Skip to main content

Full text of "USPTO Patents Application 09870801"

See other formats


IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE 


ARTHROCARE CORPORATION, 
Plaintiff, 

V. 

SMITH & NEPHEW, INC. 

Defendant. 


SMITH & NEPHEW, INC., 

Counterclaim Plaintiff, 


V. 


ARTHROCARE CORPORATION, AND 
ETHICON, INC., 

Coimteiclaim Defendants. 


C.A.No.Ol-504-SLR 


SMITH & NEPHEW^S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35 U.S-C. S 282 
Defendant Smith & Nephew, Inc. ("Smith & Nephew") hereby provides its 
written notice pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 282 of the patents and publications that it may rely 
upon to anticipate, render obvious or show the state of the art with respect to United 
States Patent No. 5,697,536 ("the '536 patent"), 5,697.882 ("the 882 patent"), and 
6,224,592 ("the '592 patent"). Smith & Nephew may also rely on the persons listed 
below as being prior inventors or having prior knowledge of or as having previously used 
or ofieied for sale the inventions of the patents-in-suit. Smith & Nephew also 
incorporates by reference the items set forth in its responses to Plaintiffs Interrogatories 
and in the expert reports of Dr. Kenneth Taylor, Dr. Michael Choti, Dr. Kim Manwaring 
and Ronald Panitch, Esq. 


Furthermore, in light of the recent filings by the parties on proposed claim 
construction, Smith & Nephew reserves the right to further supplement this notice 
depending on the Court's ruling on claim construction and/or possible new claim 
constructions. 


I. PRIMARY REFERENCES RELIED UPON 


A- PATENTS 



CoaDtry 



N^eoC^ateatee 

(I) 

US 

2,056,377 

10/6/36 

Wappler 

(2) 

US 

3,815,604 

06/11/74 

O'Malleyet al. 

<3) 

us 

3,828,780 

8/13/74 

Morrison, Jr. 

<4) 

us 

3,901,242 

8/26/75 

Storz 

(5) 

us 

3,920,021 

11/18/75 

Hiltibrandt 

(6) 

us 

3,939,839 

2/24/76 

Curtiss 

(7) 

us 

3,970,088 

7/20/76 

Morrison 

(8) 

FR 

2,313,949 

1/7/77 

Hiltibrandt, et al. 


No. 76 17587 



(9) 

us 

4,074,718 

2/21/78 

Morrison, Jr. 

<10) 

US 

4,092,986 

6/6/78 

Schneiderman 

(11) 

us 

4,116,198 

9/26/78 

Roos 

<12) 

US 

4,181,131 

1/1/80 

Hisao Ogiu 

(13) 

us 

4,184,492 

1/22/80 

Meinke et al. 

(14) 

us 

4,232,676 

11/11/80 

Herczog 

(15) 

us 

4,248,231 

2/3/81 

Herczog et al. 

(16) 

us 

4,326,529 

4/27/82 

Doss et al. 

(17) 

us 

4.381,007 

4/26/83 

Doss 

(18) 

us 

4.548,207 

10/22/85 

Reimels 

(19) 

us 

4.590,934 

5/27/86 1 

Mails etal. 

(20) 

us 

4.660,571 

4/28/87 

Hess et al. 

(21) 

us 

4.674,499 

6/23/87 

Pao 

(22) 

us 

4.785.823 

11/22/88 

Eggers et al. 

(23) 

us 

4.805.616 

2/21/89 

Pao 

(24) 

us 

4,823,791 

4/25/89 

D'Amelio et al. 

(25) 

us 

4,832,048 

5/23/89 

Cohen 

(26) 

wo 

90/03152 

4/5/90 

Considine et al. 

(27) 

us 

4.920.978 

5/1/90 

Colvin 

(28) 

us 

4,931.047 

6/5/90 

Broadwin et aL 

(29) 

us 

4,936.281 

6/26/90 

Stasz 

(30) 

us 

4,966,587 

10/30/90 

Cosman 

(31) 

us 

4,976.711 

12/11/90 

Parins et al. 


2 



Country 

Patent No. 

Date 

Name of Patentee 

(32) 

US 

4,979.948 

12/25/90 

Geddes et al. 

(33) 

DE 

3930451 Al 

3/21/91 

Hoffmann et al. 

(34) 

US 

5,007,908 

4/16/91 

Rydell 

(35) 

US 

5,009,656 

4/23/91 

Reimels 

(36) 

us 

5.035,696 

7/30/91 

Rydell 

(37) 

us 

5,047,026 

9/10/91 

Rydell 

(38) 

us 

5,047,027 

9/10/91 

Rydell 

(39) 

us 

5,080,660 

1/14/92 

Buelna 

(40) 

us 

5,084,044 

1/28/92 

Quint 

(41) 

us 

5,085,659 

2/4/92 

Rydell 

(42) 

us 

5,088,997 

2/18/92 

Delahuerga et al. 

(43) 

us 

5,098,431 

3/24/92 

Rydell 

(44) 

us 

5,108,391 

4/28/92 

Flachenecker et al. 

(45) 

us 

5,112,330 

5/12/92 

Nishigake et al. 

(46) 

us 

5,122,138 

6/16/92 

Manwaring 

(47) 

us 

5,167,659 

12/1/92 

Ohtomo et al. 

(48) 

us 

5,171,311 

12/15/92 

Rydell et al. 

(49) 

us 

5,197.963 

3/30/93 

Parins 

(50) 

us 

5,207.675 

5/4/93 

Canady 

(51) 

us 

5.217,459 

6/8/93 

Kamerhng 

(52) 

us 

5.306,238 

4/26/94 

Fleenor 

(53) 

us 

5.432,882 

6/13/95 

Jackman et al. 

(54) 

us 

5,454,809 

10/3/95 

Janssen 

(55) 

us 

5,4%,314 

3/5/96 

Eggers 


B. PUBLICATIONS 





^Sbarce & P4iEe?N«Sv 


(1) 

Leonard I. 
Malis, M.D. 

Bipolar Coagulation in 
Microsurgery 

Microvascular 
Surgery, 126-131 

1967 

(2) 

A.K. Dobbie 

The Electrical Aspects of 
Surgical Diathermy 

Bio-Medical 
Engineering 206-2 1 6 

5/69 

(3) 

Honig 

The Mechanism of 
Cutting in Electrosurgery 

IEEE Transactions On 

Biomedical 

Engineering 

1/75 

(4) 

Elasserand 
Roos 

Uber ein Instrument zur 
leckstromfreien 
transiu-ethralen Resection 
(ConcCTiing An 
Instrument for 
Transurethral Resection 
Without Leakage of 
Current) 

Acta Medicotechnica 
(Medizinal-Markt), 
Vol, 24, No. 4, 129-134 

1976 


3 



Author 

Article Title 

Source & Page Nos« 

Date 

(5) 

Piercey, 
M..D., et al. 

Electrosurgical 
Treatment of 
Experimental Bleeding 
Canine Gastric Ulcers: 
Development and testing 
of a computer control 
and a better electrode 

Gastroenterology^ Vol. 
74, No. 3, 527-534 

1978 

(6) 

Dennis et al. 

Evolutions of 
Electrofulguration in 
Control of Bleeding of 
Experimental CJastric 
Ulcers 

Digestive Diseases and 
Sciences, Vol. 24, No. 
11,845-848 

11/79 

(7) 

Barry MS et 
al. 

The effect of 
radiofrequency-generated 
thermal energy on the 
mechanical and 
histologic characteristic 
of the arterial wall in 
vivo: Implications for 
radiofirequency 
angioplasty 

CRC Press, American 
Heart Journal, Vol, 
117*332-341 

2/82 

(8) 

Swain et al. 

Which Electrode? A 
comparison of four 
endoscopic methods of 
electrocoagulation in 
experimental bleeding 
ulcers 

Gm/,25, 1424-1431 

1984 

(9) 

Robert G, 
Britain 

Letter from Department 
of Health and Human 
Services to Jerry L. 
Malis 


4/15/85 

(10) 

Slager et al. 

Vaporization of 
Atherosclerotic Plaques 
by Spailc Erosion 

y^CCVol. 5, No. 6, 
1382-6 

6/85 

(11) 

Jerry L. Malis 

Letter from Jerry L. 
Malis to Food and Drug 
Administration 


7/25/85 

(12) 

Ramsay etal. 

A Comparison of Bipolar 
and Monopolar 
Diathermy Probes in 
Experimental Animals 

Urological Research 
13:99-102 

1985 

(13) 

Leonard L 
Malis, M J). 

Instrumentation for 

Microvascular 

Neurosiu-gery 

Cerebrovascular 
Surgery, Vol 1,245- 
260. 

1985 



Author 

Article Title 

Source & Page Nos. 

Date 

(14) 

Leonard L 
Malis, M.D. 

Acoustic Neuroma 
Surgery 


1987 

(15) 

Slager et al. 

Spark Erosion of 
Ajteriosclerotic Plaques 

Kardiologie, 
KardioL16: Supp. 6, 
67-71 (1987) 

1987 

(16) 

Valleylab, 
Inc. 

Surgistat Service Manual 

Valleylab Part Number 
945 100 102 A 

7/88 

(17) 

Leonard I. 
Malis, M.D. 

New Trends in 
Microsurgery and 
Applied Technology 

Advanced Technology 
in Neurosurgery^ 1-16. 

1988 

(18) 

Nardella 

Radio Frequency Energy 
and Impedance Feedback 

SPIEVol. 1068 
Catheter-based Sensing 
and Imaging 
Technology 

1989 

(19) 

Tucker et al. 

A Bipolar Electrosurgical 
Turp Loop 

The Organizing 
Committee of the 
World Congress on 
Endourology and 
ESWL Foundation for 
Advancement of 
International Science 

1989 

(20) 

Tucker et al. 

A Comparison of 
Urologic Application of 
Bipolar Versus 
Monopolar Five French 
Electrosurgical Probes 

Journal of Urology 
Vol 141, 662-665 

3/89 

(21) 

Lee et al. 

Thennal Compression 
and Molding of 
Atherosclerotic Vascular 
Tissue With Use of 
Radiofirequency Energy: 
Implications for 
Radiofrequency Balloon 
Angioplasty 

JACCVoX. 13 No. 5, 
1167-75 

4/89 

(22) 

Tucker et al. 

In vivo effect of 5 French 
bipolar and monopolar 
electrosurgical probes on 
the porcine bladder 

Urological Research 
18, 291-294 

1990 

(23) 

Kramoiowsky 
et al. 

UseofSF Bipolar 
Electrosurgical Probe in 
Endoscopic Urolog^cal 
Procedures 

Journal of Urology 
Vol. 143, 275-277 

2/90 

(24) 

Kramoiowsky 
etal. 

The Urological 
^plication of 
Electrosurgery 

Journal of Urology 
Vol, 146, 669 

9/91 


5 



Author 

Article Title 

Source & Page Nos. 

Date 

(25) 

Douglas 0. 
Olsen, M.D. 

Bipolar Laparoscopic 
Cholecystectomy 

Bipolar Laparoscopic 
Cholecystectomy 
Lecture & Videotape 

10/7/91 

(26) 

Carl A. 
Larson 

Letter fi^om Department 
of Health and Human 
Services to Jerry L. 
Malis 


4/22/91 

(27) 

Codman& 
ShuitlefF, Inc. 

The Malis Bipolar 
Electrosurgical System 
CMC - in Instruction 
Manual 


7/91 

(28) 


Valley Forge's new 
products 

CLINICA,475,5 

11/6/91 

(29) 

Valley Forge 

Scientific 

Corp. 

Summary of Safety and 
Effective Information 
ftomSlOK 


At least as 
early as 
1991. 

(30) 

Codman & 
Shurtleff, Inc. 

The Malis Bipolar 
Coagulating and Bipolar 
Cutting System CMC-II 
brochure 


At least as 
early as 
1991 

(31) 

Leonard L 
Malis, M.D. 

The Value of Irrigation 
During Bipolar 
Coagulation 

feeARTC 21602 

At least as 
early as 
4/9/93 

(32) 

ArthroCare 

ArthroCare Sept 93 
Investor Video 

/■ 

9/24/93 

(33) 

Leonard L 
Malis, M.D. 

New Trends in 
Microsurgery and 
Applied Technology 

&eARTC21596- 
21600 

At least as 
early as 
4/9/93 

(34) 

Leonard L 
Malis, MX). 

Excerpted from a 
seminar by Leonard I. 
Malis, M.D.atthe 1995 
American Association of 
Neurological Surgeons 
Meeting 


1995 

(35) 

Leonard! 
MaUs,MX>. 

Electrosurgery, 
Technical Note 

J. Neursurg., Vol. 85, 
970-975. 

11/96 

(36) 

Ian E. 

Shuman, 

DDS,FAGD 

Bipolar Versus 
Monopolar 

Electrosurgery: Clinical 
Applications 

Dentistry Today iWo\. 
20, No. 12 

12/01 


6 


II. REFERENCES LISTED ON THE PATENTS-IN-SUIT 


A. PATENTS 



Country 

Patent No. 

Date 

Name of Patentee 

(») 

US 

2,050,904 

08/11/36 

Trice 

(2) 

US 

4.033.351 

ovosm 

Hetzel 

(3) 

US 

4.040,426 

08/09/77 

Morrison,'Jr. 

(4) 

us 

4,043,342 

08/23/77 

Morrison, Jr 

(5) 

us 

4,202337 

05/13/80 

Hren et al. 

(6) 

us 

4,228,800 

10/21/80 

Degler, Jr. et al. 

(7) 

us 

4,240,441 

12/23/81 

Khalil 

(8) 

us 

4,476,862 

10/16/84 

Pao 

(9) 

us 

4,532,924 

08/06/85 

Auth et al. 

(10) 

us 

4,567,890 

02/04/86 

Onta et at. 

00 

us 

4,593,691 

06/10/86 

Lindstrom et al. 

(12) 

us 

4,658,817 


Hardy 

(13) 

us 

4,682,596 

01I2%I%1 

Bales et al. 

(14) 

us 

4,706,667 

11/17/87 

Roos 

(15) 

us 

4,709,698 

12/16/87 

Johnston et al. 

(16) 

us 

4,727,874 

03/01/88 

Bowers et al. 

(17) 

us 

4,736,743 

04/12/88 

Daikuzono 

(18) 

us 

4,737,678 

04/12/88 

Hasegawa 

(19) 

us 

4,762,128 

08/09/88 

Rosenbluth 

(20) 

us 

4,765.331 

08/23/88 

Petruzzi et al. 

(21) 

us 

4,785,806 

11/22/88 

Deckelbaum 

(22) 

us 

4,813,429 

QfiiniZ9 

Eshel et al. 

(23) 

us 

4,860,752 

08/29/89 

Turner 

(24) 

us 

4,936,301 

06/26/90 

Rexroth et al. 

(25) 

us 

4,943,290 

QlllAm 

Rexroth et al. 

(26) 

us 

4,955,377 

09/11/90 

Lennox et al. 

(27) 

us 

4,967,765 

11/06/90 

Turner et al. 

(28) 

us 

4,968,314 

11/06/90 

Michaels 

(29) 

us 

4,998,933 

03/12/91 

Eggers et al. 

(30) 

us 


04/16/91 

oterzer 

(31) 

us 

5,037,421 

08/06/91 

BoutacofTet al. 

(32) 

us 

5,057,105 

10/15/91 

Malone et al. 

(33) 

us 

5,057,106 

10/15/91 

Kasevich et al. 

(34) 

us 

5,061,266 

10/29/91 

Hakky 

(35) 

us 

5,078,717 

01/07/92 

Parinsetal. 

(36) 

us 

5,083,565 

01/28/92 

Farms 

(37) 

us 

5,102,410 

04/07/92 

Dressel 

(38) 

us 

5,125,928 

06/30/92 

Parinset al. 

(39) 

us 

5,147,354 

09/15/92 

BoutacofTet al. 


7 



Country 

Patent No. 

Date 

Name of Patentee 

(40) 

US 

5,151,098 

09/29/92 

Loertscher 

(41) 

US 

5,176,528 

01/05/93 

Fry et al. 

(42) 

us 

5,178,620 

01/12/93 

Eggers et al. 

(43) 

us 

5,190,517 

03/02/93 

Zieve et al 

(44) 

us 

5,192,280 

03/09/93 

Parins 

(45) 

us 

5,195,959 

03/23/93 

Smith 

(46) 

us 

5,217,455 

06/08/93 

Tan 

(47) 

us 

5,217,457 

06/08/93 

Delahuerga et al. 

(48) 

us 

5,249,585 

10/05/93 

Turner et al. 

(49) 

us 

5,261,410 

11/16/93 

Alfano et al. 

(50) 

us 

5,267,994 

12/07/93 

Genteliaet al. 

<5l) 

us 

5,267,997 

12/07/93 

Farin et al. 

(52) 

us 

5,273,524 

12/28/93 

Fox et al. 

(53) 

us 

5,277,201 

01/11/94 

Stem 

(54) 

us 

5,281,216 

01/25/94 

Klicek 

(55) 

us 

5,281,218 

01/25/94 

Imran 

(56) 

us 

5,282,797 

02/01/94 

Chess 

(57) 

us 

5,290,273 

03/01/94 

Tan 

(60) 

us 

5,290,282 

03/01/94 

Casscells 

(61) 

us 

5,300,069 

04/05/94 

Hunsberger et al 

(62) 

us 

5,300,099 

04/05/94 

Rudie 

(63) 

us 

5,301,687 

04/12/94 

Wong et al. 

(64) 

us 

5,304.170 

04/19/94 

Green 

(65) 

us 

5,312,395 

05/17/94 

Tan et al. 

(66) 

us 

5,312,400 

05/17/94 

Bales et al. 

(67) 

us 

5,314,406 

05/24/94 

Arias et al. 

(68) 

us 

5,318,563 

06/07/94 

Malis et al. 

(69) 

us 

5,322,507 

06/21/94 

Costello et al. 

(70) 

us 

5,324,254 

06/28/94 

Phillips 

(71) 

us 

5,326.343 

07/05/94 

Rudie et al. 

(72) 

us 

5330.470 

07/19/94 

Hagen 

(73) 

us 

5,330,518 

07/19/94 

Neilson et al. 

(74) 

us 

5,334,140 

08/02/94 

Phillips 

(75) 

us 

5334,183 

08/02/94 

Wuchinich 

(76) 

us 

5336.217 

08/09/94 

Buys et al. 

(77) 

us 

5.336.220 

08/09/94 

Ryan et al. 

(78) 

us 

5.342357 

08/30/94 

Nardella 

(79) 

us 

5.366.443 

11/22/94 

Eggers et al. 

(80) 

us 

5370.642 

12/06/94 

Keller 

(81) 

us 

5,370.675 

12/04/94 

Edwards et ai. 

(82) 

us 

5380.277 

12/06/94 

PhiUips 

(83) 

us 

5380316 

01/10/95 

Aita et al. 

(84) 

us 

5383,876 

01/24/95 

Nardella 

(85) 

us 

5383,917 

01/95 

Desai elal. 


8 



Country 

Patent No. 

Date 

Name of Patentee 

(86) 

US 

5,389,096 

02/14/95 

Aita et al. 

(87) 

US 

5,395,312 

03/07/95 

Desai 

(88) 

us 

5,417,687 

05/23/95 

Nardella et al. 

(89) 

us 

5,419,767 

05/30/95 

Eggers et al. 

(90) 

us 

5,423,803 

06/13/95 

Tankovich et al. 

(91) 

us 

5.441,499 

08/15/95 

Fritzsch 

(92) 

us 

5,445,634 

08/29/95 

Keller 

(93) 

us 

5,496,312 

03/05/96 

KJicek 

(94) 

us 

5,514,130 

05/07/96 

Baker 

(95) 

us 

5,556,397 

09/17/96 

Long et al. 

(96) 

us 

5,569,242 

10/29/96 

Lax et al. 

(97) 

us 

5,584,872 

12/17/96 

LaFontaine et al. 

(98) 

us 

5,609,151 

03/11/97 

MuHer et al. 

(99) 

us 

5,647,869 

07/15/97 

Goble et al. 

(100) 

us 

5,676,693 

10/14/97 

LaFontaine 

(101) 

us 

5,681,282 

10/28/97 

Eggers et al. 

(102) 

us 

5,683,366 

11/04/97 

Eggers et al. 

(103) 

us 

5,697,281 

12/16/97 

Eggers et al. 

(104) 

us 

5,697.536 

12/16/97 

Eggers et al. 

(105) 

us 

5,697,882 

12/16/97 

Eggers et al. 

(106) 

us 

5,697,909 

12/16/97 

Eggers et al. 

(107) 

us 

5,700,262 

12/23/97 

Acosta et al. 

(108) 

us 

5,725,524 

03/10/98 

Mulier et al. 

(109) 

us 

5,749,869 

05/12/98 

Lindenmeier et al. 

(110) 

us 

5,766,153 

06/16/98 

Eggers et al. 

(111) 

us 

5,807,395 

09/15/98 

Mulier et al. 

(112) 

us 

5,810,764 

09/22/98 

Eggers et al. 

(113) 

us 

5,860,974 

01/19/99 

Abele 

(114) 

us 

5.871,524 

02/16/99 

Knowlton 

(115) 

us 

5.885,277 

03/23/99 

Korth 

(116) 

us 

5,891,095 

04/06/99 

Eggers et al. 

(117) 

us 

5.897,553 

04/27/99 

Mulier et al. 

(118) 

us 

5,902,272 

05/11/99 

Eggers et al. 

(119) 

us 

5,944,715 

08/31/99 

Goble et al. 

(120) 

us 

6.004,319 

12/21/99 

Goble et al. 

(121) 

us 

6.013.076 

l/ll/OO 

Goble et al. 

(122) 

us 

6,015,406 

1/18/00 

Goble et al. 

(123) 

us 

6.027,501 

2/22/00 

Goble et al. 

(124) 

us 

6,039,734 

3/21/00 

Goble 

(125) 

us 

6,056,746 

5/2/00 

Goble et al. 

(126) 

EP 

515 867 

12/2/92 

Valluvan 

(127) 

EP 

0597 463 

5/18/94 

TiemeyetaL 

(128) 

EP 

0 703 461 A2 

3/27/96 

Yates 

(129) 

EP 

0 740 926 

11/6/96 

WurzCT et al. 


9 



Country 

Patent No. 

Date 

Name of Patentee 

(130) 

EP 

0 740 926 A2 

1 1/6/96 

Wurzer et al. 

<131) 

EP 

0 754 437 

1/22/97 

Goble et al. 

(132) 

GB 

2327350 

1/99 

Goble et al. 

(133) 

GB 

2327351 

1/99 

Goble et al. 

(134) 

GB 

2327352 

1/99 

Goble et al. 

(135) 

JP 

57-57802 

4/82 

Inoue Kiyoshi 

(136) 

JP 

57-117843 

7/82 

Nakano Yukiyoshi, Matsuura 
Masaaki 

(137) 

WO 

90/07303 

7/12/90 

Janssen 

(138) 

WO 

90/09303 

7/90 

Dare-Bryan et al. 

(139) 

WO 

91/13650 

9/19/91 

Cathaud 

(140) 

WO 

92/21278 

12/10/92 

Edwards et al. 

(141) 

WO 

93/13816 

7/22/93 

Eggers et al. 

(142) 

WO 

93/20747 

10/28/93 

Rosar et al. 

(143) 

WO 

94/04220 

3/3/94 

Edwards et al. 

(144) 

WO 

94/08654 

4/28/94 

Beuchat et al. 

(145) 

WO 

94/14383 

7/4/94 

Rudko 

(146) 

WO 

94/14386 

7/4/94 

Day 

(147) 

WO 

94/26228 

11/24/94 

Eggers et al. 

(148) 

WO 

95/34259 

12/21/95 

Desai 

(149) 

WO 

96/00042 

1/4/96 

Edwards et al. 

(150) 

WO 

97/00646 

1/9/97 

Goble et al. 

(151) 

WO 

97/647 

1/9/97 

Goble et al. 

(152) 

wo 

97/24073 

7/97 

Goble et aL 

(153) 

wo 

97/24993 

7/17/97 

Goble et al. 

(154) 

wo 

97/24994 

7/17/97 

Goble et al. 

(155) 

wo 

97/48346 

12/97 

Goble et al. 

(156) 

wo 

97/48345 

12/97 

Goble et al. 

(157) 

wo 

98/27879 

7/98 

Odelletal. 

(158) 

wo 

98/27880 

7/2/98 

Goble 

(159) 

wo 

99/51155 

10/14/99 

Goddard et al. 

(160) 

wo 

99/51158 

10/14/99 

Goddard et al. 


B. PUBLICATIONS 







(1) 

Rand et al. 

Eflfect of Electrocautery 
on Fresh Human 
Articular Cartilage 

Journal of 

Arthroscopic 

Surgery 

1985 

(2) 

Pearcc 


Electrosurgery, pp. 
17, 69-75. 87 

1986 

(3) 

Buechelt et al. 

Excimer laser ablation of 
fibrocartilage: an in vitro 
and in vivo study 

Lasers in Surg^y 
and Medicine 
11:271-279 

1991 


10 



Author 

Article TiUe 

Scarce & Page Nos. 

Date 

(4) 

Costello 

Nd: YAG lasser ablation 
of the prostate as a 
treatment for benign 
prostatic hypertrophy 

Lasers in Surgery 
and Medicine 
12:121-124 

1992 


III. Public Domain Books 

B. PUBLICATIONS 



Author 


Date 


<1) 

John A. Pierce 

Electrosurgery 

1986 

1.25L 


rV. Individuals 

(1) Eberhard Roos 

Address: Ing,VDI Eberhard Roos 

Semmelweisstr, 1 
D 78532 Tuttlingen 
GERMANY 

Declaration: Declaration of Eberhard Roos 2/1 1/2003. 

(2) Dr. Kim H. Manwaring 

Address: Phoenix Children's Hospital 
1919 E Thomas Road 
Phoenix, Arizona 85016-7710 

(3) Dr. Kenneth Taylor, 

Address: 375 Golden Eagle Drive 
Broomfield. CO 80020 

(4) Dr. Michael Choti, 

Address: 600 North Wolfe Street, Halsted 614 
Baltimore, Maryland 21287-5614 


11 


(5) Jerry L. Maiis 


Address: 1 36 Green Tree Road 
Oaks, PA 19456 

(6) Dr. David Present 

Address: Unknown 


(7) Ginger More 

Address: Unknown 

(8) Leonard I. Malis, M.D. 

Address: Street Address Unknown 
New York City, NY 

Dated: March 28, 2003 FISH & RICHARDSON P.C. 


WilUam J. MSrsden. J\(#224 
Keith A. Wah^Jr. (#4J57) 
Eugene B. JoswicKt#4271) 
919 N. Market Street, Suite 1 100 
P.O. Box 11 14 

Wihnington, DE 19899-1114 
Telephone: (302)652-5070 
Facsimile: (302) 652-0607 


MarkJ.Hebert 
Thomas M. Johnston 
225 Franklm Street 
Boston, MA 02110-2804 
Telephone: (617) 542-5070 
Facsimile: (617) 542-8906 

Kurtis D. MacFerrin 
500 Arguello Street, Suite 500 
Redwood City, CaUfomia 94063 
Telephone: (650) 839-5070 
Facsimile: (650) 839-5071 


Attorneys for Defendant 
SMITH & NEPHEW, INC. 


12 


CERTinCATE OF SERVICE 


I hereby certify that on this 28* day of March, 2003, a true and correct copy of the 
SMITH & NEPHEW'S NOTICE PURSUANT TO 35. U.S.C. § 282 was caused to be 
served on the attorneys of record at the following addresses as indicated: 


BY HAND DELIVERY Attorney for Plaintiff 

Jack B. Blumenfeld, Esq. Arthrocare Corporation 

Morris, Nichols, Arsht & Tunnell 
1201 North Market Street 
P.O. Box 1347 
Wilmington, DE 19899-1347 


BY FACSIMILE AND Attorneys for Plaintiffs 

FEDERAL EXPRESS Arthrocare 

Matthew D. Powers, Esq. 

Jared Bobrow 

Perry Claik, Esquire 

Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP 

201 Redwood Shores Parkway 

Redwood Shores, CA 94065 


BY HAND DELIVERY 

Steven J. Balick, Esq. 

Ashby & Geddes 

222 Delaware Avenue, 17th Floor 

P.O. Box 1150 

Wibnington, DE 19899 


Attorney for PlaintifCCounterclaim 

Defendant 

Ethicon, Inc. 


20S70296J4ioc 



I 


(ojdsn) )|UD|g eBod Sjm