i sti they're unlikely to reduce the monthly purchases unti 2014. inflation is low we have been paying a lot but if you look at it the way the fed does the economy is growing very slowly. let's to use those conditions to pull back and take the floor of the accelerator. lo and the etf o reducing ssme of the exemption on the muni bonds and talk about reducing deductions for mortgage ierest.
is this for rea or will become a significant factor in the marketplace? >> the to the you mentioned, the to deductions are very unlikely the dy bond and houng deduction are very unlikely to go away for a long time but rest assured gen the fiscal situation over time all taxpayers, all citizens are going to be receivi less entitlements in will be paying more taxes. we have a fiscal problem ahead of us. it is not a crisis now that is why the politicians don't act. it probably won't maybe fiber 10 years but somewhere unless we change the way we do business there will be a problem but right now we can
borrow all the money we want at 2.6% and that is not a crisis. lou: a somebody wants a crisis then they can talk about raising taxes. this president better be constrained. >> there is a lot of uncertainty. lou: thank you for being with us. the brand new book collusion shows a liberal mainstream media. and how to avoid a bp to in 2016. next. >> one democrat now says james obamacare. change the law.
carney and company. carney and company. 9:20 a.m. eastern. the pursuit of a better tomorrow is something we all share. but who can help you find your own path? who cabuild you a plan, not just a pie chart? who can help keep your instments on course, whatever lies ahead? that someone is a morgan stanley financial advisor. and we're ready to work foyou.
lou: my next guestays the mainstream media has not shown as much bias as they did during the presidential election a and if conservatives to do something now they will not win in 2016. here to talk about his new book in the mea's role with the bombing is reelection from the media research cenr the author of the brave new book entitled collusion, how the media's role the 2012 election and how to stop them from doing it in 2016. congratulations on the book.
with the cables you talk about the cnn candy crowley the way she responded a and interjected in that debate asserting that the president had declared benghazi was an act of terrorism and there was no consequence in civic no. every four years republicans complained about the moderator's that they have a heated in choosing theast year it was interesting because the two moderators you expected to be left wing jim leyritz and especially bob schieffer both did a terrific job in the first and third debates. they both did a great j. the middle was candy crowley and i would have put my money on her. but she was terrific and took away a golden moment r me on the. he heard e president say that the president declared
it a terrorist attack and he looked at the president in disbelief that you may have just given me the presidency with th statement and she rushed to defend the president and said he was right and he made her repeat that he was right and he was not at all. lou: a hint the idea i watchethat moment i thought it is even a better moment because now he can ke on the media as well as the president of united states. had he chosen to do that that would have been a golden moment. >> what was the hig watermark of newt gingrich? georgia when he took in the media.
bush 41 tried that with all was lost but the conservatives can stand that against them dirt you saw the nonstop attacks against every single republican while white washing any controversy with barack above and conservatives are fed up. lou: the book is called pollution -- pollution. -- collusion. lou: but they cannot find a way to counterattack the national media you talk about ignorance, and arrogance and fear i just think that you
and reince priebus will get along. [laughter] >> the ignorance they do not understand how important this is and should be at the top of their agenda. they have to g through this force that stopshem at every opportunity. the arrogance is to think that they don't need to do that or that they are above that. you sough itith the new rob the campaign. they made no effort. and so many republicans believe ifhey are smacked once they betterot respond they may get smacked twice. %-why not respond? lou: i cannot agree more and i find it amazing republicans didn't think they needed to get out the vote either. that was a silly oversight with a presidential ection >> i was asked last night is it fair to say th media stole the ection?
buttenbaum melos to for many reasons but i do believe the media was fair barack obama uld have b hey, buddy? oh, hey, flo. you want to see something cool? snapshot, from progressive. my insurance company told me not to talk to people like you. you always do what they tell you? no... try it, and see what your good driving can save you. you don't even have to switch. unless you're scared. i'm not scared, it's... you know we can still see you. no, you can't. pretty sure we can... try snapshotoday -- pressure.
neil: and leased it is something if the irs will not c any one then let's cut the fund of the targeted budget. welcome, everybody. i am neil cavuto. how is this? republans looking to cut 3 million from the budget more than what the white house once it is a penalty for the agency that will not reprimanded cells because two months after thewhite house promised it would get to the bottom of thi not a single group has been questioned or have initial findings reported. maybe the irs is getting the budget cut is just a deserved