Backward error initialization and parasitic mode control are well-suited for use in algorithms that arise from a discrete variational principle on phase-space dynamics. Dynamical systems described by degenerate Lagrangians, such as those occurring in phase-space action principles, lead to variational multistep algorithms for the integration of first-order differential equations. As multistep algorithms, an initialization procedure must be chosen and the stability of parasitic modes assessed. The conventional selection of initial conditions using accurate one-step methods does not yield the best numerical performance for smoothness and stability. Instead, backward error initialization identifies a set of initial conditions that minimize the amplitude of undesirable parasitic modes. This issue is especially important in the context of structure-preserving multistep algorithms where numerical damping of the parasitic modes would violate the conservation properties. In the presence of growing parasitic modes, the algorithm may also be periodically re-initialized to prevent the undesired mode from reaching large amplitude. Numerical examples of variational multistep algorithms are presented in which the backward error initialized trajectories outperform those initialized using highly accurate approximations of the true solution.