after he left the saudi consulate in istanbul. said the consulate was also following up and coordinating with the turkish authorities to discover the circumstances of her show she's disappearance. the bloomberg news agency published a statement by mohammed bin cell man on wednesday the 3rd of october before the official saudi press agency followed suit 3 days later. mbia said quote my understanding is he entered and he got out after a few minutes or maybe one hour adding that his shoji was not inside the consulate and that quote if he's in saudi arabia i would know it this is on a dark thank you wolf like when they wanted to. actually look at all the baking i mean the army tick. tick on christmas well there was some money you know i didn't get it thanks for the service or to the mother i mean. i thought my god you know. the bomb was for the thought of course if i get me back to germany in court for all wondered if the bus could be adequate to duty and any other were scared to return or. at the very 1st beginning of the event has b

after he left the saudi consulate in istanbul. it said the consulate was also following up and coordinating with the turkish authorities to discover the circumstances of her show she's disappearance. the bloomberg news agency published a statement by mohammed bin cell man on wednesday the 3rd of october before the official saudi press aide. see followed suit 3 days later. m.b.'s said quote my understanding is he entered and he got out after a few minutes or maybe one hour adding that showed he was not inside the consulate and that quote if he's in saudi arabia i would know it listen all of our conference like me in the army take. some water action look at all the big made army tick. tick i guess not so there is someone there when i get it thanks for the service or to the not i mean. i thought my god you're an equaliser. the bomb was full of the thought of course if i get me back to jim i didn't call forth on whether the bus could be an acquittal did he and floating any other were scared to return or. at the very 1st beginning of t

this is the saudi consulate in istanbul, turkey. we only know jamal khashoggi was murdered and the brutal way in which it was done because the saudi consulate was bugged by turkish intelligence. the planning and the execution were all recorded. agnes callamard negotiated access to these crucial recordings. the intention clearly on the part of turkey to give me access to those calls was to help me prove planning and premeditation. joining her investigation team was british barrister helena kennedy. she took detailed notes. there was a discussion about, will the body and the hips fit in the bag this way? they are two of the very few people who have been allowed to hear the tapes. about halfway through, they say, you know, "you shouldn't be taking all of these notes," and i said "well, i'm sorry," and then, you know, i carried on doing it. istanbul — where east meets west — the city where jamal khashoggi spent the final weeks of his life. hi, i'mjane. he was here with his turkish fiancee, phd student, hatice cengiz. translation: th

after he left the saudi consulate in istanbul. it said the consulate was also following up and coordinating with the turkish authorities to discover the circumstances of her show she's disappearance. the bloomberg news agency published a statement by mohammed bin cell man on wednesday the 3rd of october before the official saudi press aide. see followed suit 3 days later. m.b.'s said quote my understanding is he entered and he got out after a few minutes or maybe one hour adding that showed he was not inside the consulate and that quote if he's in saudi arabia i would know it listen all of our conference like me in the army take. some other action look at all the bacon i made the army tick. tick on christmas will there be some money there when i get it thanks for the sort of solitude not by me but for my garden. but i'm watchful of the thought of course if i get me back to jim i didn't call forth on whether the bus could be adequate to duty and float him some good to me or they were scared to return or. the very 1st beginning of t

after he left the saudi consulate in istanbul. said the consulate was also following up and coordinating with the turkish authorities to discover the circumstances of her show she's disappearance. the bloomberg news agency published a statement by mohammed bin selman on wednesday the 3rd of october before the official saudi press agency followed suit 3 days later. n.b.s. said quote my understanding is he entered and he got out after a few minutes or maybe one hour adding that he was not inside the consulate and that quote if he's in saudi arabia i would know it. on a dark. like me and i wanted to. actually look at all the big tick. tick. well there was some other. men. yeah and it cannot. be done watch for the thought of course if i get me back to do what i call forth or what the dish maybe i shouldn't be able to do the end floating near they were scared to return or. at the very 1st beginning of the event has been happen mr advani or can assert that on earth kingdom also go our authorities clearly show that he has left because la

after he left the saudi consulate in istanbul. it said the consulate was also following up and coordinating with the turkish authorities to discover the circumstances of her show she's disappearance. the bloomberg news agency published a statement by mohammed bin cell man on wednesday the 3rd of october before the official saudi press agency followed suit 3 days later. m.b.'s said quote my understanding is he entered and he got out after a few minutes or maybe one. our adding that shows he was not inside the consulate and that quote if he's in saudi arabia i would know it listen all of our consul fucked me in the army to kick. some other action look at all the big name in the army take a job when it's hard to pick up this muscle there was someone there why didn't i get it thanks for the service or took the not by me but the my god you're an equal in. the bomb was for the thought of course like me back to jim i didn't call forth on what the dish may have washed or the bus could be adequate to do the hand float of some good children

as a terrorist organization but then as your guests in in istanbul in turkey saying that the turkish government sat down with a terrorist organization because i don't think you can reject the truth that the turkish government sat down with the p.k. k. between 20132015 this was the right thing to do because there is absolutely no reason to perpetuate this conflict right now the turkish government took the p.k. k. as the other side of this conflict and sat down and tried to solve this age old question ok now about why i don't think the old discourse and rhetoric holds any water anymore a gentleman in of course as you know another major concern is what will happen to nearly 12000 i saw fighters held by kurdish forces in syria if indeed turkey goes ahead with this operation some 2000 of them are foreign fighters including from france germany and the u.k. but european governments have refused to take them back earlier we spoke to a journalist molly sweeney who recently interviewed people trapped in northeastern syria take a listen. the turks have been threatening this area for years now i

the hundreds of polices well that's it for me it just now i am going to hand you over to our team in istanbul for special wife kept ridge over her shortly anniversary memorial. one year ago at this exact moment 1 14 pm on a tuesday afternoon jamal khashoggi journalist father fiance walked into the saudi arabian consulate in istanbul to collect papers for his upcoming marriage he never walked out hello i'm come out santa maria here in istanbul as we examine the murder of jamal khashoggi the conspiracy the lies and the injustice. whatever the seconds it will forever be linked with this city the day that a journalist was silenced in a way few of us could have ever imagined and spunked outrage on an international scale we are on air for at least the next hour speaking to those closest to show g. to those close to the investigation into his death and to our own correspondents in and around includes. he is outside the saudi consulate were a vigil is being held right now there is andrew symonds who is at the turkish prosecutor's office where the murder file still sits and with me here in our studio

let's bring in our sponsor in istanbul a some reports have suggested that even the turks were caught by surprise by the president's announcement of u.s. troops withdraw from northern syria i wonder what's going on in their minds right now whether this threat by the u.s. president to obliterate turkey's economy if in his words they do anything he considers off limits what are the turks making of all this painted if you're looking at the looking at the issue from the from ankara and istanbul you can see that there is a mass standing over there ok and this mass is of washington must know the mass of turkish american relations on the one inside there's a president just between of ours he is telling that he is indorsing a turkish possible operation order in syria and secondly he is just threatening turkey true to its devastated turkish economy on the other side the pentagon which should be ruled by the president it is dragging its feet to to apply the orders of the president and this when you look at the issue from took his perspective it is a mass and this mass is an american mass the tr

members of the so-called hit team which charged over the killing a member of the consulate staff in istanbul was also indicted 5 of them face the death penalty but one major participant sanctioned by the us for his part in the planning and execution of the operation still hasn't been charged that men sowed tanny he tweeted in 2017 that he's a trustworthy employee who carries out the orders of his boss the king and his boss the crown prince sir from our studio position here overlooking the bosphorus let's go out into stan bowl and start with anders them and see if that the turkish prosecutor's office and andrew what developments are there one year turkey has been the one driving this car is driving the investigation what developments are there. very few right now and that's the point kemal there is a focus as you saw in my report on what was happening in the run up because all the evidence points towards a very large state organized murder mission in which the target was jamal khashoggi and the seams the murder was top of the list in the options and now in terms of evidence they've done all t

footage of 15 saudi government agents arriving in istanbul on the day of the killing and leaving just hours later among them a top adviser to saudi crown prince mohammed bin. the us and us come out told that left little doubt was conducted and done by state official who said it used it create lined upon state and resources. that came into. a private chat with diplomatic clearance. the murder drew global condemnation. denied all involvement in the killing recently he gave a us t.v. interview defending himself in the run up to the anniversary shows he's fiance had to change told that was a calculated move. these statements made at this particular time seem like an attempt to quell pressure from the public mohammed bin soundman said he accepts responsibility but at the same time he says he didn't know anything about it and in doing so he's trying to dodge responsibility the saudis have officially blamed rogue elements instead and put 11 people on trial for the murder amnesty international told you it seized little value in that. there is. a trial process apparently going on in saudi arab

andrew symonds live from outside the prosecutor's office in istanbul thank you. well the death of a virgin. has resonated around the world andrew thomas reports from a protest in sydney australia. this protest outside the saudi consulate in the center of sydney has been organized by human rights groups and saudi refugees in australia to mark the 1st anniversary of the murder of your mouth but it's not just about marking that grim anniversary it's also people here say about continuing the sort of work that he was doing speaking out about human rights abuses in saudi arabia and the imprisonment of political prisoners by journalists inside the country and protesting the ongoing export of weapons to saudi arabia while the war in yemen rages marcus was a brave champion of human rights and many many human rights defenders around the world and saudi arabia standing up today and calling for justice calling for an investigation into his standing with the more than 30 political prisoners that continue to be locked up in saudi arabia for nearly speaking out for their rights

now it's been one year since jamal khashoggi answers the saudi consulate in istanbul to say documents for his upcoming marriage he never came out alive today family friends rights activists and media freedom groups are in istanbul for immemorial to shoji investigations by turkish officials indicate that he was killed and dismembered by a saudi hit squads so the crown prince mohammed bin some man says he takes responsibility but denies ordering the killing of his fiance is demanding answers from riyadh and the crown prince monley dot. com it is meaningful that this was broadcast close to the october 2nd date it sounds to me like it was something that was said to weaken or listen public pressure secondly if that is not the case and it was carried out under the crown prince's responsibility then we would have the right to ask him about the details then why was jamal killed and why has the public not been informed about the death until now i am talking about the details for instance we don't know where the body is his funeral prayers have not been performed there is no period of if he car

but we start off in istanbul with the 16th edition of the city's by o'neill which features more than $220.00 works by $56.00 artists turkey has one of the oldest and proudest artistic traditions in the world and yet today with scores of journalists and intellectuals in prisons as a result of government crackdowns on freedom of expression the country can be a hostile place for contemporary art all the more kudos then for a show that continues to find ways to push the envelope. of the. continent echoing current concerns it's about plastic waste climate catastrophe and visions of the future. infused with the paintings of spaniards and 1960 s. depicts a man trapped in a surveillance state under the. franco power dials to remain in turkey may not be entirely coincidental i work here exactly as i would have been working in your building or paris i didn't care about any possible censorship. so just how free is the art scene in istanbul and turkey in new auto museum is privately financed and organized it has cleverly retreated into various individual exhibitions. of modernism. and the critic

well probably around this time it's 10 minutes to 3 in the afternoon in istanbul here probably around this time one year ago was outside the consulate making those phone calls to turkish operatives making the calls which jamal told her to make if he didn't come out now she stands here at a memorial this is some of those pictures overlooking. the memorial memorial stone that's going to be unveiled i guess that they're under the white cloth it's simple. correspondent emotional times and i mean i just thought just looked at the clock later and thought i imagine this as she said it's broken but proud woman pacing up and down we saw her on the c.c.t.v. pictures pacing up and down outside the consulate exactly and not knowing that life is about to get completely turned upside down exactly i mean she's she she's one of the sad sides of the story of course along with his own family his films and daughters and other family members but of course. the teacher had to carry a lot of burden during this crisis and she have to deal with media actually have to deal with the police you have to deal wit

was murdered inside the soul the consulate in istanbul turkey today supporters of kosher meat called for justice at a memorial service that was held in istanbul a united nations investigation has found what it calls credible evidence linking sold the crown prince mohammed bin selman to the murder but a year later none of the masterminds has been brought to justice for the killing. of 1 14 pm friends and family marked the time to show she was last seen alive a moment of silence to commemorate his murder and the sense of a crime gone unpunished in the years since i still see justice i want to know what happened to he's body i once he sprang to be released from jail i want those in power i hold accountable for day actions 1 14 pm one year ago a c.c.t.v. camera captured cars shoji walking into the saudi consulate in istanbul his body is believed to have been dismembered and disposed of saudi arabia initially hampered turkish efforts to investigate but i'm correct had audio recordings of exactly what happened in turkey also released c.c.t.v. footage of 15 saudi government agents arriving

well friends and rights activists are holding a memorial in istanbul outside the saudi consulate that's the place where to mock killed and our correspondent yulia han is there for us can you tell us what's been happening where you are. while there is a memorial service for mr the show just a little further away from where i am it started at 114 local time marking the moment the right to walks into the building right behind the saudi consulate a year ago and we all know he never emerged today the building is basically sealed off the lot of police and security around as according to my information no one from the saudi state is present here today it's mostly human rights activists other journalists friends of mr the shock she ended his fiance who came together today to calm the memory mr bush. and to have what they call is a moment of silence because they say this is exactly what his killers wanted to silence a man a journalist who had always refused to be silent who openly criticized the saudi kingdom one of the speakers today is the. midst of a fiance it's a particularly painful day for

well joining me now via skype from istanbul is sin then again he is a visiting professor at carnegie europe thanks very much for being with us so how close is the relationship then between presidents trump and one or the relationship is indeed quite close because president traum has been in regular dialogue with the turkish president are gone and as we see in this case he took on board are the ones arguments and decided to give the go ahead to the turkish across the border military operation and his stance is not the difference than what we heard from the others pillars of the u.s. administration and primarily pentagon and we when we look at the turkish economy and president trump personally does does he have a conflict of interest because of the trump towers in istanbul he doesn't own the towers but does license his name. yes obviously that's the definition of conflict of interest and given that he has this business venture in turkey. even though as you rightly said he doesn't all the property nonetheless gets a license fee based on extending his franchise so in that sense yes there

joining us here in our studio is cynical so you are istanbul correspondent so it's a year to the moment effectively. at what point on either this stay october 2nd or october 3rd did you find out the news and then begin reporting on it well actually on october the 2nd in late afternoon everybody heard about i mean the officials heard about your mouth to shoot you not getting out of the consulate building because. forms of turkish officials we all know the story and we wanted an. news package but you know that when somebody is missing there's always the hope that 1st there was a hole a maybe he was taken out to somewhere else for interrogation or something else but he could have. he could see him from somewhere and so on the 2nd day it was obvious that something was exactly going wrong or what do you remember you started doing the live reports and then you start feeling ok this is this is not right this is not normal this is something different. that one of the things that i can share is that when i went in front of the consulate building on october 3rd it early morning there i met her te

prosecutor's office in istanbul. it's been a year since the murder there been any developments on that front. well you have 1st of all before answer your question the mood of the solemnity 7 kilometers away at the consulate and the anger that there's been no justice in this case is contrast it with a mood of sadness but also frustrated because this is the offices of the investigation team the prosecutor general's office there is a whole mass of evidence inside and preparations for what many had hoped might be a court case in turkey with extradition of the suspects from riyadh but really there is no chance of that saudi arabia is standing for let's look at the numbers we have 15 people likely to be indicted at some stage whether or not there's an extradition or not there will be indictments released possibly all certainly they exist against those 15 suspects along with another 3 who will be accused of being complicit in preparing things in terms of saudi arabia is a cold case really closed with secrecy of the highest

and the mood is heated up in istanbul as well. took processes be a vulgar us. honey so if they are from the come or guard i don't want to live in this neighborhood and in this country anymore it's maybe. i just try get along with most of the syrians say if there are some bad people but you get that everywhere. get out the bag we want them to leave as soon as possible we don't want them here any more now he's saying. turkish president regift type ad one has recognized this change in public sentiment he has made repeated promises that millions of syrians will return home to a so-called safe zone he wants to establish in northeast syria the government insists there are no deportations and that syrians who are returning are doing so well in terror really. america checker goes disagrees the attorney is trying to help get offered racial son back from syria mohammed and his family have valid turkish documents and protection status chucker goes has filed an appeal with turkey's constitutional court. and the whole sending a person to a war zone is a serious human rights

dying jones is standing by for us in istanbul daryn what's istanbul's reaction to the u.s. threats well perp resident heard one in a very tough speech said we're not going to step back we're going to continue with this hope operation even though we are facing what he describes as threats from the left i'm from the right from everywhere and he outlined that that the scope of the operation is to create this safe zone of 32 kilometers into syria and which it will be all the syrian kurdish militia or terrorists as ankara calls them will be removed from that area so there is no stepping back from across in fact if anything they are ramping up the pressure on the syrian kurdish militia and there is expected to be a further. acceleration of the of this operation given the fact that encore is aware it is under increasing international pressure. and kurds are fleeing this fighting understandably where are they seeking shelter and who's helping them. well that is the big fear among all aid agencies we've already understand that around a 100000 people have been displaced by the fighti

as a terrorist organization but then as your guests in in istanbul in turkey saying that the turkish government sat down with a terrorist organization because i don't think he can reject the truth that the turkish government sat down with the p.k. k. between 20132015 this was the right thing to do because there is absolutely no reason to perpetuate this conflict right now the turkish government took the p.k. k. as the other side of this conflict and sat down and tried to solve this age old question ok now about why i don't think the old discourse and rhetoric holds any water anymore a gentleman in of course as you know another major concern is what will happen to nearly 12000 i saw fighters held by kurdish forces in syria if indeed turkey goes ahead with this operation some 2000 of them are foreign fighters including from france germany and the u.k. but european governments have refused to take them back earlier we spoke to a journalist molly sweeney who recently interviewed people try.

was murdered inside the saudi consulate in istanbul turkey a u.n. investigation found what it called credible evidence linking saudi crown prince mohammed bin solomon to the killing but a year later none of the masterminds has been brought to justice for the murder and western partners seem to have forgiven saudi arabia. a c.c.t.v. camera captured the last images of journalist jamal khashoggi he was walking into the saudi consulate in istanbul where he would be brutally murdered what happened inside this building shocked the world. body is believed to have been dismembered and disposed of his remains have never been found. she was an outspoken critic of the saudi leadership since 2017 he had lived in self-imposed exile in the u.s. i was a columnist for the washington post. after he was murdered saudi arabia initially hampered turkey's efforts to investigate but eventually riyadh admitted she had died in the concert at the state television spoke of an argument that had broken out with shock she being killed in the ensuing brawl. but the consulate bui

as a terrorist organization but then is your guests in in istanbul in turkey saying that the turkish government sat down with a terrorist organization because i don't think you can reject the truth that the turkish government sat down with the p.k. k. between 20132015 this was the right thing to do because there is absolutely no reason to perpetuate this conflict right now the turkish government took the p.k. k. as the other side of this conflict and sat down and trying to solve this age old question ok now i don't see why i don't think the old discourse and rhetoric holds any water anymore a gentleman in of course as you know another major concern is what will happen to nearly 12000 i saw fighters held by kurdish forces in syria if indeed turkey goes ahead with this operation some 2000 of them are foreign fighters including from france germany and the u.k. but european governments have refused to take them back earlier we spoke to a journalist molly sweeney who recently interviewed people trapped in northeastern syria take a listen. the turks have been threatening this area for year

rather going back to istanbul now we go to andrew simmons outside the prosecutor's office and we've got jamal who is outside the saudi consulate of course jamal this is where the crime was actually committed and there's an whole array of people and groups who are determined for this crime to be remembered. indeed martin and they are organizing a memorial service will begin the exact minutes on this last year of the street and to that building and then dumping this memorial service martin as a moment of silence and the idea behind this name is a century sending a defiant tone to those who murdered. that this bites their attempts to try and silence a free press to try and silence somebody. had written about what he saw as either corruption or oppression not just inside eurabia but also in the wider arab world that those attempts to silence those voices will not succeed far from its they have given birth true more determination amongst other groups so you have colleagues of his from the united states you have human rights activists you have his fiance you have politicians from egypt for ex

camera captured shoji walking into the saudi consulate in istanbul his body is believed to have been dismembered and disposed of saudi arabia initially hampered turkish efforts to investigate but i think are a had audio recordings of exactly what happened turkey also released c.c.t.v. footage of 15 saudi government agents arriving in istanbul on the day of the killing and leaving just hours later among them a top adviser to saudi crown prince mohamed bin. the us and us kalamata old d.w. that left little doubt was conducted and done by state officials say it used it create lined upon state and resources. that came into. a private chat with diplomatic clearance the murderer drew global condemnation. denied all involvement in the killing recently he gave a us t.v. interview defending himself in the run up to the anniversary because shows he's fiance had to change told that was a calculated move. these statements made at this particular time seem like an attempt to quell pressure from the public mohammed bin soundman said he accepts responsibility but at the same time he says he didn't k

s julia han has more tonight from istanbul. we've seen an emotional ceremony here today for jamal khashoggi it started shortly after 1 pm local time marking the moment he walks into this building right behind me the saudi consulate here in istanbul a year ago and we all know he never reemerged today his friends human rights activists his feel say and also jeff bezos the c.e.o. of amazon and also the owner of the washington post which was a regular contributor gathered here to commemorate his life and his work and to them on justice and also to have what they call a moment of unsigned because that's what his kill is one to they say to silence a man a journalist who would always refused to be silent to openly criticize human rights violations in saudi arabia and that's probably one of the key messages of the day that critical minds critical voices like mr should never be intimidated into silence that his murder actually turned him into a bigger symbol for press freedom and freedom of opinion worldwide. reporting from. well for mo

well friends and rights activists are holding a memorial in istanbul outside the saudi consulate the place where it was killed and correspondent. there for us good to see you give us an idea of what is happening where you are. well the memorial service for jamal is about to start actually it's scheduled to start at $114.00 local time marking the moment the saudi rider walked into the saudi consulate that's the building right behind me a year ago and we all know he never reemerged the saudi consulate today is basically sealed off there is a lot of police and a security around according to my knowledge no one from the state from the saudi status taking part in the ceremony today it's rather human rights advocates it's other journalists midst of a g.'s friends and his fiance who came together to commemorate him and to have what they call is a moment of unsigned because they say that's exactly what the killers wanted to silence a man a journalist who had refused to be silent this is of course a very painful day also for his turkish fiance had teacher who count even visit a grave because

elma xeni had returned to istanbul from jeddah that day with a deadly plan. to eliminate the saudi journalist jumbo. when we're out of the numbers on the 21st of june 2017 mohammed bin selma was made crown prince of saudi arabia. 2 weeks later a major diplomatic crisis blew up in the gulf between saudi arabia and 3 of its allies and cattle. also that june another writer close to be in selma on advised either to take part in the campaign against qatar or to leave the country ashaji chose to leave saudi arabia he flew from jeddah via london to the united states. the pressure increased i believe into 14 or to 15 when he was banned from writing minster of information decided to publish the letter burning from our from writing so i think you found the very insulting you should remember the german was banned from tweeting and writing articles white. because his dog or a lot of speak. of the. conciliation we did worked. for i think 171 is there in. version 230 no he just has to do it right i showed you had studied journalism at indiana state university in the early

thank you to my panel and my audience here in istanbul and, of course, to all of you wherever you're watching or listening on tv, radio or online. from me, zeinab badawi, and the rest of the global questions team, goodbye. hello. that we can ? ?nosapce ‘s weather continues on that fairly unsettled, autumnal note. more rainfall sunday and this comes from anglesey —— the weekend ? ? nosapce ‘s and this comes from anglesey —— the weekend ? ?nosapce ‘s weather. many places will see rain at times on sunday but more sunshine and dry weather later, especially in the south and west. we won't all see the rainfall but generally through the day we've got low pressure still in charge setting out to the west and a couple of weather fronts to watch out for today, producing heavy bursts. first thing sunday morning we've got clear spells initially for the far south—east of england and parts of east anglia but the rain will soon sweep in here and as it moves north and east across the bulk of england and wales, it will bring showers to eastern parts of northern ireland and southern and

>> well, i also have a little conflict of interest because i have a major, major building in istanbul. and it's a tremendously successful job. it's called trump towers, two towers, instead of one.