Skip to main content

tv   Countdown With Keith Olbermann  MSNBC  August 24, 2009 10:00pm-11:00pm EDT

10:00 pm
off, and if you can make it 100 meters out into the water, you win nearly 50 grand. what could be ealesier? it's just gravity. the competitors fall into two categories. the one who believed their aerodynamics improved dramatically if they are dressed as a crocodile. or laurel and hardy. or as the two dumbest raf pilots ever. with that mustache, they could fly all the way to canada. or not. then there are the gliders. surely their sleek machines will send them soaring heavenward or not. if i have to watch people fail, i would rather see them fail wearing something like this.
10:01 pm
here is the best effort of the day. this guy made it 99.8 meters just inches short of winning the money prize, but, oh, he didn't. that's because we were not meant to master this. >> the lawn chair seemed like a good idea at the time. >> it seemed like that. >> missed it with a belly flop. >> that close. >> thanks so much. thank you for watching tonight. i'm allison stewart in for rachel maddow. you can e-mail us at rachel at msnbc.com. "countdown with keith olbermann" starts now. good night. which of these stories will you be talking about tomorrow? the report is out. bush interrogators threaten khalid sheik muhammad, we're
10:02 pm
going to kill your children. bush interrogators threatened al nashiri, we are going to use this power drill on your head. they threaten to rape mothers, assault family, as detainees were forced to watch. and concurrent with the inspector general's nauseating, beyond belief findings more records which dick cheney thinks prove torture works. there will be a special prosecutor. his name is john durham. colonel lawrence wilkerson on who should be held responsible and who probably will be. the republicans and shouting fire in a nonfiery theater. senators mccain and hatch actually suggest the debate would have been different if senator kennedy had been there. like it was his fault. and senator grassley on having said -- >> you have every right to fear. we should not have a government program that determines you're going to pull the plug on grandma. >> that, grassley says now, was the president's fault. >> the specific language i used was language that the president
10:03 pm
had used at portsmouth. >> and the newest crazy scare tactic. first they had a death panel. now there's a death book. >> usually we discuss the news but today we're going to tell you about something you may never have heard about. what critics are calling the death book. >> unfortunately, the death book chris is holding is actually a veterans administration manual, a minor update of the one used in 2007 under president bush. or to translate this into republican, george bush had a death book. and told you so. what or who killed michael jackson? police confirm no murder investigation -- coroner's office said this afternoon no foul play. are the police out of this necessarily? >> this doctor is pivotal to this investigation and, boy, i hope he's got a lawyer. >> the l.a. county coroner's office reportedly rules jackson's death a homicide. all that and more, now, on "countdown." >> this is it.
10:04 pm
i mean, this is really it. good evening from new york. the u.s. department of justice will investigate incidents of torture committed by u.s. officials and contractors during the bush administration including threatening people with guns and power drills, with raping their mothers, with killing their children. our fifth story today on "the countdown." the white house today flooding the zone on the same day a federal judge ordered the release of the cia documents that read like something out of the spanish inquisition. specifically, federal prosecutor john durham expanding his existing investigation into cia destruction of interrogation videotapes to include the interrogations themselves one administration official telling the news tonight he'll detail ten cases detailed in this new cia report such as one in which one person was forced to breathe in cigarette smoke until they had to purge. like taking the "u.s.s. cole"
10:05 pm
master mind and stripping him naked except a hood on his head, racking a pistol on his head and revving a power drill in violation of u.s. law against threatening to kill detainees. telling him, quote, we could get your family and your mother in here to rape them in front of him. like telling the 9/11 master mind, "we are going to kill your children," with mock executions, firing a gun in a cell and letting a detainee next door seeing a hooded body lying apparently dead on the floor. as well as incidents in the report that remain secret, incidents the administration official said, quote, raise allegations of abuse that are much worse, presumably than the ones that kill people. officials went beyond doj guidelines but had, quote, oral concurrence to do so. the attorney general acknowledged he is fully aware of the repetitive use of the waterboard and despite former vice president cheney's claim that two cia reports from 2004 and 2005 will vindicate his use of torture those reports also released with redactions today say only detainees provided
10:06 pm
information not that torture was necessary to get it. mr. cheney unavailable for comment today, said to be on a boat. but if you think he's up river or heading for international waters, our chief justice correspondent pete williams reports that holder has all but concluded he will not recommend mr. durham investigate the bush officials who conceived of and authorized cia torture. even though top bush official jay bibee green-lighted death threats shortly before someone pointed a power drill on mr. al mashiri's head. there will be a task force. mr. obama appointing this man to oversee the interrogations, john brennan, to make sure detainees are not tortured, nor renditioned to states that torture. this despite the fact that brennan ran the bush cia counterterrorism center while the center developed its torture and rendition regimes, regimes which brennan later defended.
10:07 pm
let's turn to jay mayer, author of "the dark side," the inside story on how the war on terror turned into a war on american ideals. great thanks for your time tonight. >> great to be with you. >> what did i miss just now? >> well, that was a pretty good rundown on what sounds like really a medieval program. you know, one of the things that the inspector general's report says that i think is important is he told the cia back in 2004 when his report was given to them that they were in deep legal trouble. and so they were very much forewarned and i think there were some other documents put out by the justice department today that showed that they continued to justify the program on through 2007. that is three years later they were still doing many of the same things or justifying them anyway, so basically they were warned. they were in legal trouble. and you could see that in this report because it reads like a crime scene basically. >> there was the one quote in there in which someone was saying, we have to answer for
10:08 pm
this in ten years. they got everything right but the date. what about who's answering? who is answering here? every single passage that might lead higher up, identify the source of a torture technique, that has been blacked out, redacted. do we get that information from durham's investigation or never? >> well, my guess is that if they actually open some kind of serious investigation, and durham is said to be a very serious prosecutor, that even if they start at the very bottom, it's going to keep leading up and up through the chain of command. because if nothing else if they bring charges against anybody at the cia who was at the bottom of the food chain, the first thing that person is going to do is say i was authorized. let me tell you what my orders were. so they've begun a process that could lead to the top. >> well, if it works along the archibald cox lines as i analogized last week where they supposedly circumscribed it but as you say people want to get out from being the scapegoats
10:09 pm
for the whole operation i think your assessment is correct. what about mr. cheney's assessment that there would be documents that prove the torture worked where traditional and legal interrogation did not or would not? is there anything in those documents that were released today that supports that contention? >> well, the documents that i've seen, and maybe i'm missing something, but so far i am amazed at how little support there is for the things that vice president cheney has been saying. there is nothing but a mass of claims that they got information from this individual and that individual, many from ksm who apparently has been the greatest font of information for them but absolutely nothing saying they had to beat them to get this information. as anybody knows who knows anything about khalid sheik muhammed, he was dying to tell the world when he was interviewed by al jazeera about
10:10 pm
everything he knew and everything he did. he was proud of his role as the mastermind of 9/11 and loves to talk about it so there is no evidence that i see in this that these things were necessary. i spoke to someone at the cia who was an advisor to them who conceded to me that we could have gotten the same information with tea and crumpets. >> or buying a copy of the al jazeera interview. last note about this appointment of john brennan or intention to put him in charge of interrogate. is the lesson of the bush years ultimately that interrogators should answer directly to the white house via this man john brennan? >> it's an irony john brennan seems to be at the apex of the interrogation policy in the obama administration. many people remember, including me, i interviewed him two years ago. he was defending the bush program. he was an internal critic of waterboarding but beyond that he told me we've got to do these things.
10:11 pm
that intense interrogation techniques were necessary. now that he's advising obama he may have changed his mind. certainly the task force has taken a position that abuse has to be in the past. we don't need these things. and i guess john brennan very much is taking that position now, too. >> hopefully there's no zealot like a convert. jane mayer of "the new yorker" and also author of "the dark side." thanks for your time. >> glad to be with you. here tonight with an insider's perspective colonel lawrence wilkerson who served as chief of staff to secretary of state colin powell. thank you for your time, sir. >> thanks for having me. >> first off, your response to the cia report and particularly what are being called the cheney documents. >> well, of course, i had known a lot about this before the documents came out. i did my own investigation for secretary powell and then later my own for myself. and i read carl levin's fine report from the senate armed services committee and frankly on the basis of that report alone i think there should be some accountability and proceedings. so this didn't shock me that
10:12 pm
much except perhaps as usual to see all the redacted material. as for the two cheney reports i looked at online, just a few hours ago, the one about khalid muhammad and the more comprehensive one i agree with jane mayer that there is absolutely nothing that supports a direct cause and effect relationship between these sorts of heinous methods and the information gained. quite the contrary from what i've heard from fbi interrogators, military interrogators, and others. >> back to the main report, we've heard a lot and the rationalization inside the obama administration for not prosecuting the people who developed these techniques or authorized them or who followed the actual, as crazy as the authorizations were, followed those authorizations, is that it would demoralize the cia and so forth. but this report has a lot in it and speaks powerfully to the idea there were many people who did good work inside the cia, inside the rules, and repeatedly, perpetually and sometimes at great peril
10:13 pm
objected to these other methods. is there no reason to worry about demoralizing those people who played by the rules. >> absolutely, keith. i found the same thing with regard to abu ghraib and other more visible examples of the way the armed forces were involved in this when i encountered lieutenants and captains and majors and ncos, noncommissioned officers who had objected and not participated. it's the same thing in the cia. you've got a lot of outstanding people in the federal bureaucracy, cia, armed forces, dia and so forth and you demoralize these people when you allow the few who do this sort of thing to get away. let me emphasize that. this was not very many people. this was a very select group of contractors and cia personnel, starting with george tenet, running down through mclaughlin and rodriguez and down to the people who actually did it, contractor, nci, very small group.
10:14 pm
i would say less than 1% of the people in the agency. >> great chunks of this report, colonel, remain secret as you said. it's startling to go through it and say this is what has been released publicly and it's a series of black boxes. what do we still need to know that might be in there under the black ink? >> i think john durham is going to have to find out what's under that black ink and almost all of these reports. i think there are indications in carl levin's report, some 200 pages or so of it, that there are some fairly heinous things under that black ink. and probably more important to people like dick cheney and david addington and bill haynes and a whole bunch of others, jim haynes, is the fact there may be links all the way up to the vice president's office because that's where it all started. it started with david addington and vice president richard cheney and their gross fears that led them to do things that i probably never thought an american would do. >> it reads as i said earlier
10:15 pm
like parts of the spanish inquisition. it's amazing that it happened in our time and i guess we all have to assume responsibility for some degree to it. >> i think jane's use of the word "medieval" is right on the mark. >> colonel lawrence wilkerson former state department chief of staff under colin powell. great thanks for your time and explanation. >> thanks for having me. the republicans began in 2001 to sell fear of death as their principle political commodity and that has been solidly proven earlier than today. it continues in the response tonight to tom ridge's revelations about playing politics with counterterrorism and the latest boogey man introduced by the gop into the health care debate -- the death book. the problem arises of course when it turns out with a little more research that the death book did not originate with president obama but reached its widely used status under president bush. surprise. e you live... ...or if you're already sick... ...or if you lose your job. your health insurance shouldn't either.
10:16 pm
so let's fix health care. if everyone's covered, we can make health care as affordable as possible. and the words "pre-existing condition" become a thing of the past... we're america's health insurance companies. supporting bipartisan reform that congress can build on. in a long line of amazing peormance machines. this is the new e-coupe. this is mercedes-benz. grassley says he lied to his constituents and told them they had reason to fear the government pulling the plug on grandma because president obama
10:17 pm
used that wording first. and now the democrats the scales pulled from their eyes seem to go it alone on health care but not until the gop gives it one more try -- death books and self-proclaimed right wing terrorists called great americans. this is "countdown" on msnbc. but i did. you need to talk to your doctor about aspirin. you need to be your own advocate. be sure to talk to your doctor before you begin an aspirin regimen. you take care of your kids, now 's time to take care of yourself. the amazing always infinity. ♪ it's astonishingly flexible. ♪ unbelievably soft. ♪ and has an amazing material... that's 4x more absorbent than you may need. making fluids seem to... poof... disappear. just like magic. ♪ always infinity. have a happy period.
10:18 pm
(beep) (beep) (beep) (beep) (beep) find an italian masterpiece in your grocer's freezer. new from buitoni.
10:19 pm
shrimp and lobster ravioli with garlic butter sauce. simple ingredients, artfully prepared. buitoni. the italian art of food. new, in the freezer section. if many republican lawmakers were forced to listen to their own comments about health care they couldn't genuinely expect to be taken seriously by anybody much less democrats. in our fourth story, there are new hints now that finally seeing the madness of the republican context that surrounds them democrats will be prepared to go this alone.
10:20 pm
a new smorgasboard on health care, none more than the circuitous logic of senator grassley asked why he said, quote, we should not have a government plan that will pull the plug on grandma -- >> i said that because two reasons. number one i was responding to a question at my town meetings. i let my constituents set the agenda. a person that asked me that question was reading from language that they got off of the internet. it scared my constituents and the specific language i used was language that the president had used at portsmouth. >> of course the president had used that language to rebut those like grassley and palin who had made such an outrageous claim in the first place. grassley basically admitted he was enabling the fear of his constituents instead of puncturing the misconception with facts. when asked again if the house legislation would pull the plug on grandma he said, quote, it won't do that.
10:21 pm
>> i know the pelosi bill doesn't intend to do that but that's where it leads people to. >> senator john mccain meantime defended sarah palin's claim that obama's bill would create death panels, quoting, look. i don't think they were, quote, death panels. don't get me wrong. but on the best treatment procedures part of the bill it does open it up to decisions being made as far -- that should be left -- those choices left to the patient and the individual. both mccain and senator orrin hatch separately suggested bipartisanship would be in full flower if senator ted kennedy had not been absent from the debate. then there was senator joe lieberman raising the moral imperative here just to shoot the thing down. >> morally, every one of us would like to cover every american with health insurance but that's where you spend most of the trillion dollars plus and i am afraid we've got to think about putting a lot of that off until the economy is out of recession. there is no reason we have to do it all now. >> who will think of the
10:22 pm
bankers? won't somebody think of the bankers? with the insanity all of this just beginning to sink in senator chuck schumer claims the democrats have 60 senate votes for a health care plan including the public option and that if not his party is prepared to use the filibuster proof reconciliation process to get the bill to the president. let's turn to huffington post contributor and msnbc political analyst lawrence o'donnell. good evening, sir. >> good to be here, keith. >> have democrats finally figured out they're negotiating with and arguing against mad men? have we seen something of a sea change as of tonight? >> well, keith, we like to call that shadow boxing in the senate. we don't use that phrase negotiating with mad men. that never comes up. you do at a certain point in the proceedings realize you've been shadow boxing which is to say there is really no one there on the other side and you've been negotiating with yourself. that's apparently what ended up here. when i used to be part of these negotiations on the finance committee when i worked there you could watch republicans slip away from us over time. that's what's happening here. even republicans of good will
10:23 pm
who tried to be with you in the beginning, the party pressure, they start to feel it especially on recesses as you saw with chuck grassley and they drift away. it's very clear to democrats now that that is what has happened. >> senator schumer suggested a reconciliation if the democrats don't have the 60 senate votes, various administration officials indicated that the president's patience with republicans is not endless. might only last a couple more millenia. is there a cogent strategy to do this without republicans or not? >> in a word, no. >> great. >> if there had been a strategy to do this without republicans they would have done it in july. that was their schedule. they couldn't. they let max baucus continue his negotiations with republicans because they knew they didn't have enough democratic votes. they knew they did not have 50 democratic votes for the public option at that time. never mind the 60 they would need even within the reconciliation process in order to override certain senate rules to keep elements of the bill within reconciliation. so they don't have that.
10:24 pm
they know they don't have that. and that's why the negotiations have continued. >> we've heard everything so far. we've heard grassley contradicting grassley and blaming obama for it. we've heard about death panels. we'll get to the introduction of the death book later on. probably death spam somewhere being introduced by the republicans but for sheer egregiousness the two senators invoking ted kennedy's name into this, i'd like your reaction to that. >> well, this is kind of shocking. orrin hatch and john mccain both saying that if ted kennedy were here we'd have a deal and would be able to work out a deal with him. this strikes me as them both just trying to portray themselves as reasonable men who could do business with another reasonable man. they both voted against -- they've already voted on this -- they voted against the kennedy bill in the kennedy committee in the health, education, labor, and pensions committee. they've had a bill and voted against it. that bill was conceived of by chairman kennedy. he wasn't there at the time of
10:25 pm
the votes. chris dodd was there getting it through the committee for chairman kennedy. the chairman made his wishes known very clearly. john mccain, a member of the committee, orrin hatch a member of the committee could have tried to work with senator kennedy at the beginning and they rejected that possibility. 15 years ago orrin hatch was also on both the kennedy committee and the senate finance committee where i was working. he voted against the kennedy bill that came through the kennedy committee then. he then personally complained to me about how ugly and partisan the process was, run by senator kennedy, in senator kennedy's committee. he was hoping we would do a more bipartisan process in the finance committee, which we did do. but orrin hatch was not part of anything ted kennedy tried to do on this 15 years ago and nothing that he tried to do this year. same thing with john mccain. i don't know why they said that. they know that they didn't at any moment engage in real negotiations with senator kennedy this year. >> it's flack i think they call it when the submariners use it
10:26 pm
and it's also tasteless but if you want to invoke senator kennedy and live up to his standards then act like a senator. lawrence o'donnell of msnbc and huffington post as always, great thanks. >> thanks, keith. and meet berlino. berlino is the mascot at the berlin games which makes the thing he just ran into the berlino wall. and what did the u.s. congressman say when the idiot in the crowd announced i am a proud right wing terrorist? unfortunately it's not a knock-knock joke. find out in worst persons.
10:27 pm
10:28 pm
10:29 pm
10:30 pm
i think one of the bushes just complained tom ridge did not attack bush hard enough. first on this date in 1980 while leaving shea stadium in new york already late for work i leaped head first into the overhead of the doorway of a new york city subway car. one and one-half stitches, one concussion. 414 bouts of nausea, temporary amnesia and permanent inner ear damage later i got better and thus was born the cliche' never run for a train. there will always be another one. let's play "oddball." actually i know who actually started that but i have forgotten. we begin at the track and field world championships in berlin where mascot berlino attempts to steal the spotlight from the athletes and it ended in tragedy. first he was hamming it up with bolt after the sprinter set the world record in the 200. then the bear got into the act after melanie walker won the title in the 400 meter hurdle. berlino gives the champion a
10:31 pm
piggyback ride and clearly, oh, my, berlino has no future in hurdling. after this display berlino may not be able to have a family. thus was born the cliche' never run for a hurdler. there will always be another one. >> pedalling in germany where two young people in germany were do heavy peppling in the field. no, no. just smooching and why not? they just got engaged because marcus schmitz is the son of a farmer who wanted to propose in this special way. when the time was right in a move that would make dwight from the office proud he stacked 150 bales of hay reading in german, translation, either will you marry me or more colloquially speaking, i am a jelly doughnut. his girlfriend said yes and the couple then went on this stroll through proposal henge. the latest right wing scare tactic, death books. surprise, chris wallace. guess which president issued the death book? and the day after we asked they said no. now the answer is apparently
10:32 pm
yes. michael jackson has been reportedly classified as a homicide. these stories ahead but first down "countdown"'s best persons in the world. number three, best bad politician, mayor ian stafford is also the small town's handyman and its gardener and also its perv. after a spate of local women reported break-ins in which only their underwear was stolen one installed a hidden camera and discovered the half naked mayor donning her panties and having some fun. mayor stafford has resigned though he is a natural for senator ensign's brain trust. dateline washington, number two best bizarre political complaint. nicole wallace recoiling at tom ridge's revelation that politics raised a part in one decision about the color-coded terror alert. quote, that is quite different from what he, what we very i think in a kind of wussy way alleges. i mean this is not a very precise attack. he pondered and wondered if perhaps politics went into it. you know it's very fishy to me.
10:33 pm
she is not complaining tom ridge is incorrect or wrong, she is upset he left room for the possibility that he might not know everything. what in bush land is called being, quote, wussy. all right. ms. wallace, if ridge is too circumspect, let me translate. he caught you bastards playing politics with terrorism by raising the threat level to counteract bad news for the republicans or good news for the democrats. he caught you conducting the kind of terrorism that includes not violence but just fear of violence. is that nonwussy enough for you, nicole? and dateline washington number one, best political statement, senator joe lieberman of connecticut after alec baldwin told "playboy" magazine he had no use for lieberman and thought maybe he would move to connecticut to run against him, lieberman replied, make my day. i respect alec baldwin as an actor and comedian and if he wants to run that's his right. funny, senator. we respect you as an actor and comedian. ♪ respect my name is chef michael.
10:34 pm
and my dog bailey and i love to hang out in the kitchen... so she can watch me cook. you just love the aromas of beef tenderloin... and, ooh, rotisserie chicken. yes, you do. [ barks ] yeah. you're so special, you deserve a very special dog food. [ woman ] introducing chef michael's canine creations. the deliciously different way to serve up your love at mealtime. chef-inspired. dog-desired. chef michael's canine creations. i switched to a complete multivitamin with more. only o a day men's 50+ advantage... has gingko for memory and concentration. plus support for heart health. that's a great call. one a day men's.
10:35 pm
to get out of those tubs? when we want. when we're in the mood. it's our choice. announcer: today, guys with erectile dysfunction can be ready with another dosing option from cialis. cialis for daily use is a clinically proven low-dose tablet you take every day, so you can be ready anytime the moment is right. so relax and take your time. tell your doctor about your medical condition and all medications and ask if you're healthy enough for sexual activity. don't take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsa. don't drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long term injury seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than 4 hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision stop taking cialis and call your doctor right away. announcer: today you have options, 36-hour cialis or cialis for daily use. ask your doctor about cialis today so when the moment is right, you can be ready.
10:36 pm
10:37 pm
as if the hysteria over sarah palin's death panels hadn't been infuriating and embarrassing enough on our third story on the "countdown" we have the companion item, the death book. can tartar control death toothpaste be far in the offing? the death book as document produced by the va also used and updated by the bush white house. the claim, a pamphlet distributed by the department of veterans affairs encourages euthanasia and assisted suicide for soldiers. the premise first invented in "the wall street journal" op-ed by the former director of the office of faith-based initiatives under president bush promptly promoted on who else sarah palin's facebook page, her new job, she has a facebook page. then paraded out as truth with an assist from the endlessly clueless and partisan chris wallace on fixed news. >> here you have the government that has a financial stake in the answers that they give and i think a lot of people are afraid
10:38 pm
that somehow they're going to be steered toward a denial of care so whether there's death panel written in a law or not the real issue is why would the va be promoting a document written by an assisted suicide advocate that has such a kind of obsession with death and with pushing people i think in a direction to deny care? >> the document is actually called "your life your choices" and is actually a 52-page optional guidebook for veterans about living wills and end of life care. it has been in use since 1997. with the bush administration being the one that had its va issue a directive in 2007 to list the book as an example of the type of document doctors should give their patients if requested. the directive was updated in july by the obama administration. as huffington post reports, your life, your choices has the same advanced care planning required of all health care organizations under federal law. and it was developed with guidance from interfaith ministers. in response to the lies spread by mr. towey and promoted by mr.
10:39 pm
palace, the group votevets.org posted this. really if the document was really trying to get veterans to pull the plug on themselves then first suggesting to them that their life should be prolonged at all costs is a pretty stupid way to do it. joining me now msnbc political analyst, pulitzer prize winning columnist of "the washington post", eugene robinson. good evening. >> good evening, keith. >> death panels, the death book. what is next, the death home game, polyunsaturated death, or my favorite, the new cash for death program at your ford dealer? >> you know, i think you're being far too kind. i think they swing for the fences and go straight for death by democrat. vote for the democrats and you die. you die an awful death. vote for republicans you'll live forever. i mean, that seems to be the next logical step. >> yeah, well, they're pro choice, going to protest at grave yards hence forth. mr. towey went on and on about why is the government spending money on this? he has a nonprofit group called aging with dignity.
10:40 pm
again, this is on huffington post. he attempted to in the past get the va to distribute his own book on this subject instead of this one that has been in use under three presidents. and nobody is bothered by this blatant commercial interest, this kind of mendacious conflict of interest by this guy pushing the story on fox. >> i'm kind of bothered by it, keith. you know, i hope we can get past mr. towey and his hooey about, you know, he does have his own pamphlet that he'd like to put out there but consider the context. i mean, are we arguing that veterans should not be given information about their end of life choices? does that make any sense? it's -- it's -- this argument has become insane. it's become a fact-free zone. >> it's like an impression, an impression of what would scare people the most, what could we take that has a sliver of truth and possible credibility to it and exaggerate it into making it look like somebody is going to come and decide when to end your
10:41 pm
life. and can we measure the degree of irresponsibility and danger to not only mischaracterize a policy that the bush administration actually is sort of authenticating here but to tell our troops that a democratic administration is encouraging them to pull the plug? >> you could call it politically irresponsible and dangerous but on a human level, it's cruel. it's ridiculous. it's denying or seeking to deny to people who are aging a full set of options that they can sort through as they decide how to live their final years and their final days. i mean, this is, look. we're all going to be there. and we're all going to have decisions to make and our families are going to have decisions to make and you need information. >> sarah palin has linked the towey death book op-ed to her
10:42 pm
facebook page. one observation and one question. apparently having a facebook page is for people who are too lazy to have their own blog. two, wasn't she the same person who said in her great farewell address, in the name of the american soldier, quit making stuff up? >> yes, but she is also the person who said there was a department of law in the white house. and so we have to keep the context. here's the one takeaway from this, this whole discussion, though. you know, all of those countries that have socialized medicine and rationed care and, you know, the norways and the uks and canada and france and switzerland and those places we're supposed to be afraid of that they're going to have death panels or something like that or death books, they all have greater life expectancy than the united states. we're not number one, not number ten, we're number 35 according to the cia fact book. they're clearly not the ones sending people to an early grave. it's our health system that is sending americans to an early grave.
10:43 pm
but that, again, fact gets lost in the discussion. >> that's like saying oh, this'll impose rationing. well, we have rationing now. it's called rationing for rich people and poor people don't get any of the treatment that would be rationed out supposedly in the worst fears of the republicans and the new system. gene robinson, pulitzer prize winning columnist of "the washington post." also of msnbc, great thanks, and i'll see you at the meeting of the death panel. tomorrow a look at the health care giant no longer using a proxy as it is directly urging employees to fight against the public option. we'll introduce you to the people and practices of united health group who have driven reimbursement rates or driven the reimbursement rates of its own company to some of the nation's lowest and executive compensation to some of the highest, all that before congress even deliver as bill, early versions which have been described as a bonanza for the industry. reaction summed up in a single word by a former executive, hallelujah.
10:44 pm
told you so. the l.a. coroner's office has reportedly classified michael jackson's death as a homicide and glenn beck is back from suspension and back to busily killing the truth. do not cower in fear. the worst you could do is die without honor. and we're truly responsible for the freedom of this country. oh, how could anybody ever think that was an incitement to violence? coming up at the top of the hour on the rachel maddow show michael steele launches a patients' bill of rights which defends pretty much everything president obama is aiming for. m. [ female announcer ] trying to be smart with the family budget? here goes the good old steam. [ pfffft! ] whooa!!!! [ female announcer ] let bounty help... because it cleans the mess with less than the bargain brands. it's thick and absorbent. and really durable. in lab tests bounty absorbs twice as much as the bargain brand. [ steam hisses ] why use more when you can use less? bring it. with bounty. the thick quicker picker-upper. and try bounty napkins. now with new prints.
10:45 pm
10:46 pm
the michael jackson homicide investigation. first the worst. the duel resumes as lonesome roads beck comes back from suspension and a town haller calls himself a terrorist and a republican congressman calls the terrorist a great american. watching "countdown" on msnbc. special intere groups are trying to block progress on health care reform, derailing the debate with myths and scare tactics.
10:47 pm
desperately trying to stop you from discovering that reform won't force you to give up your current coverage. you'll still be able to choose your doctor and insurance plan. tell congress not to let myths get in the way of fixing what's broken with health care. learn the facts at healthactionnow.org. but i've still got room for the internet. with my new netbook from at&t. with its built-in 3g network, it's fast and small, so it goes places other laptops can't. i'm bill kurtis, and wherever i go,
10:48 pm
i've got plenty of room for the internet. and the nation's fastest 3g network. gun it, mick. (announcer) sign up today and get a netbook for $199.99 after mail-in rebate. with built-in access to the nation's fastest 3g network. only from at&t. gerald posner on the reported classification by the l.a. coroner's office that michael jackson's death was a homicide. next. but tonight's worst person in the world, to billo the clown. his simpleton's world view refuses to use any intellectual energy to arrive at his opinions. president obama's health care vision is confusing. it may also bankrupt the nation. that does not sound smart to me. the american people do not want to invest trillions of dollars in a big government program that's confusing. that would be insane. in other words billo doesn't like to read anything longer than five paragraphs unless there are pictures of puppies or girls.
10:49 pm
who said it would bankrupt the nation? what authority are you quoting? did you pose that possibility about say the pointless war in iraq? the far left doesn't want to hear it because those loons want income distribution and takes government run health care to do it. that's patriotism. if you take the same amount of money out of corporate profits and give it back to the people that's income redistribution. but clear thinking americans understand the whole deal as screwed up. the country needs a fresh start on health care. billy goes insane any time anybody accuses him of reading or regurgitating republican talking points yet there it is. the country needs a fresh start on health care. a virtual word for word repeat of the talking points from last week as presented by republican senator jon kyl. our runner-up glenn beck, the lonesome roads of 2009 now with 33 sponsor cancellations including a fox news wide one from u.p.s.
10:50 pm
back from suspension today with his tin foil hat all polished and freshly recrinkled. you can be rich. you can be poor but these czars are pushing people around, this system of government that is going on right now we are building at best a thugocracy. we are building massive unions, radicals, revolutionaries, they don't care. they've gone in this cloak of credibility. if you are afraid now, you will cower and fear all your lives. your children will also cower in fear and they will serve masters. do not cower in fear. the worst thing you can do is die without honor and we are truly responsible for the freedom in this country. we will be held responsible not only by god but also the founders when we cross the other side and they will say, what was more important than your children's freedom? the answer is nothing. there he is fomenting more violence against the government. glenn, you do realize when you go off on this paranoid, comical rants, you begin to sound like one of the mullahs, right? mullah glenn beck. is that better than lonesome roads or too offensive to mullahs? our winner republican congressman wally herger in
10:51 pm
front of 2,000 people in redding, scared about their health care and the choices, he not only said, quote, our democracy has never been threatened as much as it is today, but then some idiot in the crowd stood up and said, i am a proud right-wing terrorist. congressman herger replied, amen. god bless you. there is a great american. no, sir. that is not a great american. that is a man calling himself a right wing terrorist. even if he was being hyperbolic you're a u.s. congressman, damn it, bound by oath to uphold the constitution and if some buffoon in your audience describes himself with the word "terrorist" you are at minimum required to remind him what that means and how many americans have died at the hands of terrorists and you have to tell him to shut the hell up until he can come close to living up to what you told everybody in that crowd when your fascist rally started, they have to respect each other's opinions. if you can't, congressman herger, you're not entitled to
10:52 pm
serve as redding's dog catcher let alone in the house of representatives. congressman wally "right wing terrorist is a great american" herger, today's worst person in the world. announcer: here's ryan getting ready to make his approach... to the men's room. second announcer: looks like he needs to go urgently. true. and there's casey, about to drive... also to the men's room. he has been going over and over. they ought to see their doctors. could be male urinary symptoms due to bph, an enlarged prostate. for many guys,
10:53 pm
prescription flomax reduces their urinary symptoms due to bph in one week. and if their doctors do prescribe flomax, they could get up to $40 off new or refill prescriptions. so guys already on flomax can also save. only your doctor can tell if you have bph, not a more serious condition like prostate cancer. avoid driving or hazardous tasks for 12 hours after your first dose or increase in dose, as a sudden drop in blood pressure may occur, rarely resulting in fainting. if considering cataract surgery, tell your eye surgeon you've taken flomax. common side effects are runny nose, dizziness and decrease in men. ask your doctor if flomax is right for you. and call 877-4-flomax for more information and to see if you qualify for up to $40 off new or refill prescriptions. for many men, flomax can make a difference in one week.
10:54 pm
10:55 pm
michael jackson's death has been ruled a homicide. in our number one story on the "countdown" police are investigating his doctor for manslaughter. this a little more than eight weeks after jackson's death when we had asked, who or what killed michael jackson while officials were still insisting there would be no criminal investigation. the los angeles county coroner has ruled jackson's death a homicide according to law enforcement officials. a search warrant for the office of jackson's personal physician, dr. conrad murray, more
10:56 pm
detailed, quote, the los angeles chief medical examiner coroner indicated he had reviewed the preliminary toxicology reports and his preliminary assessment of jackson's cause of death was due to lethal levels of propofol, diprivan. a police officer said that agents had gathered, quote, items constituting evidence of the offense of manslaughter that tend to show dr. conrad murray committed that said criminal offense. further details from court documents, dr. murray told investigators he had been treating jackson for insomnia for six weeks giving him 50 mg of the drug propofol every night intravenously. on the morning jackson died dr. murray tried to induce sleep with three other prescription drugs before administering 25 mg of propofol. jackson went to sleep and then later died. eight weeks ago i asked investigative reporter diane dimond about the implications for a personal doctor in such a case. if have you a live-in doctor what does that mean? >> if you're a celebrity and have a live-in doctor, i lived in hollywood.
10:57 pm
you lived there, too. it means you have your in-house drug pusher is what you really have. i need an oxycontin please. i need a little demerol and they're on hand to do that for you. this doctor is pivotal to this investigation and, boy, i hope he's got a lawyer. >> let's bring in the chief investigative reporter of the daily beast and noted author gerald posner. thanks for your time tonight, sir. we've got a slew of information from various sources today. what are we seeing? >> we're seeing the inevitable. they're going to get an indictment. everybody is clamoring for somebody to be charged. it is going to be, as dr. murray said, i'm afraid of being made the scapegoat. i don't think he has a choice. he'll get a criminal indictment for manslaughter. >> it appears he cooperated with police. he described what he administered. he said he went to the restroom after he gave jackson the propofol the final time. is he trying to turn some sort of a deal here or did he set a trap for himself?
10:58 pm
because once it's been determined that jackson died from propofol, as you suggested, it's only a matter of time before murray gets arrested, isn't it? >> i tell you, it's only a matter of time until he gets arrested but the interesting thing is he's got six hours of conversations, interrogations with the l.a. police and according to his lawyers and to murray they told me last week he hasn't changed an iota of that testimony. i talked to those lawyers an hour ago and they said the affidavit today has the timeline wrong, it's made it up about murray leaving the room and there is other information in it that's just incorrect so what's interesting is we're taking the police affidavit as though it's fact but let me tell you i know this defense team is about to contest this. this isn't going to go down as a slam dunk for the prosecution. >> what is the role of the timing, gerald, between that video that dr. murray created and put on youtube last week or whenever it was and all this coming out? are those two things just concurrent or connected? >> no. it's connected. dr. murray has been cut apart by a thousand little pieces very
10:59 pm
effectively by one of the best leaking operations in the united states, the l.a. police department. they know when and how to leak. i've seen it before. they did it very well on simpson and here as well. the defense has held back. i think what we've seen so far is the indictment and conviction in the paper. look, the key here is they can't find any evidence that murray ever ordered propofol. jackson was being treated for propofol before hand. that's how he dealt with his insomnia. now you have a doctor coming in, murray, who says i think you're an addict. i'm going to slowly wean you off. and the concert promoter says don't do it in a clinic or hospital. make sure it's at home so nobody knows he is getting ready for his london tours. a lot of liability i think will still come out. >> as you point out the suggestion here is that dr. murray did not obtain propofol under his own license which suggests somebody else did. is there someone else to redirect that beam of prosecution onto him? >> i don't think you can redirect it onto them. what he's done is he has to show the responsibility for and the

149 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on