Skip to main content

Full text of "NASA Technical Reports Server (NTRS) 20050220658: Overview of the Aerothermodynamics Analysis Conducted in Support of the STS-107 Accident Investigation"

See other formats



C/5 
co H 
o C n 



5 O N 
CD O ° 
> CO 


0 c n 
> > 

O 03 
c 

< 


o 

o 

CM 


Q_ 

< 


CD 

-t— < 

C 

_ 0 
CD O 

-§_ 0 

E 03 
03 Q- 
o CO 


co 


o 

C/3 

C 


£ x: 

fe o 

6 < 

cf) 

< 



and et. al 




Aero/Aerothermo/Thermal 

Organization 



QQ 


O 

O 

Q_ 

Q. 

3 

0 


~o 

0 

E 


c 

0 

0 

-Q 

0 

0 


J= = 

0 o 

S 1 

CD o 

c x 

O I 

» I 

'4= '-C 
C CO 

1 ■§ 

O) 0 

0 o 
O o 
CD _J 


0 


0 

c 


< 

CL 


n 

co 


c >*■§ 

C -D 

-2 -S co 

C ^ 0 

CO o 0 

-c ° 0 
CL DC OC 

I I 0 
O) D) i- 

c c o 

■© '0 LL 
O O .1= 
CD CD < 


I I I I 


E 

0 . 
0 c 
l- o 


0 

N 


0 

O) 

c > 
0 c: 

E>Z 

O c 

V © 

•J 3 "O 


o 

o 

0 Q 

0 CO 


0 JO 

c E 

0 =3 
O O 

iE ^ 

3 0 


o 

DC 

0 


I 

< 

CO 

< 


0 
0 

E 
< 
l I 

< < 
CO CO 
< < 


0 

-Q 

0 

c _] 

o _ 

O 0 g 

CO o S 

5 1 to 


I X 

CD 0 

•E T 3 
0 C 
O 0 
Z CD C/) 


I 

< 

CO 

< 


I I I I I I 


CN 


0 

'0 


0 

0 

> 

0 

c 

< 

(J) 

0 


0 0 

C - - 


< 

0 

i_ 

3 

-t— • 

O 

3 

i_ 

CO 


0 

0 

s_ 

3 

-t— • 

O 


CD 0 ^ 

.E E °3 

"c 0 CO 

0 .c CL 
> 1 - 1 - 

1 I I 


if 

o 


CL 

0 

CL 

0 

3 

>> 

CO 

0 

4— 

c 

0 

0 

0 

0 

O 

CO 


0 

E 

< 

0 

c 


>. 

"co 

TD 

O 

O 

i_ 

"c 

0 


< 

0 


0 

I 

t- 

1 

• 



0 

'0 

0 

c 

0 

0 

O 

E 

0 

c 

>, 

■O 

o 

E 

0 

.c 

H— » 

2 

0 
< 

1 


o 

E 

0 

c 

> 

Q 


■g 

‘3 

LL 

0 

c 

o 

'-1— > 

0 

-t— > 

3 

CL 

E 

o 

O 


I 


Direct Simulation Monte Carlo - TPS & Structural Materials Testing 

Wind Tunnel Testing - Coupled Venting/Thermal Analysis 

Plume Modeling 


Investigation Organization 




J 


» 


External Internal 

Environments Environments 

Chuck Campbell Steve Fitzgerald 














1 


1 1 

8 

i 

5 


e 

s 

? | 

1 1 1 

] 


! 

• i 

1 

£ 

8 


i 

i 

I 

! 

2 s 

s s 1 

i 


< 5 

• 


* 

s 

* 1 


s 


! < 

r 

3 

i 

1 

P 

i' 

1 

§ 

!_ 

J 

iii 

HI 

i 


11 

] 

5 

.1 

I 

i 

J 

s 

t 

f 

LJ 

S 

I 

I 

L 

! 

i 

f 

1 ! I 

Li 


9 £ - £ 

i i $ s r 
?t a 1 3 ? 

o^ l hi 
3 3 5 g li 


qqqqq^ 


£££• 


Jjj|3S 

■gfciSga 

lull 


£ CO 

O o 

fS 

I 


g? 

.E lu 

H Q£ 

1 JL 

rc co 

fro 

S -! 1 

£ * 

.2, o 

cu a. 


r>. — 
© ro 
TT C 




Produced by NASA/JSC - EG/Aeroscience 
Broome) 







Indications from 01 Telemetry Data 



Horvath 



Aero/Aerothermo/Thermal Analysis Process 



Confirmed 

Scenario 













§ 

o 



o 



[d 03Q] 3UnjLVU3dW31 


Id 93al aaruvaadwai 


td 93 a] 3univa3difl!3i 


(d 93 a] samvasdwai 


Id D dal dUniVHddWdl 



\ 

1 


1 

t— 

1 

LU 

O 

< 

r~ 

i 

& 
=> 
c n 

i 

j 

LU 

Q 

— 1~ 
i 

c n 

3 

cn 

=> 


U_ 

i 

i 

i 

i 

i 

i 

ad 

CD 

l— 

r- 

o 

i 

i 

> 

i 

_J 


side fuselage and OMS 
pod temperatures ~ El+340s 






Leading Edge Structural Subsystem 





External Aerothermal Environments 


o 





, : Internal Heating 

Aerodynamics Environments r* Thermal Analysis 

Analysis I . 1 1 


























Surface Heating & Temperatures 

Radiation Equilibrium 



Heat Flux & Stanton No. 



Orbiter Wing Leading Edge Damage Survey 






C ' 

£n. 

1 

m ~ 



CAD definition provided by NASA JSd 




siuamuo-HAug |eiwaij}Ojav |eujaju| 




Energy Balance 1-D Heating 2-D Heating 3-D Heating 











Orbiter Wing CAD Model 



CO 

E 



2 I o3 




Note: Wing Skins Not Shown 




Aerodynamic Flight Reconstruction 
















Chronology of 

Aerodynamic/Aerothermodynamic Contributions* 

2003 

February March April May June 








Assessment of specific damage scenarios 






















JU0OKHU 6uu*eA ej|3Q 


JU9LUOUJ 6tlj||OJ B)|3Q 


♦ Run 29 multiple trips 

ht residual moment * -0.00015 
476 sec) 

L 1 



















<c 

0) 

CO 


<0 

.</> 


□ 




O) 


(0 

<D 


O) 


0 

< 


CO 3 


c “ 

E a> 

J TJ 

(0 O 

® f » 

■*• © ca 

& c 
O) (Q to 

W CL o 
®8 2 

a> -o 

TJ 0 -[ 

c/) ^ a, 8 

S E * 

!5 O g 1 

TJ 


O 

II 


a> 

E 


o ^ 


>*r <0 
° t 

2 1 9 
>°- 


® 5 


■■S 2? 


Q) 

— V#/ 

Q. c 

X </> 

t- 

II 

!t 

CO 

C 

LU 

>- 

cc 


u. 

(J 

0. 






c 

£ 


O 

O 

q: 


£ 


a> 


O) 

(0 

o 

O 

<0 

a: 

t 

s 

E 

o 

as 

CO 

<u 

c 

O 

c 

>» 

■Q 

a> 

o 

</> 

•C 

o 

1_ 

a> 

D) 

<0 

E 

0) 

0 


< 

05 

D 


"co 

a> 

15 

c 

> 

to 

o 

0 

to 

a> 

o 

E 

O) 

-j 

■ MM 

u. 

0 

2 

0- 


Q. 

X 

LU 


r ^ 

, J I 



||OJ BJ|9p 




-CJ 

-C> 


oq 











< 







Aero-Aerothermal Closure 














Tt 

<N 


JJr ^ O) c 
W q) 0) x: 
So-o 



© 

!c 

c 

3 

0 

X 

i_ 

© 

■0 

% 

c 

© 

§ 

s 

1 

c 

© 

© 

’© 



o> 

X 

m 

<Z) 

© 

§ 

c 

_© 

© 

E 

■6 

§ 

’© 

0 

< 

T3 

- k_ 

© 

s 


—3 

CD 

HI 

2 


ro c y - 
2 -2> * 3 


-d 

CL >, 

- a) ._ 
x: it to 0 

IsSI-f 
S 1 1 1 e 
s | s l n 

^ 2 Q u. W 


c := 
©<5 0 
© 2 
o> . a: 
.2 * „ 


^ £ © 
C <D Ct 
CO o m 


cH g o 

c -o -C (D C 5 o 

© o 3 X O CO © 

O H- * O O * 5 


(0 

CO fe 

C s 

CD | 

E * 

CD 1 
D) - 

“8 I 

$ 1 
O 2 

c ^ 

-* 1 
o | 

< £ 

00 

E 



Q 

c 


-d 

0 


Q_ 

© 

© 


Q. 


JX 

E 

1 

§ 

0 

SZ 

to 

0 

I- 

© 

— 

2: 

>> 

© 

X 3 


JZ 

O 

© 

0 

m 

be 


Q 


to 

to 



© 

-d 

Q_ 

0 

O 

© 

-C 

T 3 

8 

5 

E 

§ 

-0 

5 

© 

© 

JZ 


.r = sr .r © ,b 

ir qq $ a: ^ > 


c a ~ 

o o .E, 

C c o 

S £ § 

o a: ° 


-S | 3 d f 

S S' <3 is§£ 

mm ^ C p LJ cju-__iw^ 


£11“ l -i 1 1 s It 

^6°w^wo6£2 


© 

c O) 
to 00 -O 


ZJ o t 
CD O ^ 

-e b q 

i!g 


— ra u n u ^ 

C O) © CO y o Z 
> *^ ±i a) 5 “ n 

Q ^ j- © p - 
= p c ^ > 

•-5 .b © _ 03 

$ i- * < a 


.ro -o 

i | x 

03 u- (0 

o c =3 

£ -g f 

£ I 8 

O CD O 


£ 3 ^ 1 ? 

■g E 5 2 
.2 © o ra 
a: co cc x. 


< © m 
© m co 
| E *fe 
co 2 


© C0 O 

I s 1 

.5 ® 5 

_ W m 



■D E 
c m 0 
© t/> -3> O 
b © -Q ^ 

D 'r r O 

n ^ t t-j 


Hill 

S“f ?8 

Hill 


| © e => I .e 
oI^-Sm^E©icl 

© /k - 1 - ©S>'©'o^5 t 9 

JE#S ®(00-=£ 2 r 

CL^^COOCLU-QrOLi-CL 


^ © © ^ b- O © o 

fc -QCO©trococto 

F -Q © = 3 5 -a :p c 

b m . — : 1 in L ■= 


2|3 


I® « f ifs s 


J ^ o 2 © s 
> to -o ^ 5 5 


c 

c 

= E 

-X -* , 
_o to o : 
^ -Q 3 
^ O © 
m CD £ I 

© -g 03 

s| £ 

* 2 C3 


* 


in 

<N 


TJ 

© 

3 

C 

C 

o 

o 

c 

o 

4-» 

tf) 

3 

o 

X 


09 

c 

8 

CQ 


<D 

>. 

0) 

TO 

O 


0 ) — 0 ) 
■* © 5 

m W *0 

O' 3 P 

<D ^ C 
TO TO 9 > 

c > g 


O) 

o 

5 

c .c 


| II- 

i- 5 
e d 


O TO 
1 TO 


^ < 


u ^ 

TO TO JS -X . . 

KDW J 


CD X 
§ £ 


X 

O 

(Q 

© 

CQ 

c 

0 

09 

c 

1 

3 

X 

I 

o> 

c 

© 

o 

CD 


TO 
O CD 


c 
c = 


> 

f f si &*i ° 

ffl I o c § i 
c © Q *= u 

S | S3 1 S 1 5 g 

^^QU-llO^OQ 


T3 

TO C ■ 
v x 


^ c 
£■ « 


« 8 
TO £ 


C 

2 

L- 

ra 

E 

o 


E 

oo 

to 

© 

E 

TO 


C 

© 

O 

© 

o 

TO 

a 

co 

>» 

■a 

© 

c 

c 

© 

* 


09 

E 

© 

o 

CQ 


TO 

CD 

c 

TO 

a 


"O 

0 


c 

o 

O 

CO 


c 

© — 

° S 

8 ^ 

Q. ■§ 

C S 

S W 
(/) © 

Us 

-9 > O 


< 

< 


00 


c 

© 

o 


© 

>> 

© 

O) 

c 

TO 

-J 

< 

< 

z 


o 

to TO 
= CO 

X TO 

•§ S’ 

m w 


TO 

a 

x 

o 

i- 

TO 

TO 

© 

TO 

IX 

U> 

TO 

E 

< 

< 

<o 

< 

z 


8 

c 

TO 

5 

TO 


8 

CO 


c 

© 

O 

■*-> 

X 

a> 


a 

co 

75 

X 

2 

TO 

s 

< 

< 


3 2- 
x ro 
M- o X 

3 CO CO 
^ o> c 

TO TO X 
0-0 
— > O — ) 


c 

o 

■*-* 

TO 

3 

O 


a> 

c 

© 

o 

CO 


Q. 

TO 

— c 

i_ a) ^ 

TO $ TO 

c E m 

CO CO 

s m 

TO 


c 

TO 

CO 

c 


< -g 

*o CO 


o 

c 

c 

CO 

x 

CO 


TO 

TO TO TO 5 

'd c ^ 
ro x - U 

CQ O o co 

r £! O) C 

_F O 3 C 
O O O TO 

co a a 


o 

-O 

CO 

c 

O CO 

O -g 

^ TO 
CO Q 

TO E 

o F 


CO 

^ TO 

-g 1 2 

s S 

c E 
TO E 
* % 

m ■= 
CO o 

CO ^ 


c 

C TO 

S?E 
>> E o 
o> ° z 

Z z O 
e- T3 O 
TO > « 

X To E. 
I- Q TO) 


0 

E 

0 

Q) 

■o 

0 


E 

re 

a> 

«T 

n 

3 

CO 

re 

E 

<s> 

.c 


c 

© 

O 

© 

o 

TO 

a 

CO 

c 

o 

to 

c 

X 

o 

-> 

< 

<0 

< 


TO ~ 

f=- O) 

•g o _ 

“ 1 5 

| s c 

^ CO O 


TO = 

P TO 

I «■ 

I I | 

O 5 

TO v CO 

o O 
6 -8 


TO 


TO 

c 

TO O) 
Q. 1= 

O 6 

TO >s 
O tT 

o ™ 
-a X 


6 o 

*c o 
LU Q 


TO 

3 

Li- 

ra 

o 


CO 

Q. 

TO 

Q_ 

TO 

Q 

c 

TO 

> 

TO 




CO CO 


3 

Q 

TO U “ 

I s 

o 2 

CQ CO 


T3 

TO 

TO t_ 
O) TO 

& 1 
LL O 


E TO 


r _ 


TO H 
TO 

3 ^ 
X c 

.2 to 

UJ ^ 


o 


TO 
-o 
c 

CO 

= 

0 CO QC 

Z D- 0) 

s I I 

Q H CO 


CO 

E 

JiC 
^ O 


CO 


N C 

0 o 

3 « 

O) ^ 

o -o 
OC o 
>, * 

TO p ^ 

^ ‘ Q. 

TO 


TO 

'c 

CO 


•O TO 
o > _ 
a: < co 


o 

< 



E 

re 

o 

*7 

3 

CO 

0) 

o 

E 

re 

c 

> 

-o 

o 

E 

k_ 

o 


4 


o 

E 

o 

JD 

CO 


© 

c 

>% 

*D 

I 

o 

0 
X 

1 

Ol 

c 


CQ 


P ■§ 

g s 


O < 


I a 

3 TO 

CO Q_ 


TO . 
E TO 

II 

»_ co 
TO TO 

o> F 

Ǥ! 


c 

r 

co 

■O 

© 

© 

JC 

j*: 

o 

o 


2 

TO 

o 

E? 8 

S|3 
° o nj 

CD Q CL 
c TO c 

a g s 

co h- 


cq a: 


ro 

X 

8 

C 

o 

c 

o 


I 

o 

■O 

ro 

X 

TO 


2 

Q. 

2 

O) 


CD 

X 

*< 

X 

"O 

E 

ro 

© 

CD 

c 

© 

X 

o 

-p 

TO 

a 

CO 

ro 

LL 

CO 

ro 

i 

CQ 

it 

5 

m 

O 

TO 

o 

c 

x 

X 

CO 

s 

O 

co 

© 

Q- 

i 

< 

o 
— ) 


2 5 3 8 

P x .2 to 
0! 3 J 2 
X u- O) TO 
A E to 
q c I -g 
u ra r ~ 
CO > N 2 


■c 


E TO 

s " 

co 

> 3 


— -c P 


co 


c 

3 

S. 

5 


© 


o 

XI 

m 


_ Q 


© 

c 

o 

3 

© 

Z 

© 

’■6 

c 

re 

co 


x 

CL 

TO 

« 

CQ 

E 

o 


O Q 

x x: 
0- CL 


Q a 


s | 
2 | 
CO ^ 

© o 

CQ DC 


Q. 

E 

© 

t— 

TO 

X 

O 

E 

© 


TO 

£ 

£ 

*8 


£ a 

s£ 

TO 8 

It 

X CL 

© -a 
O LU 


o d 


X 

CL 

TO 

Xd 

© 

QC 

■c 

< 


>i 

o 

cc 

co 

-C 

o 


VO 

<N 


“O 

CD 

"O 


O 


O 

o 


(/) 

c 

CD 

E 

CD 

O) 

"O 

CD 


£ 

o 



■O 

a> 

3 

C 

c 

o 

o 

E 

a> 

h- 

n 

3 
C 0 

15 

E 


a> 

c 

>> 

•a 

Q) 

JC 

o 

o 

a: 


O) 

c 

‘(I) 

O 

CO 


c 

CO 


w o 


I 8 

w « 


tf) 

a> 


o 

n 


co z 

x « 


co 

O 


c 

to 


CO 


<0 


co a: 


c 

o 

to 

^7 (O 

a) o 
o> ^ 
q. 

— CL 
CO “o 

O LU 


<D 

& 

CO 

a: 

< 


re 

c 

o 

V-< 

re 

c 


re 

o 


a. c 
a. o 


x 


^ m _ co 

8 § © I 

c a. E w 

• b 5 z 

u 


CO 


(O 


E o 


o 


cc 


- 1 § 
< a. a: 


■o 
c 

CO 

8 5 

o w 

U. ai 



Lockheed Martin 

Stan Bouslog 
Bill Rochelle 
Jim Milhoan 
Matthew Vogel