Skip to main content

tv   Breaking the Set  RT  December 5, 2013 12:29am-1:01am EST

12:29 am
after this we lost a good opportunity to start for and no way out of the political process and to nominate people here in madame the clearly demand we want the president to step down that's the way to solve the political crisis business the way to get closer to this decision agreement was the european union you mentioned earlier the brutal use of force by the police and we've all seen the footage from kiev and i think everybody including president unicom of himself recognize that the use of force was excessive and as far as we understand the investigation is underway and before that investigation was event completed the chief of police had to step down so don't you think that in demanding nothing last then the resignation of the president himself the opposition is being a bit excessive in its demands. well as of the moment we have heard some words not too many wars and we have seen no actions at all so not
12:30 am
a single police officer has been punished for it after this bloody saturday we have not seen the minister of internal affairs in the parliament he was afraid to come to see the m.p.'s we have not seen a single senior officer stepping down so actually people are so angry as of the moment because in the parliament they expected that those who were responsible for this bloody massacre here in the on my down would be promised that would be the first step to get closer to justice and we see we also know actions so it's seen i think for most of the people here and i was absolutely clear that the president's party of regions which did not vote. against the government share this responsibility with the police officers so everyone stood here and understands that it's clearly it was clearly the president of ukraine who gave the orders and who have to who has to be responsible for what happens here now mr shift chunk of the word revolution is back in use in key of these days and one thing that we learned
12:31 am
from the arab revolutions over the past couple of years is that you know bloodshed can start with a couple of broken ribs and a few concussions but it can very quickly degenerate into people actually being killed on the streets and compared to what we saw in egypt or syria thankfully the protests in the ukraine and even the police efforts to disperse that process while all of that were relatively civilized do you think the worst is now over and have you any concerns that if those rallies continued that they could be real blood being spilled in care. well there is one think we should makes the events in kiev these days very different from the arab revolutions and it's about the peaceful. brought to us every ten or fifteen minutes every speaker who is on this station says to the to the people we're a peaceful gathering of citizens we're not going to attack government buildings and
12:32 am
if you see anyone who who calls to go and attack the presence of mr nation or a different building that's someone who wants this revolution to be stopped so i think it's this is what makes this ukrainian process very different from when the revolutions which we saw in the middle east what makes this event similar to the arab it's the anger that people have and it's the gone one to which absolutely does not respond to what the citizens demanded of them well mr sharon case somebody who covered the arab revolutions extensively i can tell you that many of those revolutions started with peaceful rallies but from the very beginning there were some people some provoke a terrorist within the crowd and what we now are hearing even from western media is that there are people in in kiev who have been hurling rocks at the police people who have been using have a machinery such as an excavator on the streets all of cave and there have been
12:33 am
some of times to storm government buildings still count the opposition now guaranteed that people who have gathered behind your back will indeed abide by the law that the protest will be carried out in peaceful fashion i think i think you referred to one specific episode which happened on sunday a couple of blocks away from this place next to the presence of mr nation so as of the moment it's absolutely clear that it was broke a sion which was set up was the sort of the first of all there were there were no no one there were no protesters who were brought there by their position there was a small group of radical there was a small radical group which had nothing to do with the peaceful protests on the done second we know that most of them had the chance to go to to stay safe on the both sides of the police wall when. third that we went to the escalator and many people many people could see this this huge experience or right in the center right next to the presence of mr think not
12:34 am
a single car could enter downtown q but there was this extra weight to safely waiting for this crowd of radicals next to the presence of mr h. and there was a pile of stones well prepared for that so i think their position was really did something really good and important when we went there and pull some people out of there and so that's the one think about what we saw here on sunday about eight hundred thousand people peacefully standing on them i don't kandice think of the crowd of this size. it successfully states peacefully here and if you if you go to the dancers now you see a very peaceful crowd of people to be fair to the president in a call which he himself can down the use of force by the police he called it excessive and he also called on the opposition to abide by the law and abide by the democratic procedures that exist in any democratic country i want to play a sound bite from what he said and have you comment on that let's listen to what he
12:35 am
had to say. if we want european standards we must do everything within the framework of the law but this is the principle of democracy. elections are coming the people will decide to have originated. in the boot so essentially what he's saying is that if you want to be democratic just be democratic doesn't he have a point he's a century asking you to either way till next elections or wait until you have enough seats in the parliament to impeach him but as of as of now you don't have either of these opportunities. well we have heard a lot of words from mr and a caution this is that we have seen no actions i'm not sure you would be the best the best advocate for him but this man has done. this blood a set of the to punish those responsible once again not a single police officer was fired four days after after the events the minister
12:36 am
internal affairs is hiding from the press and is hiding from the public the prime minister came to the to the parliament and and was there enough to to say that harrison is fine and what was the country so once again president and of course has done nothing and i think from for every grain and in substance to clear that he is complete the person responsible for this crisis that the country is is in and once again of a goal is a legitimate change of power i think no one here wants a civil war no one here wants a coup that we want a legitimate change of power if unocal which feels confident enough if he wants this gone through to get out of the crisis let's do an early presidential election but isn't it also the case that the opposition at this point doesn't have enough seats in the parliament tuesday's vote no confidence vote in the cabinet is one proof of that and on the top of that you simply don't know how many people feel the same sentiment that is expressed on my don these days so why not wait just
12:37 am
a year to see and to allow these. legal procedure democratic procedure to take hold why do you why are you calling for a preliminary election for early elections when certainly the full scope of your democratic procedure is haven't hasn't been exhausted by now. well i think we can start and academical discussion on whether people who clearly see that something terrible is happening to their country should wait for the next presidential or whatever election but i think it's not really worth what we need to discuss it as of the moment look look what you can see behind my back as of the moment you can see congress of thousands of people staying here it's the eleventh day of this was it brought this as of the moment to be. our industries around the country and this think what we're what we're witnessing is an irreversible change it's a near irreversible shift here in this country but mr shashank and this is exactly
12:38 am
my point three the actions may provide for a very dramatic footage but it's not an accurate measure of democratic aspirations to match our democratic aspirations and why the ukrainian people want what you what you are calling for you need to have elections but you have only here on til the next election so why not wait. i think there are clear democratic tools which could help us find their way out of this political process first of all if we have the prosecutor general office which is capable of investigations that will tell us if we have responsible police officers who could quit their jobs that will help if we have a responsible government which can fire those officers who did this great things that will help finally if we're talking about the parliament the parliament could also do its part of the job but it's refused to do so today but once again every day that we don't know what to do in this in terms of procedures we get into a more dangerous situation mr i heard some commentators compare the current events
12:39 am
and key of to the orange revolution a couple of years ago and the most notable outcome of that revolution was of course the so-called project accredit forces with viktor yushchenko and yuliya tymoshenko and get the ukrainian people. after their coming to power. you know fairly quickly had a period of disenchantment and they were voted out of power so if the opposition manages to secure power once again what do you think should be done differently this time around to make sure that people's aspirations are indeed mad. well there is a lot of disappointment in petitions of all kinds here and there is some disappointed in program a critic forces as well but once again if you think about the last parliamentary election these three. does which are in opposition got majority of the votes votes in the party of actions at the last presidential election unit tymoshenko last year
12:40 am
and of course only three percent so we can say that it remains as a very competitive country in terms of politics and as of the moment to the point that the polls clearly show that people people are not tebow is what's happening in the country even before these events on the air around sixteen percent of the population support it what did the what you did his approval ratings went to historical low lowest even in the east of the concert so i think as of the moment vast majority of ukrainians clearly want changes ok mr shanker we have to take a short break now but when we come back in western media accounts ukraine often comes across as more than they cinderella caught between the well meaning european fairy and the exploitive russian stepmother is reality indeed so black and why that's coming out in a few moments on well the part. the
12:41 am
plentiful supply was terrible they weren't very hard to make out a little plots against along here a plug that never had sex with the target there are no legs let's play. lists lead legs. let's. listen to. a.
12:42 am
i think. over. digital the price is the only industry specifically mentioned in the constitution and. that's because a free and open press is critical to our democracy shred albus. role. in fact the single biggest threat facing our nation today is the corporate takeover of our government and across several we've been hijacked by handful of transnational corporations that will profit by destroying what our founding fathers one still just my job market and on this show we reveal the big picture of what's actually going on in the world we go beyond identifying the problem trucks rational debate and a real discussion critical issues facing america five ready to join the movement then walk a little bit. right
12:43 am
on the scene. first street. and i think pictures. on our reporters twitter. and instagram. to be in the know. on. deliberate torch is on its epic journey to such. one hundred twenty three days. through two thousand and nine hundred towns and cities of russia. relayed by fourteen thousand people or sixty five thousand kilometers. in a record setting trip by land air and sea and others face.
12:44 am
a limp dick torch relay. on archie's. welcome back to worlds apart a riyadh discussing ukraine struggle for democracy and a better future event duration a prominent ukrainian journalist and politician mr shift chant russia has been accused of intimidating his crane and you know coverage personally into submission and forcing ukraine to turn its back on a democratic dream why do you think moscow is being so mean to fellow ukrainians. i think russia and the criminal leaders have been very pragmatically they do want to keep ukraine close they do want to see ukraine as part of the customs union so i think the dam which evasion is very clear for me but i don't really think that is going to change a lot of things here in the recruiting because the west majority of ukrainians do
12:45 am
want to cream to go to go to the closer ties with the european union and sooner or later it was this president who was a different president i think will for the clear perspective of the association with europe now i heard your interview on b.b.c. radio the other day and he sat there quote just a couple of weeks we thought we were about to become one of the european nations and now we find ourselves under newly formed dictatorship in eastern europe something that you would expect in belarus or sometimes in russia now i'm not going to even argue with you whether russia constitutes a dictatorship i think that's a very farfetched statement but. don't you think that democracy is a bit too complicated than we trade union or reach. agreement to decide and to align yourself with don't you think that you give too little credit to your country of forty five million people by reducing it to a simple or maybe
12:46 am
a complicated but a single decision like that. i think you are perfectly right with that and if you listen to most of the speeches here on the under my done especially in the very first of the day my done it was really of. the european values and the ripping practices if we're talking about this decision agreement is about so two hundred of pages which do not mean changes right the way but for many years both the korean government and the korean opposition have been convincing the ukrainians that this decision agreement will be a solution to minor problems fighting corruption the rule of law democracy and human rights efficient economy and prosperity all those things could be much easier to reach with this decision agreement that's what was the government and the opposition have been saying for quite a long time so now with this with this turn towards stores russia did not just
12:47 am
throw away this decision agreement she stalled peace this wonderful dream for most of the ukrainians most of them really believed the believed that we begin to build something of what we have never had here a successful democratic country but mr shand i know that you have a very long track record of being an advocate of five human rights and speaking for me here freedoms in your country and i'm sure you know that building democracy takes years and it is not after you neighbor is there from your crane whether it is russia or the european union but rather to the ukrainian people so what favs them even with you know annoyed graham and signed with the european union what really stops them from building all those liberties within that own borders oh if we're talking about the citizens look at the polls clearly show that the majority of the ukrainians do want to ukraine to sign this station agreement even before the recent
12:48 am
events this number was more than sixty percent only about thirty. center wanted to create to join the custom soon and so the proportion is clearly in favor of the union i think the idea of building a successful ukraine without joining in the unions no matter whether it's the european union of the customs union is sometimes debated here in ukraine but i think it's absolutely gorgeous for most of the people. who fall of the situation in the economy and job politics that it could be much easier in a close association with european union. ok i would like to come back to this issue of russia suppose it intimidation the kremlin's position has been that this this dispute is all about economy it and that russia believes its economic interests will suffer if european goods will start sliding into europe into ukraine rather and later into russia tax free i wonder if you think that russia could have protected its economic interests in some other way without apply i'm due process
12:49 am
onto your crane was there any other way to go around this dispute. i find some of the economic arguments that you mention quite artificial and profound i think many people in ukraine feel that this pressure was not just about the economy it was pretty much about geopolitics and pretty much. absolutely mr shelley but let me stay on their own the question do you believe that russia is given its own right to protect its economy if it believes that this economy its market is being threatened by the possibility of you in european good coming into ukraine and later on. i think that to russia perfectly says the right to act according to its national interests as long as it does not violate the
12:50 am
international arrangements. russia has meant because first of all we have the framework of the a w two world trade organization and there were some clear big issues that russia took and including that if there were some problems with the partners inside of w two there are some instruments to solve that then if you remember in ukraine when ukraine was giving away its nuclear arms there was a special treaty and russia was part of that which clearly said that russia is never going to use economic pressure in some other kinds of pressure to influence their transposition so many people in ukraine clearly clear see that russia russia went into the zone which was very close to relation of these international obligations but once again it's not it's not just legal framework i think it's much more about the way this pressure was put on the countries see it was much more about the warden so i think many people here feel that it was a very hostile action towards ukraine well and what is it about their warning and
12:51 am
the way this pressure was put on to ukraine because as far as fires kremlin is concerned it was very straightforward about what will happen if you crane indeed decide to sign this association agreement and to the list of documents that you mentioned earlier i want to add the free trade agreement between russia and ukraine that clearly stipulates that russia is within its own right to withdraw from the agreement if the ukraine sides with signs any trade agreements with third parties so. when you say that russia violated some laws this is actually not substantiated at this point. but look i think not to go into very close legal debate which i'm ready for i'm prepared for but i think it's just part of the of the situation part of the problem i think that both in russia and in ukraine there were there were more than enough people who were happy to exaggerate this conflict and to use the situation for both and to ukrainian or enter russian propaganda inside
12:52 am
of the two countries so i think that clearly damaged the relation. of the two countries if we want to think long term we should find a proper solution for corporation of ukraine associated with the european union russia and the think it's in the long term russian interests to predictable partner here in q. well i think i would agree with you and one thing that russia and the european union definitely have in common is that they both want to have a prosperous and stable ukraine because if this crisis goes on all those people will go either you know ukrainian people will go either to russia or into the repeating union in search of jobs so i think neither russia nor the european union would be interested in that what do you think would be a compromise that would satisfy all three parties involved. well first of all to all those in russia who can hear us if you look at this madame you
12:53 am
should really realize that it's not against russia and it's not against their actions and it's not against running away from. seoul in internal ukrainian problems this people here want to want there have been future as as a good prosperous future for themselves so i think that. is very important of to find a legitimate solution here for ukraine but mr there is one comparison go i am making rounds here in moscow and ukraine is being compared to a lady who on the one hand takes money from an old and algal a gentleman but wants to spend her time with you know. young man but sometimes you you really have to choose i mean you cannot have both and it seems that ukraine is what you are really saying is that you crane wants to see that on the on two stools here it wants to have this free trade agreement with russia to reach gives the ukraine a lot of revenues but on the other hand it wants to associate itself both politically
12:54 am
and economically with the european you voice is sometimes. absolutely you used quite a risky comparison and if you use in that kind of amount of force i think you should clearly separate the present existing ukrainian authorities which have been negotiated in a very embarrassing way was both their opinion in the russian and ukrainian nation and i think if you think if you if you look at the least of these people behind me there is pressure is very clear and you're absolutely right it's about a clear choice between deposed soviet world and between the and between the european model of society and we perfectly understand what we are talking about it's corruption of the post soviet world and it's the rule of law for most of the contests of the european union is snake election of two human rights and civil liberties in the post of the world and it's a deep respect to human rights in the european union so yes you're absolutely right it's about the very clear choice and i think in these days this nation is really
12:55 am
making issues and i think there are there are many commentators now in moscow who believe that you know college has indeed shown himself as a very unpredictable and sometimes a very dangerous actor you know he's found as you said so much time negotiating with the european union on the association agreement he made a u. turn very dramatic u. turn at the very last moment he managed to put europe and russia a bit longer had but. did do you really think that these patrol of piano comment as as a russian muppet in the ukraine is really justified because this is the way this has this argument this dispute has been portrayed in western media that russia really wants to keep you know college in kiev which many would argue is not in russia's best interest. well i think if you portray in the. brush and. brush. i think it would be to lose their rights the right
12:56 am
way to understand him i think they're on the think what he really cares as a. moment is his personal interests it's he is. in the interests of his family of both in terms of his political influence and in terms of the economy and of running a business in ukraine once again i think it's personally in a close who holds the full responsibility. of the political crisis in ukraine that's the person who put the relationship between ukraine and russia into a very dangerous situation and that's the person who put the relationship between ukraine to be there have been union into this wary of mass that we can see it and so this that's why going back to the beginning of conversation most of the ukrainians feel that this man should step down from his present position he's personally responsible for this mess that the country is at the moment while i'm at the tank unfortunately as only time will tell whether this is going to happen but
12:57 am
we are out of time right now i really appreciate your perspective and to our viewers if you like the show please join us again same place same time here on while the party. form is probably the most complex and difficult to. answer still locked up. in the phenomenon of friendly fire probably extends back to the invention of gunpowder. just kill
12:58 am
a bunch of people you don't know if the premises are really us people. reading. this some shoots my brother in the leg not intentional because of it because it was night times four in the morning even the best given the belch shoulders. are going to make mistakes does this whole idea of brotherhood an author and camaraderie in this sense it was in this context it has absolutely no place. what defines a country's success. faceless figures of economic growth. or a factual standard of living.
12:59 am
dramas that could just be ignored. stories others the few. places. from around the globe.
1:00 am
syrian rebels kidnap a group of nuns from a christian monastery allegedly moving them to a nearby rebel controlled town as a christian community is increasingly caught up in the raging violence. i'm ready to pick up an a k forty seven and start shooting we'll look out the radical right wing groups that have hijacked the demonstrations in kiev as more european leaders throw their weight behind protests in ukraine. is humanitarian aid from the european union and altogether these products make up around a third of all the stuff here. aid for the plagued by unemployment and a recent study shows over twenty percent of you rick.


info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on