, professor alison young, professor of public law at cambridge university. what do you make of what sirjames eadie has been saying? he is trying to draw out the unconstitutional role of the courts. and do they have —— to be able to go off and control it? he says they are political controls and there are no legal limits but some of the questions he has had from the justices of the supreme court had been saying, what if this was for too long? what if you did breach a constitutional principle, it is our job to defend that and surely we can intervene there. thank you very much indeed. that is being heard right now. let's go back now to sirjames eadie, qc, representing the government on day two of the supreme court hearing. that provides no answer and no distinction between dissolution as the paradigms examples, the fourth point i can make very shortly in terms of the generality and that is that this is not a context which is about rights. this is not miller, this is not any of those cases in which the traditionally identified areas have been eaten into. it is not about rights. those

law, deputy chair of the faculty of law at the university of cambridge, fellow of saint catharines college. he also served as the legal adviser to the house of lords select committee on the constitution. and on the third page, in the final paragraph, the court sees that leads on to the question whether notwithstanding all of the foregoing, the answer to that question, an answer that largely follows the foregoing analysis is surely no. this is so because of what once the issues are clearly understood, the court does not need to do in order to answer the releva nt to do in order to answer the relevant legal question. it is correctly pointed out that supplementary authorities tab 13 that it supplementary authorities tab 13 thatitis supplementary authorities tab 13 that it is misconceived to suppose that it is misconceived to suppose that the exercise of the prorogation of power necessarily involves matters of high policy. it's exercise is almost always mundane. and he says it is possible to go even further in the present context and argue the issue at stake is justiciable because it d

understood to be an academically has been at the university of cambridge in britain, and also teaching at an australian university. there are reports she is the mac has beenjailed university. there are reports she is the mac has been jailed for university. there are reports she is the mac has beenjailed for ten yea rs. we the mac has beenjailed for ten years. we do not know what sort of charges are offences she has alleged to have carried out. ten year sentences are often handed down for foreigners who have been suspected of spying. we do not australian authorities are leading efforts in tehran for the release of these three individuals. a bit of reaction for you after the decision that the prorogation of parliament is unlawful and mps have cold for parliament to be recalled. we have the welsh labour mp who has said on twitter, it should be prime minister's questions. parliament has illegally prorogued. i have come to the chamber. no sign of the prime minister. if you go into his tweet, there is a reply from his colleague saying, iam there is a reply from his colleague saying, i am headin