Skip to main content

Full text of "Narrow deeply bound $K^-$ atomic states"

See other formats


Narrow deeply bound K atomic states 



E. Friedman and A. Gal 
Racah Institute of Physics, The Hebrew University, Jerusalem 91904, Israel 

^ ; Abstract 

Using optical potentials fitted to a comprehensive set of strong interaction 
level shifts and widths in K~ atoms, we predict that the K~ atomic levels 
^^ ! which are inaccessible in the atomic cascade process are generally narrow, 

spanning a range of widths about 50 - 1500 keV over the entire periodic table. 
CN ' The mechanism for this narrowing is different from the mechanism for narrow- 

vQ ■ ing of pionic atom levels. Examples of such 'deeply bound' K atomic states 

cn ■ are given, showing that in many cases these states should be reasonably well 

^^ ! resolved. Several reactions which could be used to form these 'deeply bound' 

f^ I states are mentioned. Narrow deeply bound states are expected also in p 



0^ 






atoms. 

PACS: 21.65.+f; 36.10.Gv 

Keywords: Kaonic atoms; Deeply bound kaonic states; K^ nucleus potential 



Corresponding author: E. Friedman, 
Tel: +972 2 658 4667, Fax: +972 2 658 6347, 
S^ . E mail: elifried@vms.huji.ac.il 

February 9, 2008 



S 



The strong interaction level shifts and widths in hadronic atoms provide valuable infor- 
mation on the hadron-nucleus interaction at threshold [jl|. Radiative transitions seen in a 
typical X-ray spectrum normally terminate at a circular atomic level (n = / + 1, /) having a 
nonradiative, absorptive width of order 1-10 keV. Lower atomic levels which are inaccessible 
via the atomic cascade process are expected to be considerably broader, judging by the 2 - 
3 orders of magnitude increase in width going from (n + 1, / + 1) to (n, I). The interest in 
observing such 'deeply bound' atomic levels stems from anticipating a larger overlap of the 
corresponding wave functions with the nuclear density profile, and hence a greater sensitiv- 
ity to the hadron-nucleus strong interaction. However, once the width becomes of order 1 
MeV, it should be increasingly difficult to resolve these levels. 

To date, deeply bound hadronic atom levels have been directly observed only for pions 
0J^, using the {d,^B.e) recoilless reaction [^ on ^°^Pb, following earlier predictions that 
the Is and 2p atomic levels in pionic Pb have widths of order 0.5 MeV, significantly less 
than the approximately 1.5 MeV spacing |^^. This striking narrowness is due to the well 
established repulsive s-wave part of the pion-nucleus potential at threshold which pushes 
the corresponding atomic wave functions out of the nucleus such that their overlap with the 
nucleus, and hence with the imaginary part of the potential, is substantially reduced. A 
similar, but not as favourable situation might occur for E~ atoms due to the inner repulsion 
of the S nucleus potential 10^ • The other hadronic atom species which have been studied 
experimentally, consisting of K~ and p atoms, do not appear at first sight likely candi- 
dates for narrow deeply bound states, since the real part of the hadron-nucleus potential 
at threshold is known for these hadronic species to be strongly attractive and, furthermore, 
the imaginary (absorptive) part is particularly strong, reaching (absolute) values of order 50 
- 100 MeV inside nuclei [Q. These features of the ii'~-nucleus optical potential Vopt follow 
quahtatively from various microscopic studies of Vopt utilizing the dominant effect of the 
A(1405) subthreshold unstable bound state llO-Ol- 

In this Letter we wish to point out, for strongly absorptive potentials, a new mechanism 
for suppressing the widths of deeply bound atomic states. It is based on the observation 
made by Krell long time ago |1^ that absorptive potentials generate effective repulsion 



which pushes the wave function further outside the nucleus. We demonstrate this effect 
for realistic K~ nucleus optical potentials obtained by fitting to a comprehensive set of 
K^ atomic levels reached in atomic cascade, as deduced from K" X-ray spectra. Thus, 
we predict that K~ deeply bound atomic states, generally, are remarkably narrow and, 
therefore, warrant experimental study. 

The interaction of the K~ meson at threshold with the nucleus is described by the 
Klein-Gordon equation of the form: 

V2 - 2i2{B + Vopt + V) + (K + Bf] ^ = {n = c=l) (1) 

where fi is the K~ - nucleus reduced mass, B is the complex binding energy and Vc is 
the Coulomb interaction of the K~ with the nucleus. Only the leading term in Vopt is 
retained in Eq. (|ID. We have checked that this neglect is well justified for atomic states. 
The phenomenological density dependent (DD) potential of Friedman et al. |IU| , pD| which 
generalizes and updates Batty's earlier analysis pl|] is given by: 



2/iKp*(r) = -47r(l + £)6(p)p(r) , (2) 



h{p) = h, + B,{p^r , (3) 

Po 

where 60 and Bq are complex parameters determined from fits to the data, m is the mass 
of the nucleon and p(r) is the nuclear density distribution normalized to the number of 
nucleons A, and po =0.16 fm~^ is a typical central nuclear density. 'Macroscopic' nuclear 
densities [|l| were used in most of the present calculations. For a detailed discussion of the 
DD potentials as well as of the x^ fits to the kaonic atom data see Ref . |]1[ . Here we note 
only that the full data base for kaonic atoms, containing 65 data points over the whole of 
the periodic table, was used in the fits, which yielded x^ per point around 1.6, representing 
good fits to the data. In this work, in order to test the dependence of our predictions on the 
type of fitted potentials, we use two potentials of Table 6 in Ref. [Q . The first potential is 
of a tp form [pQ = 0.62 + zO.92 fm, Bq = 0) with depths of about 70 MeV for the (attractive) 
real part and 110 MeV for the (absorptive) imaginary part. The second potential is of a 
DD form satisfying the low density limit (with 60 given by the K~N scattering amplitude 
at threshold in free space). Its parameters (60 = —0.15 + zO.62 fm and Bq = 1.66 — z0.04 
fm, a = 0.24) produce a considerably stronger attraction in the nuclear interior, but weaker 
absorptivity than for the tp potential. Both give a good account of the K~ atomic data with 
the DD potential yielding a significantly better fit. Parameters for the density distributions 
p{r) are given in Table 2 of Ref. |2^ . 

We begin the discussion with the Is atomic state in kaonic carbon where a width of 
62 keV is calculated together with a binding energy of 270 keV, which makes this level 
resolved from the observed 2 keV broad 2p atomic level bound by 111 keV. Figure |I] shows 
the absolute value squared of the radial wave function of the Is state. The dashed curve is 
for the Coulomb interaction due to the (finite size) nuclear charge distribution and including 
also the usual vacuum polarization terms. The other curves include additional components 
of the tp potential, as obtained from fits to kaonic atom data. The solid line is for the full 
complex tp potential added, the dotted line is for adding only its imaginary part, and the 
dashed-dot curve is for adding only its real part. The results are almost indistinguishable 
if the DD potential is used instead. A striking difference compared to pionic atoms P,|^ is 
immediately clear from this figure, namely, that the strong interaction effects are completely 
dominated by the imaginary potential. The strength of the imaginary potential is such that 
the wave function is effectively excluded from the nuclear interior (r^3 fm), and the addition 
of the attractive real potential has a negligible effect on the wave function. This repulsion 
reduces sufficiently the overlap with the nucleus, and hence with Im Vopt, such that the width 
of the Is state becomes 50 times smaller than would have been the case for the Coulomb 
wave function (3.1 MeV). 

A comment on the dash-dot curve in Fig. |l] showing the wave function for Im Vopt=0 is 
in order. This wave function displays repulsion with respect to the Coulomb wave function 
shown by the dashed curve, even though Re Vopt is attractive. This phenomenon occurs in 
hadronic atoms whenever Re Vopt is deep enough to bind ntic/ear states ( [|^; see also [Q). 



Since the real atomic wave function is orthogonal to the wave functions of these deeper 
states, it develops nodes inside the nucleus. Such a node is seen in Fig. |[ These extra 
nodes, and the actual lvalue, determine the position of the main peak of the atomic wave 
function, which in the present case occurs further out than the peak of the Coulomb wave 
function, signifying repulsion. When Im Vopt is switched on to its full strength, it is clear 



from Fig. ^ that the K~ wave function gets thoroughly suppressed in the nucleus. This 
suppression depends weakly on Re Vopt-, which means that for strongly absorptive potentials 
the nuclear states affect marginally the atomic states. 

The phenomenon of well resolved deeply bound atomic states is not confined to light 
kaonic atoms but is universal all over the periodic table. Figure |^ shows the calculated 
'deeply bound' portion of the K~ atomic spectrum in Ni as a typical medium weight nucleus 
and Fig. |^ shows similar results for Pb. For these N > Z nuclei we have used neutron 
densities that slightly extend beyond those for protons, with Rn — Rp = 0.20 fm for Ni and 
0.36 fm for Pb, where Rn and Rp are the half density radius parameters. In both examples 
one sees many deep atomic levels whose widths are less than 1 MeV. Although some overlap 
is observed in the case of heavy nuclei, we note that by using /-selective reactions to populate 
such states certain levels could be expected to be reasonably well resolved. 

Further insight into the mechanism responsible for the width suppression is provided by 
Fig. ^, showing strong interaction widths and shifts for the 5g level in kaonic Pb calculated 
as a function of Im bo for the tp potential. The solid curves are for the full complex optical 
potential Vopt, whereas the dashed curves are for the imaginary part of the optical potential 
only (Re 6o = 0). The real Vc potential is included, of course, in all cases. For small values 
of Im bo, the effect of the attractive Re Vopt is to increase the width by roughly a factor of 8 
with respect to that calculated when Re Vopt is switched off. It is remarkable, however, that 
in each of these cases the width saturates such that the difference between the two calculated 
widths becomes less than 50%. This saturation and near equality of the calculated widths 
for the nominal value of Im bo is observed for other deeply bound states with different values 
of /, regardless of whether the solid curve for F lies above the dashed curve for F (as in 
Fig. ^ or below it (as is the case, for example, for the 4/ state in Pb and for the Is state 
in C discussed in connection to Fig. |I|). For the dashed curve, it is seen that the width 
saturates already at about 15% of the nominal value of Im bo, a feature which is due to 
the exclusion of the wave function from the nuclear interior. The shift in this case (with 
Re bo = 0) is repulsive. When the attractive Re Vopt is included, the (solid curve) width 
reaches a maximum at as little as 7% of the nominal depth and then begins to decrease. 
That is accompanied initially by a fairly constant repulsive shift which eventually goes down, 
remaining nevertheless repulsive. We recall that a repulsive shift due to an attractive real 
optical potential indicates the existence of deeply bound nuclear states [^ . These states, 
for the nominal value of Im bo, are very broad (F of order 50 MeV and more) and are not 
expected to be seen as well defined states. 

In order to check the sensitivity of the results to variations in the model, we have replaced 
the tp optical potential by the DD potential and found that although the spectrum of the 
deeply bound nuclear states varies considerably, the overall picture regarding the atomic 
states remains essentially unchanged. For example, the widths of the circular 1=1. ..5 levels 
in Pb change by less than 5% when the DD potential is used. Similar changes are observed in 
the calculated widths when the macroscopic densities are replaced by single particle densities 
(see Ref. |]T]]). The positions of the above levels change by less than 12 keV. The largest 
sensitivity to the potential used and to the type of nuclear density is observed for the binding 
energy of the Is level, where the variation is up to 40 keV, being however only 2.5% of the 
width of the level. We point out that the extrapolation from the atomic states observed in 
the atomic cascade process, to the 'deeply bound' atomic states, involves 6 MeV at most 



for Pb, and that no strong model dependence is expected over such an energy intervaL In 
contrast, the location of the very deep and broad nuclear states depends sensitively on the 
Vopt used. 

Before closing, we wish to mention a few candidate reactions to form K~ 'deeply bound' 
atomic states. The lesson gained from searching for such vr" states 0-0 is that a particularly 
low momentum transfer in the forward direction, say g^SO MeV/c, is necessary in order 
to achieve good angular momentum selectivity (A/ ~ qR) and to minimize the suppressive 
effects of the nuclear distortion. This calls for using as low-energy K~ beam as possible, short 
of using stopped K~ . At the AGS, however, the momentum transfer in the reaction {K~ ,p) 
for example, with a typical K~ incident momentum p^ = 600 MeV/c and for protons emitted 
in the forward direction, is already too large to be useful {q ~ 180 MeV/c). Particularly 
low-energy K~ , of kinetic energy T^- = 16 MeV, can be produced in the decay at rest of 
the <f){1020) meson. The corresponding momentum transfer in the in-flight reaction {K~ ,p), 
g ~ 50 MeV/c, is sufficiently small in this case, by far smaller for example than the value 
q ~ 110 MeV/c for the reaction (i^~, 7). Such an experiment could be planned in the e"'"-e~ 
collider DA^NE, or by using quasi free pp annihilation in a suitable facility to produce 
slow <p mesons, as considered very recently by members of the GSI collaboration looking 
for meson-nuclear bound states [^. For a 'beam' of <p mesons produced with momentum 
Pl = 262 MeV/c, it is then possible to inject strictly zero kinetic energy antikaons into a 
nuclear target by observing K~^ in the forward direction with the same momentum in the 
recoilless reaction denoted by (0, K~^). We defer a more detailed discussion of this reaction 
to a separate publication. 

In conclusion, we have shown that 'deeply bound' kaonic atom states, i.e. states which 
are inaccessible via the X-ray cascade process, are sufficiently narrow to make them well 
resolved, particularly in /-selective reactions of the type mentioned above. The mechanism 
responsible for the suppression of widths in the presence of very strong absorptive potentials 
is the effective repulsion induced by such absorptivity. The net effect is repulsion regardless 
of the presence of strongly attractive real potentials and, in fact, the energy level spectra are 
dominated by the imaginary part of the potential. The calculated 'deeply bound' atomic 
spectra are remarkably insensitive to the model used for the potential or to the model used 
for the nuclear density, provided fits are made to the data on strong interaction effects in 
'normal' kaonic atoms. Preliminary results suggest similar effects in antiprotonic atoms. 



We wish to thank A. Gillitzer, P. Kienle and T. Yamazaki for useful communications. 
This research was partially supported by the Israel Science Foundation. 



REFERENCES 

[1] C.J. Batty, E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Reports 287 (1997) 385. 

[2] T. Yamazaki et al., Z. Phys. A 355 (1996) 219. 

[3] T. Yamazaki et al, Phys. Lett. B 418 (1998) 246. 

[4] S. Hirenzaki, H. Toki, T. Yamazaki, Phys. Rev. C 44 (1991) 2472. 

[5] E. Friedman, G. Soff, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Phys. 11 (1985) L37. 

[6] H. Toki, T. Yamazaki, Phys. Lett. B 213 (1988) 129. 

[7] C.J. Batty, E. Friedman, A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 335 (1994) 273. 

[8] C.J. Batty, E. Friedman, A. Gal, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 117 (1994) 227. 

[9] J. Mares, E. Friedman, A. Gal, B.K. Jennings, Nucl. Phys. A 594 (1995) 311. 
[10] M. Alberg, E.M. Henley and L. Wilets, Ann. Phys. [NY] 96 (1976) 43. 
[11] M. Thies, Nucl. Phys. A 298 (1978) 344. 

[12] R. Brockmann, W. Weise and L. Tauscher, Nucl. Phys. A 308 (1978) 365. 
[13] M. Mizoguchi, S. Hirenzaki and H. Toki, Nucl. Phys. A 567 (1994) 893. 
[14] V. Koch, Phys. Lett. B 337 (1994) 7. 

[15] T. Waas, N. Kaiser and W. Weise, Phys. Lett. B 365 (1996) 12. 
[16] T. Waas, M Rho and W. Weise, Nucl. Phys. A 617 (1997) 449. 
[17] M. Lutz, Phys. Lett. B 426 (1998) 12. 
[18] M. Krell, Phys. Rev. Lett. 26 (1971) 584. 
[19] E. Friedman, A. Gal, C.J. Batty, Phys. Lett. B 308 (1993) 6. 
[20] E. Friedman, A. Gal, C.J. Batty, Nucl. Phys. A 579 (1994) 518. 
[21] C.J. Batty, Nucl. Phys. A 372 (1981) 418. 

[22] A. Gal, E. Friedman, C.J. Batty, Nucl. Phys. A 606 (1996) 283. 
[23] A. Gillitzer. P. Kienle, T. Yamazaki (private communication). 



FIGURES 



0.06 



CK"1s 



0.04 



DC 



0.02 




r(fm) 

FIG. 1. Absolute value squared of the Is radial wave function for kaonic atoms of C. Dashed 
curve for electromagnetic interaction only, solid curve with the full optical potential included, 
dotted curve for only the imaginary potential included and dashed dot curve for only the real 
optical potential included. 



JiK" 



-1 



> 



0) 

c 

0) 



-2 



-3 ' ^ ^ ^ ^ ' 

2 

/ values 

FIG. 2. Deeply bound levels in kaonic atoms of Ni calculated using the tp potential specified 
in the text. The bars stand for the full width T (=2 Im B) of the levels and the centers of the bars 
correspond to the energy (— Re B). 



-2 



-4 



> 

CD 



CD 

c 
CD 



-8 



-10 



PbK" 







/ value 

FIG. 3. Deeply bound levels in kaonic atoms of Pb (see caption of FIG. 2 for details). 



1000.0 



> 

CD 



CjO 
I 



100.0 



10.0 



1.0 



0.1 
0.001 








- 




Pb K" 5g 


' 


-£ 


^^x^"^---^ 


- 


- 




.-^^- 


r 
r 


/ '■ / 

/ / 
/ / 
/ / 

/ 

/ / 

/ / 

/ 

/ / 

/ / 

/ 


- 




/ 

/ 

/ 


- 




-8 ' 

1 

1 






1 
1 


^ 




1 


- 




1 


- 




1 


- 




1 
1 


- 




1 
1 


' 




1 
1 

1 
1 





1.000 



0.010 0.100 

Im bg (fm) 

FIG. 4. Strong interaction shift and width for the hg state in kaonic atoms of Pb as function 
of the imaginary part of 6o- Solid curves for the full optical potential, dashed curves for imaginary 
potential only.