tv The Journal Editorial Report FOX News June 21, 2014 11:00am-11:31am PDT
plus, the mysterious case of the disappearing e-mails. is congress buying the irs' latest story? and as we commemorate the 50th anniversary of the civil rights act, jason riley looks at whether a half century of liberal social policies have helped or hurt black americans. >> american forces will not be returning to combat in iraq, but we will help iraqis as they take the fight to terror iists who threaten the iraqi people, the
region and american interests as well. >> welcome to "the journal editorial report." that was president obama thursday announcing plans to send up to 300 american military advisers to iraq to help the government battle islamic insurgents. the rapidly deteriorating situation has opened up a heated debate here at home over whether to intervene and just who is responsible for what went wrong. joining the panel, wall street columnist, brett stevens and matt kaminski. brett, 300 military advisers, air strikes maybe but not now unless they get their political act together. can you detect a strategy here? >> yeah. the strategy is to have the appearance of strategy to offer a kind of image of action 300 people are not going to stop american advisers, even if they're special forces, are not
going to reverse the gains which is isis, an al qaeda affiliate has made in taking over geographically a quarter or even a third of the country. they might be able to help the iraqi government on the margins, but at best it's a containment strategy for al qaeda. it's not an effort to reverse the gain gains that al qaeda has made. >> de facto partition, would that be the result? a kurd in the north, and then this potential terrorist state in the west? >> well, that's a win-win for iran. >> but is that the likeliest outcome? >> i think at this point i must say it is. we've put in 300 people, but that's really not enough to either change the military facts on the ground nor is it enough to buy enough leverage in b baghdad to make the political changes necessary to bring about a kind of sunni/shia reconciliation. >> why is that point? they're also leaking, the white
house is leaking they want the prime minister nuri al mralaki who they blame for all of this to go. is that likely to work? >> no. i think it's going to make malaki to try and stay in place and it will basically bring the shia, the majority shia, around malaki because the americans are telling him to go. but i think, remember, partition is a terrible outcome for iraq. it's going to be very painful to separate neighborhoods and it will be the final defeat of what we started and paid very heavily in 2003 by going in. >> let's focus on one more piece of the possible partition, and that's if this al qaeda affiliate, it's al qaeda, is able to -- >> it's jihadist. >> if they're able to establish themselves in central iraq, this will essentially be what al qaeda did in afghanistan in the early 2000s but this will be a lot more convenient well supported area for them to do planning operations to take terror into the world as they
did before. and the american people should make no mistake, this is an p outward moving terrorist force. they are not going to establish a little state there, do sharia law and live happily ever after. this is a centrifugal voice. >> this is why i think voices like rand paul who had an op-ed this week are so misguided. this is not simply an iraqi civil war. an al qaeda stint in northern iraq is a threat to the entire region and a threat to the united states. we already see reports of european jihadis, even american jihadis getting training in a place like this. afghanistan was -- the taliban was a state sponsor of al qaeda. this is al qaeda itself in control. >> if it is that large a threat -- and i agree with you -- then why not reach out to iran as some in the administration want to do, to help mitigate that threat? where would you put the very -- is that al qaeda stand potential at the top, followed by iran? >> why not deal with iran to
help? >> well, because we have two enemies, one is the shiite terrorist sponsoring state and the other is a potential sunni state sponsor -- sunni terrorists. so we are not -- this is not world war ii. we do not have to enlist the soviet union in order for us to defeat nazi germany. we are a powerful -- we are the world's super power and if we had the political where with all we could reverse the gains isis has made without making a concession to the iranians or giving them an additional -- >> wouldn't that require a major intervention, that is, military intervention, not just air strikes, not just 300 advisers but a lot more deployed american troops on the ground to be able to assist the iraqis? you said yourself they're not able to do it by themselves. >> right. and that's exactly right. >> so you're acknowledging it would take that intervention. >> of course it would. and by the way, this -- we -- if americans may have short memories. we were attacked by al qaeda on
9/11. this president came to office saying, i'm not going to have these fake wars against, say, saddam hussein. i'm going to go after al qaeda. well, here it is. we are do 0ing next to nothing about it. >> rand paul is against it and a lot of republicans haven't been speaking up. this president isn't going to do that kind of strategy, is he? >> i don't think so. that's the other scary scenario here, you have al qaeda winning, iran winning because for iran it's fine to have a sunni terrorist in the north and you have a lack of leadership here on both the left and the right. but at some point, you hope nothing catastrophic needs to happen, but at some point you will need to really radically shift policies. >> but iran doesn't necessarily really want to fight there as well. i mean, this would be permanent civil war there, fighting between the shia and the sunnis. >> that's true. i think as you suggested paul what they would be willing to settle for is basically having control of southern iraq. it would be bloody, but the
outcome would be them in southern iraq and al qaeda in northern iraq. >> thanks. when we come back, the irs chief is in the hot seat after the agency waited two months to tell congress about those missing e-mails. so what can be done now to get them back? ael, i'm 55 years old and i have diabetic nerve pain. the pain was terrible. my feet hurt so bad. it felt like hot pins and needles coming from the inside out of my skin. when i did go see the doctor, and he prescribed lyrica. it helped me. [ male announcer ] it's known that diabetes damages nerves. lyrica is fda-approved to treat diabetic nerve pain. lyrica is not for everyone. it may cause serious allergic reactions or suicidal thoughts or actions. tell your doctor right away if you have these, new or worsening depression, or unusual changes in mood or behavior. or, swelling, trouble breathing, rash, hives, blisters, changes in eyesight, including blurry vision, muscle pain with fever, tired feeling or skin sores from diabetes. common side effects are dizziness, sleepiness, weight gain and swelling of hands, legs and feet. don't drink alcohol while taking lyrica.
don't drive or use machinery until you know how lyrica affects you. those who have had a drug or alcohol problem may be more likely to misuse lyrica. having reduced pain is great and i'm grateful for it. [ male announcer ] ask your doctor about lyrica today. it's specific treatment for diabetic nerve pain. whatever happened to good? good is choosing not to overshoot the moon, but to land right on it. good is maxwell house. ♪ good to the last drop good is maxwell house. upgrafor the most advanced norelshaving experience.00 with gyroflex 3d technology, you can get to those hard to reach places for the ultimate shave wet or dry. guaranteed. visit philips.com/fathersday now to save $50. ♪ ♪ ♪
[ male announcer ] if you can't stand the heat, get off the test track. get the mercedes-benz you've been burning for at the summer event, going on now at your authorized mercedes-benz dealer. hurry, before this opportunity cools off. ♪ geicmoney for over 75 years.save they've really stood the test of time. much like these majestic rocky mountains. which must be named after the... that would be rocky the flying squirrel, mr. gecko sir. obviously! ahh come on bullwinkle, they're named after... ...first president george rockington! that doesn't even make any sense...mr...uhh...winkle. geico. fifteen minutes could save you fifteen percent or more on car insurance. when folks think about wthey think salmon and energy. but the energy bp produces up here creates something else as well: jobs all over america. engineering and innovation jobs. advanced safety systems & technology.
shipping and manufacturing. across the united states, bp supports more than a quarter million jobs. when we set up operation in one part of the country, people in other parts go to work. that's not a coincidence. it's one more part of our commitment to america. were lost when her computer hard drive cashed in 2011. but koskinen faced a grilling on capitol hill friday with more to come next week after it was revealed that those e-mails and those of six other irs officials may have been gone for good
after their computer hard drives were recycled. something the agency has known since february. we're back with dan henninger, colin leafy and james freeman. colin, what do you make of the explanation from the irs that these e-mails were lost because the, quote, computer crashed, unquote. >> i mean, it's completely implausible, right? by the way, we now know computer hard drives can be are recovered from fires. there's all kinds of techniques now on that sort of recovery. but the bigger issue here that we have to keep repeating is how fantastical the narrative is that they're spinning. lois lerner, the center, the key official, she refuses to testify before congress. that leaves all the information to come from her e-mail and correspondence. now they tell us that they can't find her e-mail for these specific period when all of this
occurred. by the way, also can't find the e-mails of six other people that she likely corresponded with. then they tell us that actually they've known this for four months and haven't even mentioned it. so it's just an astonishing story they're spinning here. >> just to clarify, these e-mails are not lois lerner's e-mails with fellow irs staff members. those they have. these are e-mails with the justice department, with the treasury department and potentially with the white house and also with democrats on capitol hill. so we really don't know who she might have been taking orders from, what those orders might have been or what kind of discussions they might have had about how to proceed here. >> that's right. >> james, where does this leave us? >> it's kind of an amazing story. if you take it all the way back, the number of things that have come out of the irs that were just flat-out not true, it starts in 2011 with the inquiry from congressman dave camp to the irs, lois lerner saying no, we're not targeting, the irs
saying we're not targeting. shortly after that is when apparently this computer crash happened with lerner and then others at the irs as well. >> we've also learned that they failed to fully comply with subpoenas for going on many months, almost up to a year, because the subpoenas had said, look, you must supply all e-mails. instead, this last week the irs has admitted that it was only supplying some of the e-mails deciding on its own volition which were really relevant to the probe that congress was pursuing. now, what is the definition of "all "? >> it seems very straightforward. it's kind of worse than that because in his friday testimony, mr. koskinen is basically using as an excuse all the time they've spent looking for e-mail and filtering them. but of course it's a lot easier to just gather up the bundle and send it to the hill than to go through them all by the criteria that the irs, not the congressional investigators set. but i think it also should be noted, mr. koskinen said they
back up e-mail every night. now, if it's true that in 2011 they made herculean efforts to recover the data lost on mr. lerner's hard drive, why don't you go to the backup to get the data before it was recycled. the story, as hard as it is to believe, it's not only coherent. >> it's not only not co-hairpt, to tell you the truth, it shows not only contempt for these investigating committees but contempt for the american people, that they are not even attempting to shape a story or an answer that is the least bit credible. as you said, they had -- they knew this since february. they take all of this time to at least tell congress they had lost these e-mails. you know there's a saying, if it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, walks like a duck, this is quacking like a cover-up. how else do you describe what's going on? >> go ahead, collin. >> i was just going to jump in and say, there are so many
questions here that still have to be answered. we now know about this document dump that the irs sent over to the justice department. we don't know what's in it. we don't know whether it was asked for, whether it was sent unilaterally, who determined what the universe of the group selected was. all of these are very serious questions that we need answered, and the more this stone walling and obstruction continues, the more that sort of gets pushed into the future. >> that's the point, isn't it? if you just push this along, pretty soon this administration is over. do you think they should have a special prosecutor? >> you know, there's actually -- i think there can be an argument for that, that everyone at the justice department at this point is so compromised this whole administration looks so complicit and compromised it's hard to think that might not be a good idea. >> a lot of the media won't report this. more than two dozen house democrats support a special prosecutor. this is not a partisan issue and it shouldn't be. when we come back, 50 years after the passage of the civil rights act, are liberal social
the underserved laws couldn't accomplish everything, but he also knew that only the law could anchor change and set hearts and minds on a different course. >> that was president obama earlier this year praising president lyndon johnson as the nation prepares to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the passage of the civil rights act, the landmark legislation that outlawed racial discrimination. half a century later, my guest this week says liberal policies and well-intentioned welfare programs are holding back black
americans. wall street editorial board member jason riley author of "please stop helping us: how liberals make it harder for blacks to succeed." jason, what policies are you talking about? >> i'm talking about a lot of the great society programs we're celebrating or marking the 50th anniversary of. i'm talking about anti-poverty programs, policies such as minimum wage laws, occupational licensing and things like that. these are affirmative action, another one. these are laws that were intended to help. the intention was good and honorable and noble. but that's different from -- that doesn't make it right. it doesn't mean that the policies work just because the intentions behind them were good. >> but what about the argument that you had a century of jim crowe in much of the country which was essentially legislated, government-enforced impoverishment.
lack of access to the voting booth, lack of jobs, to get over that, help people escape that century of built-in bad behavior and government mismanagement, you needed something like the great society. >> well, what we needed was equal treatment under the law. we needed the civil rights act of 1964. the voting acts right of 1965. those were needed. we got those. the problem is when the government tries to go beyond equal opportunity and ensure equal results. that's when you get into trouble. what i'm arguing is black people must ultimately help themselves. they must develop the habits and attitudes and behavior that other groups have had to develop in order to succeed. and to the extent a government program gets in the way of that or hampers that self-development that must take place, it ultimately does more harm than good. >> in a way, you are -- and i think this is one of the most interesting things in your book -- you're trying to resurrect an intellectual tradition that has really strong roots going back in american
history, frederick douglas great abolitionist, former slave, talked about escaping dependency, booker t. wa washington. why has that tradition become so much less prominent inside the black intellectual movement? >> i think it's a very lucrative industry. what you've seen over the past 50 years is an attempt by the black elite to stay relevant. and what i try and get across in this book is that it's much more important for the black poor to have a man in the home than to have a man in the white house, like they have today. i think the obama presidency shows that wroefr whemgly is the case. the things that ail the black community are not going to be solved by politicians. they're going to be solved by the black community getting its own act together internally. the family, it's going to start with the family. >> but if the results are as
awful as you argue, why hasn't there been a revolt intellectually and then politically within the african-american community itself? >> well, on the one hand you have the history of seg ra zbaigs and who was on what side back then. a lot of people are still alive that lived under jim crowe. under older blacks you have that historical memory there. >> that the government liberated them from jim crowe. >> right. and the left has done an excellent job of convincing black that bigger government is better for them and democrats are the party of bigger government. but i think the republican party needs to do a better job of courting this vote, going into these communities. we see some politicians on the right doing that today, chris christie, a rand paul, paul ryan. they are going into those communities and there have been a few in the past, jack kemp comes to mind. but those are the exceptions, not the rule. and it's because republicans believe they can still win elections without these voters. i don't think it's racial animus. it's very pragmatic.
time spent courting one group is time not courting another group. republicans are right 0 now worried about hispanic voters and whether they need them to win elections. but no discussion is happening about blacks. they don't think they need the black vote 0 to win elections. when they believe they need them, i think you'll see more black outreveal from republicans. >> thank you for being here. good luck with the book. when we come back, hits and misses of the week. to buy a car.
what would help is simply being able to recognize a fair price. that's never really been possible. but along comes a radically new way to buy a car called truecar. now it is. truecar has pricing data on every make and model, so all you have to do is search for the car you want... there it is. now you're an expert in less than a minute. this is how car buying was always meant to be. this is truecar. if yand you're talking toevere rheuyour rheumatologistike me, about a biologic... this is humira. this is humira helping to relieve my pain. this is humira helping me lay the groundwork. this is humira helping to protect my joints
from further damage. doctors have been prescribing humira for ten years. humira works by targeting and helping to block a specific source of inflammation that contributes to ra symptoms. humira is proven to help relieve pain and stop further joint damage in many adults. humira can lower your ability to fight infections, including tuberculosis. serious, sometimes fatal events, such as infections, lymphoma, or other types of cancer, have happened. blood, liver and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure have occurred. before starting humira, your doctor should test you for tb. ask your doctor if you live in or have been to a region where certain fungal infections are common. tell your doctor if you have had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have symptoms such as fever, fatigue, cough, or sores. you should not start humira if you have any kind of infection. take the next step. talk to your doctor. this is humira at work.
time now for our hits and misses of the week. collin, first to you. >> paul, this week the media woke up to the fact that since october democratic prosecutors in wisconsin have been pursuing a secret investigation of conservative groups there. their theory, which is that the groups illegally coordinated during the recall of governor walker, has already been discredited roundly by two judges. but when some new documents were made public this week, the media instead embraced a fully already discredited narrative. so a miss for them for not doing their home work. >> you can't cover the irs, but you can cover a document dump based on a false theory of free speech. thanks. matt in. >> here is a hit to the d.c. city council, which this week moved forward to rename a street in the capital after yu jaw bow, a chinese dissident, winner of a
nobel peace prize incarcerated in china. this street happens to be the street on which the chinese embassy is located in washington. >> no accident. >> the chinese call this a provocative action, which it very much is, is meant to remind them and the world that we care about human rights in china. >> he is in prison. >> absolutely. >> you know, thpresident obama s fund-raising while the wrorld burned and a weekend when ethnic russian separatists in ukraine shot down a plane, burned gas pipes when isis was taking over cities in iraq, president obama had a day, three fund-raisers in new york. as a new yorker, i think i speak for aum new yorkers in not thanking the president for snarling traffic and ruining our commute. >> if you have your own hit or miss, send it to us. be sure to follow us on twitter.
that's it for this week's show. thanks to my panel. thanks to all of you for watching. i'm paul gigot. hope to see you right here next week. on this saturday, iraq is on the brink. this as sunni militants take over yet another key city. those insurgents launching a new offensive by storming another town northwest of baghdad. this is now the second city to be captured in the critical anwar province which saw some of the worst fighting during the iraq war. hello, everyone on this saturday afternoon. welcome to "america's news headquarters". >> thank you for being with us. as the terror group isis gains more ground in the north, eric, we're seeing thousands of heavily armed supporters from