Skip to main content

Full text of "Nodal superconductivity and non-Fermi-liquid behavior in Ce2PdIn8 studied by 115In nuclear quadrupole resonance"

See other formats


Nodal superconductivity and non-Fermi-liquid behavior in Ce2PdIng 
studied by 115 In nuclear quadrupole resonance 

H. Fukazawa *, R. Nagashima, S. Shimatani, and Y. Kohori 

Department of Physics, Graduate School of Science, Chiba University, Chiba 263-8522, Japan 




D. Kaczorowski 
Institute of Low Temperature and Structure Research, 
Polish Academy of Sciences, P. O. Box 1410, 50-950 Wroclaw, Poland 

Nuclear quadrupole resonance measurements were performed on the heavy fermion superconduc- 
tor Ce2PdIng. Above the Kondo coherence temperature T co h — 30 K, the spin-lattice relaxation 
rate 1/Ti is temperature independent, whereas at lower temperatures, down to the onset of super- 
conductivity at T c = 0.64 K, it is nearly proportional to T 1 ^ 2 . Below T c , 1/Ti shows no coherence 
peak and decreases as T 3 down to 75 mK. All these findings indicate that Ce2PdIn8 is close to 
the antiferromagnetic quantum critical point, and the superconducting state has an unconventional 
character with line nodes in the superconducting gap. 


u . 









PACS numbers: 74.20.Mn, 74.70. Tx, 74.25. nj 


The interplay between superconductivity and mag- 
netism is one of the central issues in strongly corre- 
lated electron systems (SCES) An excellent play- 
ground for the systematic study of the mutual rela- 
tionship between the two phenomena is a series of 
Ce-based heavy-fermion compounds with the formula 
Ce n MIn 3n+2 (n = 1,2, 00, M = Co, Rh, Ir, Pd) @- 
[Toj . In these intermetallics, the magnetic correlations 
arise from the Ruderman-Kittel-Kasuya-Yosida interac- 
tion and the Kondo interaction, which are both driven 
by the hybridization of localized 4/ electrons and itiner- 
ant conduction electrons. Unconventional superconduc- 
tivity has been discovered, e.g., in pressurized CeLri3 Q 
and CeRhIn5, [3| as well as in CeCoIns under ambient 
pressure conditions. [|| In each case the superconductiv- 
ity emerges near a magnetic instability at T = 0, i.e., 
the quantum critical point (QCP). Other Ce„MIn 3 „ +2 
phases are also good candidates for the investigation 
of mutual relationship among dimensionality, quantum 
criticality, and superconductivity, because their crystal 
structures can be viewed as a regular stacking of the 
three-dimensional (3D) Celn3 and quasi-two-dimensional 
(quasi-2D) CeAfIn 5 units (see Fig. 1). 

Recently, the compound C^Pdlng was reported to 
exhibit normal- and superconducting (SC)-state prop- 
erties very similar to those of CeCoIn 5 . 0, Iilr{l7| 
This compound is a heavy-fermion superconductor with 
T c ~ 0.7 K and the normal-state electronic specific heat 
coefficient of approximately 1.5 J/K 2 mol-fu. 7]. Above 
T c , the electrical transport shows distinct non- Fermi- 
liquid (NFL) behavior, i.e., linear-in-T electrical resistiv- 
ity, highly anomalous T- and iJ-dependent magnetoresis- 
























• Ce 

. M(Co, Rh, 
Pd, Ir) 

• In 


CeMln 5 (n=1) Ce 2 Mln 8 (n=2) Celn 3 (/?=co) 

FIG. 1: (Color online) Crystal structures of the Ce„MIn3 n +2 
[M — Co, Rh, Ir, Pd) compounds. 

tance, and Hall, Nernst, and Seebeck effects. 0, ITTr - lpi ] 
In parallel, the electronic specific heat ratio CJT shows 
a logarithmic temperature dependence. @, [HI [IH, UU 
Moreover, it has been established that the hydrostatic 
pressure or magnetic field can tune T c towards T = 0, 
and clear evidence for the magnetic field-induced QCP 
near the upper critical field H C 2 ~ 2.3 T has been 
found. [HI, H3] As for the superconductivity, it has been 
shown that the most probable candidate for the SC gap 
symmetry is the d-wave. [Pol [t7| Thermal conductivity 
measurements in applied magnetic fields have revealed 
the presence of residual density of states (DOS) at the 
Fermi level. (l7| Furthermore, recent penetration depth 
measurements using a tunnel diode resonator have also 
indicated a nodal-line structure within the SC energy 
gap. [lH Both T c and H C 2 are considerably lower than 
those derived for CeCoIns, 0, Q and this difference is 
probably a direct consequence of the fact that the crys- 
tal lattice of Ce2PdIng has a much less 2D character than 
that of CeCoIn 5 . 

The fascinating phenomena in Ce2PdIns have been re- 


i i i i i i i i i I i i i i i i i i i I i i i i i i i i i I i i i i i i i i i I i i i i i i i i i I i i i 

4.2 K H5| n(3) 





1 F 15 ln| 


■ * 




: ^ rin 

■ 8 

53 54 

■ f (MHz) 








|i i hi i ill i Ai tfflL 1 1 £fi 

10 20 30 40 
f (MHz) 


1 1 i*i ^ 


FIG. 2: (Color online) In-NQR spectrum of Ce 2 PdIn 8 . [II] Inset: 4vq lines of In(3) site for 113 In and 115 In nuclei. 

vealed by bulk property measurements. To the best of 
our knowledge, no microscopic or site-selective studies 
have been performed so far, which would contribute to 
a better characterization of the magnetic properties in 
the normal state and the unconventional SC behavior 
at the lowest temperatures. In this paper, we report 
on our 115 In nuclear quadrupole resonance (NQR) mea- 
surements of Ce2PdIng. The NQR data corroborate the 
aforepostulated quantum critical and nodal SC features 
in this compound. 


A polycrystalline sample of Ce2PdIn§ was synthesized 
by the arc melting method, as described in Ref. [Hj]. 
The quality of the product was checked by x-ray powder 
diffraction and energy-dispersive x-ray analysis, as well as 
by measurements of the bulk properties. The sample was 
found to be a single-phase with a fairly sharp SC transi- 
tion at T c ~ 0.65 K. [3] For NQR measurements the ingot 
was powdered in order to reduce the heating-up effect at 
low temperatures and improve the signal intensity. The 
115 In NQR studies were performed in the frequency range 
of 7—60 MHz using a phase-coherent pulsed NQR spec- 
trometer. Measurements were carried out above 1.5 K 
using a 4 He cryostat and below 1.5 K with a 3 He- 4 He 
dilution refrigerator. The spin-lattice relaxation time Ti 
was obtained from the recovery of the nuclear magneti- 
zation after a saturation pulse. T c was estimated to be 
0.64 K through ac susceptibility by measuring the tem- 
perature dependence of the characteristic frequency of 
the NQR sample coil / co ii (see the inset in Fig. [3]). 


Figure [2] shows the NQR spectrum of Ce2PdIn§ taken 
at 4.2 K. As can be inferred from Fig.Q] there are three 
inequivalent crystallographic positions for indium atoms 
in the unit cell of Ce2PdIns: the most symmetric site, 
In(l) (4mm); the less symmetric site, In(2) (mmm.); and 
the least symmetric site, In(3) (2mm.). For the In nuclei 
(/ = 9/2), the electric quadrupole Hamiltonian 'Hq is 
given by 

where eq, eQ and rj represent the electric field gradient 
(EFG), the nuclear quadrupole moment, and the asym- 
metry parameter of the EFG, respectively. By diagonal- 
izing Hq and considering the three inequivalent In sites, 
one can assign all the observed features in the NQR spec- 
trum. For each In site, four resonance lines occur with 
increasing frequency: 1vq 1 2vq, %Vq and 4z^q. The Ivq 
line corresponds to the transition between \I Z = ±1/2) 
and \I Z = ±3/2), the Ivq line is due to the transition be- 
tween \I Z = ±3/2) and \I Z = ±5/2), etc. Note that lv Q 

differs from the resonance frequency i>o = 2 i(2i-i) exce Pt 
for the case of 77 = Q. The obtained NQR frequency i/o 
and the parameter ij are 8.08 MHz and 0.00(1), respec- 
tively, for In(l); 10.37 MHz and 0.12(1) for In(2); and 
13.37 MHz and 0.27(1) for In(3). At around 20.4 MHz, 
the 2vq line for In(2) and the Iz/q line for In(3) acciden- 
tally coincide with each other. 

As is apparent from Fig. [21 no NQR signals were ob- 
served other than those arising from the 113 In and 115 In 

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1- 


i — i — i — i — i — | — i — i — i — i — r 

7" =0.64K 

1 2 
t (msec) 

FIG. 3: (Color online) Nuclear magnetization recovery 
curves of Ce2PdIn8 at 0.45, 7, and 20 K. Solid lines denote the 
fitting curves discussed in the text. Inset: Temperature de- 
pendence of the characteristic frequency of the NQR sample 

COil / co il. 

nuclei in Ce2PdIn 8 . [19j | This finding confirms the qual- 
ity of the specimen, which was free of any clear parasitic 
phases that were found in Ce2CoIn 8 and Ce2 Ruing. 
The line- width is about 1.8 times wider than the cor- 
responding line-widths of single-crystalline CeCoIn 5 || 
and Ce2CoIn 8 [l(|. This line broadening may signal 
some structural disorder in the sample studied and/or 
may arise due to averaging EFG in the powder sample. 
With decreasing temperature, the resonance frequency 
increases and then becomes nearly constant below ap- 
proximately 10 K. The width of particular lines does not 
change with decreasing temperature, since the compound 
remains paramagnetic down to the lowest temperature 

The spin-lattice relaxation time T\ was derived over 
the range of 0.075—150 K at the frequency of the spec- 
tral center at each In site. The nuclear magnetization 
recovery curves were analyzed in terms of the quadru- 
ple exponential function appropriate for the nuclear spin 
/ = 9/2 of the 115 In nuclei [20]. For example, for the 4Vq 
line with r\ = the following formula was applied, 

! _!^ = 0.1212 expf-H 

( 21t 
+0.297 cxp ( - — 

0.5594exp ( 

(U)224<..x|,(-^) .(21 

where m(t) and mo denote the nuclear magnetization af- 
ter a time t from the NMR saturation pulse and the ther- 
mal equilibrium magnetization, respectively. For In sites 
with a finite rj, the modification of the recovery curve 
was adopted from Ref. [2l[. The above theoretical for- 


10~ 1 

TTTT] 1 1 — I I I I I 1 1 1 1 — I I I I I l| 1 1 — I Mill) 

■ln(2)4v Q 
>ln(1)4v Q 
^ln(1)2v^ J 

•ln(3)3v I JPP\4 

i i i 

0.01 0.1 1 10 10CH 

■ ■ ■ ■ I I I I I I I i c I 


1 10 



FIG. 4: (Color online) Temperature dependence of the spin- 
lattice relaxation rate 1/Ti at the three inequivalent In sites 
of Ce2PdIng. Inset: Temperature dependencies of 1/Ti at 
the In(l) site of Ce2PdIns and CeCoIns, normalized at the 
respective T c . The 1/Ti data on CeCoIns were taken from 
Ref. @1. 

mula accounts for magnetic relaxation only, and the re- 
covery curve becomes more complicated if quadrupolar 
relaxation is involved. [2(| As is apparent from Fig. [31 
all the experimental data, even those taken at the lowest 
temperatures, can be well approximated by this function 
using a single-component T\. This means that indeed 
the magnetic relaxation is a primary contribution to the 
behavior of the compound studied. 

The so-obtained temperature dependencies of the spin- 
lattice relaxation rate 1/Ti in Ce2PdIn 8 are displayed 
in Fig. 3J For the In(l) site, 1/Ti was evaluated from 
the 2^q and 4^q lines, and the results were found to 
perfectly overlap at 1.5 K, thus proving the reliability 
of the determination of 1/Ti. As shown in Fig. QJ the 
relaxation rate 1/Ti is largest at In(2), and smallest at 
In(3). This tendency is the same as that of isostructural 
Ce 2 CoIn 8 and Ce 2 RhIn 8 . [Io| 

From the bulk property data, Ce2PdIn 8 has been char- 
acterized as a Kondo lattice with the characteristic tem- 
perature (T co h — 30 K) that signals the crossover from 
the high-temperature incoherent to low-temperature co- 
herent Kondo state @, (HI 03 • I* 1 nne with that scenario, 
the relaxation rate 1/Ti is nearly temperature indepen- 
dent above T co h, as expected for fairly well localized 4/ 
electrons of trivalent Ce ions. Below T co h and down to 
0.7 K (~ T c ), 1/Ti varies approximately as T 1 ' 2 . This 


temperature dependence is distinctly different from the 
Korringa relation T^T = const, appropriate for Fermi 
liquids. In turn, it is quantitatively similar to that of 
Cclrlns , which exhibits well-established NFL behavior in 
the normal state. [alSl Thus, the 1/Ti data on Ce2PdIn§ 
are fully consistent with the NFL features observed in 
the bulk properties of the compound. @, ITT14l7j 

At the onset of the SC state, 1/Ti decreases rapidly, 
without the Hebel-Slichter coherence peak, and then 
varies nearly proportionally to T 3 down to the lowest 
temperatures studied. This behavior is quite similar to 
that found for CeCoIn 5 (see the inset in Fig. 2]) and 
Celrln 5 , d, Q and it hints at a nodal character of the 
SC energy gap. It is worth noting that down to the low- 
est measurement temperature of 75 mK (« T c /9), no 
saturation in 1 /T\ (T) is seen, which would be caused by 
some admixture of paramagnetic impurities. 

The T 3 dependence of l/T x in the SC state, m conjunc- 
tion with the absence of the Hebel-Slichter peak below T c , 
indicates that the SC gap in Ce2PdIn 8 has a nodal char- 
acter. In general, the nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rate 
in the SC state can be expressed as 


1/Tioc / {N s (E,A(T)f + M s (E,A(T)) 2 } 

xf(E){l- f(E)}dE, (3) 

where N S (E,A(T)) is the DOS, M S (E,A(T)) is the 
anomalous DOS arising from the coherence effect of the 
Cooper pairs, and f{E) stands for the Fermi distribu- 
tion function. The energy gap A(T) in this equation 
can be anisotropic, and thus more precisely it should be 
written as A(T,9,ip). Assuming that the SC gap has a 
simple horizontal line node in g-space, i.e., A(T,9,(p) = 
A(T)cos#, and taking into account that the integral of 
Ms(E,A(T)) effectively vanishes due to the alternating 
sign change in A(T, 9, ip), one can properly reproduce the 
experimental l/Xi(T) data on Ce2PdIn§ in the entire SC 
range studied (see the inset in Fig. [4]). On the contrary, 
no satisfactory description of 1 jT\ (T) could be obtained 
with an isotropic SC gap, even if the anomalous DOS 
term is omitted. The calculations yielded 2A(0)/fcBT c = 
5.6, which is very close to the 2A(0)/fcBT c = 6.4 derived 
for CeCoIn.5 by means of the analogous analysis of the 

NQR data. [1] The similarity in the SC gap amplitudes 
in the two compounds provides more support for the hy- 
pothesis on the d-wave symmetry of the SC order param- 
eter in Ce2PdIng, formulated before on the basis of the 
bulk property data. [l5l Il7| However, in order to reach 
a definitive conclusion on this issue, further experimen- 
tal efforts are necessary, among them NMR Knight shift 
measurements performed on single-crystalline samples. 


An NQR study on the heavy-fermion superconductor 
Ce2PdIng has revealed distinct NFL behavior of the nu- 
clear spin-lattice relaxation above the SC critical tem- 
perature T c = 0.64 K. The temperature dependence 
1/Ti oc T 1 / 2 , observed up to T co h ~ 30 K, indicates that 
the compound is located close to the antiferromagnetic 
QCP instability. In the SC state, 1/Ti shows no co- 
herence peak and it is proportional to T 3 at least down 
to 75 mK. These features manifest unconventional su- 
perconductivity with line nodes in the SC gap, proba- 
bly of a character similar to that in CeCoIns. Further 
NMR/NQR studies in applied magnetic fields and/or un- 
der high pressure, performed on single crystals, would be 
highly beneficial for microscopic characterization of the 
properties of Ce2PdIns near the field- or pressure-induced 


The authors thank S. Ohara for fruitful discussion. 
This work was supported by Grants-in-Aid for Scien- 
tific Research (Nos. 21540351 and 22684016) from 
MEXT and JSPS, Innovative Areas "Heavy Electrons" 
(No. 21102505) from MEXT, and the Global COE 
and AGSST financial support program of Chiba Uni- 
versity. The work in Poland was supported by the Na- 
tional Science Centre (Poland) under Research Grant No. 

[1] S. Sachdev and B. Keimer, Phys. Today 64, 29 (2011). 

[2] N. D. Mathur, F. M. Grosche, S. R. Julian, I. R. Walker, 
D. M. Freye, R. K. W. Haselwimmer, and G. G. Lon- 
zarich, Nature 394, 39 (1998). 

[3] H. Hegger, C. Petrovic, E. G. Moshopoulou, M. F. Hund- 
ley, J. L. Sarrao, Z. Fisk, and J. D. Thompson, Phys. Rev. 
Lett. 84, 4986 (2000). 

[4] C. Petrovic, P. G. Pagliuso, M. F. Hundley, R. 
Movshovich, J. L. Sarrao, J. D. Thompson, Z. Fisk, 
and P. Monthoux, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 13, L337 

[5] C. Petrovic, R. Movshovich, M. Jaime, P. G. Pagliuso, M. 

F. Hundley, J. L. Sarrao, Z. Fisk, and J. D. Thompson, 

Europhys. Lett. 53, 354 (2001). 
[6] G. Chen, S. Ohara, M. Hedo, Y. Uwatoko, K. Saito, 

M. Sorai, and I. Sakamoto, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 71, 2836 


[7] D. Kaczorowski, A. P. Pikul, D. Gnida, and V. H. Tran, 
Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 027003 (2009):i6id 104, 059702 

[8] Y. Kohori, Y. Yamato, Y. Iwamoto, T. Kohara, E. D. 
Bauer, M. B. Maple, and J. L. Sarrao: Phys. Rev. B 64 


(2001) 134526. 

[9] G.-Q. Zheng, K. Tanabe, T. Mito, S. Kawasaki, Y. Ki- 

taoka, D. Aoki, Y. Haga, and Y. Onuki, Phys. Rev. Lett. 

86, 4664 (2001). 
[10] H. Fukazawa, T. Okazaki, K. Hirayama, Y. Kohori, G. 

Chen, S. Ohara, I. Sakamoto, and T. Matusmoto, J. 

Phys. Soc. Jpn. 76 (2007) 124703. 
[11] D. Kaczorowski, A. P. Pikul, B. Belan, L. Sojka, and Ya. 

Kalychak, Physica B 404, 2975 (2009). 
[12] D. Kaczorowski, D. Gnida, A. P. Pikul, and V. H. Tran, 

Solid State Commun. 150, 411 (2010). 
[13] M. Matusiak, D. Gnida, and D. Kaczorowski, Phys. Rev. 

B 84, 115110 (2011). 
[14] D. Gnida, M. Matusiak, and D. Kaczorowski, Phys. Rev. 

B 85, 060508(R) (2012). 
[15] Y. Tokiwa, P. Gegenwart, D. Gnida, and D. Kaczorowski, 

Phys. Rev. B 84, 140507(R) (2011). 
[16] V. H. Tran, D. Kaczorowski, R. T. Khan, and E. Bauer, 

Phys. Rev. B 83, 064504 (2011). 
[17] J. K. Dong, H. Zhang, X. Qiu, B. Y. Pan, Y. F. Dai, 

T. Y. Guan, S. Y. Zhou, D. Gnida, D. Kaczorowski, and 

S.Y. Li, Phys. Rev. X 1, 011010 (2011). 
[18] K. Hashimoto et al. (unpublished). 

[19] Because the natural abundance of 113 In is 4.3% and that 
of 115 In is 95.7%, the 113 In line intensities are quite low 
(see the inset in Fig. [2]). The lines due to 113 In overlap 
with those of 115 In because the ratio of quadrupole mo- 
ments is 113 Q/ 115 <3 = 0.82/0.83. However, they can be 
identified because of this ratio and the natural-abundance 

[20] D. E. MacLaughlin, J. D. Williamson, and J. Butter- 
worth, Phys. Rev. B 4, 60 (1971). 

[21] J. Chepin and J. H. Ross, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 3, 
8103 (1991).